In the table below, red is in the WG decision column indicates that the Working Group didn't agree with the comment, green indicates that a it agreed with it, and yellow reflects an in-between situation.
In the "Commentor reply" column, red indicates the commenter objected to the WG resolution, green indicates approval, and yellow means the commenter didn't respond to the request for feedback.
| Commentor | Comment | Working Group decision | Commentor reply |
|---|---|---|---|
LC-2945
Lisa Seacat DeLuca <ldeluca@us.ibm.com> (archived comment) |
|
Proposed resolution, accepted on teleconference 7 August 2014: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2014Aug/0000.html minutes: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2014Aug/att-0014/minutes-2014-08-07.html#item03 Change section 4 (Vibration Interface) Step 9.2 [1] from "If pattern is an empty list, or if the device is unable to vibrate, then return true and terminate these steps.“ to "If pattern is an empty list, a list containing a single vibration entity with max duration of 0, or if the device is unable to vibrate, then return true and terminate these steps.“ I would categorize this change as editorial, since having a max duration of 0 could be interpreted as the ‘device is unable to vibrate”, however I think a clarification could be helpful and be incorporated as part of the process of creating a CR publication draft. |
yes |