Edit comment LC-1978 for Mobile Web Best Practices Working Group

Quick access to LC-1978 LC-1979 LC-1980 LC-1981 LC-1991 LC-1992 LC-2159

Comment LC-1978

Comment Shortname:

Commenter: Dominique Hazael-Massieux <dom@w3.org>

Message-id:

Section of the document concerned:

[Free text description]Document as a wholeW3C mobileOK Basic Tests 1.0 W3C Working Draft 10 June 2008 Abstract Status of this Document Table of Contents Appendices 1 Introduction 1.1 Levels of mobileOK 1.1.1 mobileOK Basic 1.1.2 mobileOK Pro 1.1.3 Out of Scope 1.1.4 Beyond mobileOK 1.2 Applicability 1.3 Claiming mobileOK conformance 2 Conformance 2.1 Use of Terms must, should etc. 2.2 Validity of the Tests 2.3 Testing Outcomes 2.4 Conduct of Tests 2.4.1 Order of Tests 2.4.2 HTTP Request 2.4.3 HTTP Response 2.4.4 Meta http-equiv Elements 2.4.5 CSS Style 2.4.6 Included Resources 2.4.7 Linked Resources 2.4.8 Validity 2.4.9 White Space 3 mobileOK Basic Tests 3.1 AUTO_REFRESH and REDIRECTION 3.2 CACHING 3.3 CHARACTER_ENCODING_SUPPORT and CHARACTER_ENCODING_USE 3.4 CONTENT_FORMAT_SUPPORT and VALID_MARKUP Note: In the following, an "html document" is a document th... Note: In the following, "regardless of its stated DOCTYPE"... Note: In the following, "a known XHTML version" means XHTML... 3.5 DEFAULT_INPUT_MODE 3.6 EXTERNAL_RESOURCES 3.7 GRAPHICS_FOR_SPACING 3.8 IMAGE_MAPS 3.9 IMAGES_RESIZING and IMAGES_SPECIFY_SIZE 3.10 LINK_TARGET_FORMAT 3.11 MEASURES 3.12 MINIMIZE 3.13 NO_FRAMES 3.14 NON-TEXT_ALTERNATIVES 3.15 OBJECTS_OR_SCRIPT 3.15.1 Object Element Processing Rule 3.16 PAGE_SIZE_LIMIT 3.17 PAGE_TITLE 3.18 POP_UPS 3.19 PROVIDE_DEFAULTS 3.20 STYLE_SHEETS_SUPPORT 3.21 STYLE_SHEETS_USE 3.22 TABLES_ALTERNATIVES 3.23 TABLES_LAYOUT 3.24 TABLES_NESTED A Acknowledgments (Non-Normative) B References (Non-Normative) BestPractices CSS GIF JPEG POWDER RFC 2119 RFC 2616 RFC 2617 Techniques UTF-8 WCAG XHTMLBasic11 XHTMLModularization XML10 XML11 C Relationship between Best Practices and mobileOK Tests (Non-Normative)
or

Refinement of the section concerned:

Status:

open proposal pending resolved_yes resolved_no resolved_partial other assigned to Nobody

Type: substantive editorial typo question general comment undefined

Resolution status:

Response drafted Resolution implemented Reply sent to commenter

Response status:

No response from Commenter yet Commenter approved disposition Commenter objected to disposition
Commenter's response (URI):

Comment:

* when analyzing external resources (in ContentFormatSupport,
PageSizeLimit, ExternalResources), the objects and images that are set
as fallback of an object that is in an acceptable format shouldn't be
counted. For instance,
<object data="myimage.gif"><img src="myimage.png" alt=""/></object>
shouldn't trigger an error in ContentFormatSupport, the weight of
myimage.png shouldn't be counted in PageSizeLimit and ExternalResources

Related issues: (space separated ids)

WG Notes: Propose to resolve "yes".

Resolution: We agree that the "myimage.png" should not trigger a CONTENT_FORMAT_SUPPORT error, and should not be taken into account in PAGE_SIZE_LIMIT and EXTERNAL_RESOURCES. This is triggered by the note in 2.4.6 Included Resources: "object elements that are accessed in order to test their Content-Type HTTP header, but do not form part of the ultimate representation of the resource under test (see 3.15 OBJECTS_OR_SCRIPT ), are not considered to be included resources". We agree that the notion of "ultimate representation of the resource" deserves to be clarified though and the note extended to resources retrieved by section 3.15.1 Object Element Processing Rule. On the light of the discussion that followed your other comment (LC-1980) on the use of the HTTP Content-Type value to taste object element, we updated the note to specify that only resources retrieved under the 3.15.1 Object Element Processing Rule whose Content-Type is image/gif or image/jpeg are considered to be Included Resources: http://www.w3.org/2005/MWI/BPWG/Group/Drafts/mobileOK-Basic-1.0-Tests/080707r#included_resources

(Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)