"Web Services Policy 1.5 - Framework" and "Web Services Policy 1.5 - Attachment" Disposition of Comments

This is the Disposition of Comments for the 11 November 2006 Last Call of the Web Services Policy 1.5 - Framework and Web Services Policy 1.5 - Attachment specifications. This document lists the comments received on the Last Call specifications and the extent to which the Web Services Policy Working Group believes they have been addressed.

Last update: 2007-02-15.

1. Overview of Comments

Total number of comments: 37

1.1 Reaction of the Working Group and (dis)satisfaction of the Reviewer

-	Reviewer satisfied	Reviewer not satisfied	No reply from reviewer
WG accepted comment	35	0	0
WG rejects comment	2	0	0

1.2 List of Comments per Category

The reviewer is not satisfied with the response of the Working Group.

Total number: 0.
The reviewer is satisfied with the response of the Working Group.

Total number: 37 (100%).

4038 4039 4042 4068 4128 4129 4130 4138 4141 4142 4150 4177 4178 4179 4188 4195 4196 4197 4203 4204 4205 4206 4207 4209 4210 4211 4224 4225 4226 4230 4235 4236 4238 4240 4254 4306 4307
The Working Group declined to implement the change which the reviewer requested.

Total number: 2 (5.41%).

4178 4179
The reviewer did not respond to the decision of the Working Group.

Total number: 0.
The Working Group has accepted the proposal of the reviewer.

Total number: 35 (94.59%).

4038 4039 4042 4068 4128 4129 4130 4138 4141 4142 4150 4177 4188 4195 4196 4197 4203 4204 4205 4206 4207 4209 4210 4211 4224 4225 4226 4230 4235 4236 4238 4240 4254 4306 4307

The following comments are from reviewers who are not participating in the Working Group: 4210 4211

1.3 Non-editorial Changes in the Draft

To implement the comment, the Working Group made a non-editorial change to the specification. Nevertheless, the Working Group believes that the change does not invalidate previous reviews of the draft or implementation experiences, since no new concept was introduced, and no existing concept was modified.

Total number: 0.

2. Detailed Description of Comments

4038: Nested policy in normal form - Example does not match expectations

First recorded: 2006-12-06

Last modified: 2006-12-14

Last modification: Hi Paul, I agree with this resolution. Thanks, David

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4039: WS-Policy does not define its relationship to XML Base

First recorded: 2006-12-06

Last modified: 2006-12-13

Last modification: Resolved on Dec 13 based on proposal in: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2006Dec/0040.html The proposal was amended to include the following text: "This document does not define a base URI but relies on the mechanisms defined in XML Base [XML Base] and RFCs 3023 [RFC3023], 3986 [RFC 3986] and 3987 [RFC 3987] for establishing a base URI against which relative IRIs can be made absolute." See: http://www.w3.org/2006/12/13-ws-policy-irc#T17-45-16 /paulc

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4042: Editorial fix to Media type description

First recorded: 2006-12-06

Last modified: 2006-12-06

Last modification: Title: Editorial fix to Media type description Target: Framework Document, sec. "A. The application/wspolicy+xml Media Type" Description: See request from Mark Backer to change the MAC file type code at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy-comments/2006Dec/0001.html . Working Group agreed with the proposal at http://www.w3.org/2006/12/06-ws-policy-minutes.html , see "note from mark baker". Felix

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4068: XML Schema does not allow for validating xml:id in policy documents

First recorded: 2006-12-11

Last modified: 2006-12-13

Last modification: The WG chose option c) from: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2006Dec/0029.html >c) delete the explicit reference to <xs:attribute ref="wsu:Id"/> . Additional changes to the RDDL file and WG home page were identified in this thread: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2006Dec/0035.html See: tp://www.w3.org/2006/12/13-ws-policy-irc#T17-59-34 /paulc

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4128: Need references to WSDL 1.1 and WSDL 2.0 component syntax

First recorded: 2007-01-02

Last modified: 2007-01-10

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/10-ws-policy-irc#T18-22-16 RESOLUTION: Issue 4128 closed by adding reference to WSDL1.1 Identifiers draft as proposed by Ashok in http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=4128

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4129: Attaching Policies to EPRs

First recorded: 2007-01-02

Last modified: 2007-01-10

Last modification: resolved based on the resolution to 3619, no new evidence was presented that changed anyone's position on the core issue. http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=3619 See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/10-ws-policy-irc#T18-42-26

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4130: Ignorable assertions must be ignored

First recorded: 2007-01-02

Last modified: 2007-01-10

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/10-ws-policy-irc#T19-01-11 RESOLUTION: 4130 closed with no action. Primer section on wsp:Ignorable should cover use cases and give guidance to policy authors see issue 4041

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4138: Normalization Algorithm is broken (single conjunctive expressions)

First recorded: 2007-01-02

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T23-41-17 RESOLUTION: 4138 closed with proposal in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0166.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4141: Policy parameter definition is not accurate

First recorded: 2007-01-03

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T20-04-12 RESOLUTION: 4141 is closed with the proposal in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0048.html INCLUDING the proposal in Prasad's included previous note related to the proposed change to the Guidelines document

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4142: Contradictory recommendation for nesting and intersection

First recorded: 2007-01-03

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T20-12-27 RESOLUTION: 4142 closed as specified in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0137.html a) remove the following text: "The reason for requiring at least an empty <wsp:Policy/> Element above is to ensure that two assertions of the same type will always be compatible and an intersection would not fail (see Section 4.5 Policy Intersection)." and change "Note: if the schema outline" to "Note: if the schema outline"

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4150: Duplicate text exists in Section 3 and 3.2, PolicyAttachments

First recorded: 2007-01-05

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T21-50-18 RESOLUTION: 4150 closed with email http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0027.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4177: Disambiguate notational convention for choice syntax

First recorded: 2007-01-10

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4177 resolved by adding exclusive as proposed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0056.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T21-57-25

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4178: Declaration of policy domains in policy expressions

First recorded: 2007-01-10

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: everybody fine to close 4178 with "won't fixed" and "futureConsideration" See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T19-07-31

Review Status: Change declined. Reviewer is satisfied.

4179: Preferences for policy expressions

First recorded: 2007-01-10

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: everybody fine to close 4179 with "won't fixed" and "futureConsideration" See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T19-12-30

Review Status: Change declined. Reviewer is satisfied.

4188: LC Comments from SAWSDL WG

First recorded: 2007-01-10

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4188 closed with no changes to LC. Respond to SAWSDL that we agree with sentiment, point to guidelines, no need to update attachment and add reference in guidelines to their specification See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T22-07-41

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4195: How to ignore some of the assertions marked “Ignorable” only?

First recorded: 2007-01-11

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4195 closed with no action based on explanation in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0141.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T22-21-59

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4196: Clarify namespace restrictions (Framework and Primer)

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-18

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4238 and 4196 closed with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0186.html <cferris> rrsagent, where am i? See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/18-ws-policy-irc#T19-12-51

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4197: Inconsistency on treatment of unknown extensibility elements (Framework, Primer, Guidelines)

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: RESOLUTION 4197 closed with changes in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/att-0079/wspolicy-extensibility-011007.htm__charset_WINDOWS... and change as " If an Attribute Information Item is not recognized, it SHOULD be ignored. If an Element Information Item is not recognized, it MUST be treated as a policy assertion, unless specified otherwise such as in Section 4.3.4 Policy References <hyperlink>" See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T23-38-45

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4203: introduction unclear and misleading

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-32-34 RESOLUTION: 4203 closed with proposal in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0085.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4204: misleading text in sect 2.3

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-40-30 RESOLUTION: Issues 4204 4207 closed with the proposal in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0157.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4205: editorial nits

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-49-54 RESOLUTION 4205 resolved with proposal http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0088.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4206: Clarify treatment of policy assertion parameters in compatibility determination

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4206 closed with proposal in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0172.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T19-35-11

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4207: misleading text in section 2.2

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4209: Example 3.1 does not follow the algorithm in merging policies

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-52-37 RESOLUTION 4209 closed with proposal http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0119.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4210: WSDL WG Editorial comments on Framework

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: Resolved WSDL WG LC comments as per: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0152.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. Working Group External Comment.

4211: WSDL WG Editorial comments on Attachment

First recorded: 2007-01-12

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: Resolved WSDL WG LC comments as per: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0153.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. Working Group External Comment.

4224: Section 4, last paragraph content is too restrictive - policy element information items are processed in multiple contexts

First recorded: 2007-01-15

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: Resolved at http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-56-05 , by agreement with proposal at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0121.html .

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4225: Framework editorial issues

First recorded: 2007-01-15

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4225 closed with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0125.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T00-58-38

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4226: Attachment editorial issues

First recorded: 2007-01-15

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4226 closed with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0124.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T01-00-21

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4230: normative text masquerading as non-normative guidance

First recorded: 2007-01-16

Last modified: 2007-01-17

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4230 closed with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0133.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T01-04-11

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4235: clarification needed to sect 4.3 to indicate that the normalization algorithm can be applied to wsp:Policy element used as XML element policy attachment

First recorded: 2007-01-16

Last modified: 2007-01-18

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T00-17-13 RESOLUTION: Close issue 4235 with proposal outlined in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0159.html

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4236: personal comment not a comment from the WS-RX TC

First recorded: 2007-01-16

Last modified: 2007-01-16

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/16-ws-policy-irc#T21-43-11 http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=4236 RESOLUTION: 4236 is closed with removal of Individual from definition of policy assertion in 3.1 and addition of Note to section 3.2 "Note: Depending on the semantics of the domain specific policy assertions a combination of these policy assertions can be required to specify a particular behavior.

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4238: framework spec does not formally define syntax (outline, etc) for compact form policy expression

First recorded: 2007-01-17

Last modified: 2007-01-18

Last modification: RESOLUTION: 4238 and 4196 closed with http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0186.html See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/18-ws-policy-irc#T19-12-51

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4240: Title: The distribution example does not follow the axioms in Section 4.3.3

First recorded: 2007-01-17

Last modified: 2007-01-18

Last modification: See http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T00-01-01 RESOLUTION: Close issue 4240 with "In section 4.3.3 put the base case described in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-policy/2007Jan/0173.html prior to current example identified in the issue"

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4254: Change of WSP namespace to be compliant with w3c namespace policy

First recorded: 2007-01-17

Last modified: 2007-01-18

Last modification: Resolved at http://www.w3.org/2007/01/17-ws-policy-irc#T00-24-23 . The namespace will be http://www.w3.org/ns/ws-policy for the CR draft.

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4306: update namespace document

First recorded: 2007-02-07

Last modified: 2007-02-07

Last modification: 1. Framework Section 2.3 and Attachment Section 2.2 will be also changed since the material in the namespace document. 2. Change the old namesapce document to state it is depcrecated and to point to the new one. 3. Change the new ns namespace document with the proposed text. Adopted by the WG at its Feb 7 meeting. See: http://www.w3.org/2007/02/07-ws-policy-irc#T17-59-24

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

4307: Update media type description

First recorded: 2007-02-07

Last modified: 2007-02-07

Last modification: Adopted by the WG at its Feb 7 meeting. See: http://www.w3.org/2007/02/07-ws-policy-irc#T17-42-27

Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied.

Version: $Id: wsp-lc-dispositions.html,v 1.7 2007/02/14 16:15:24 fsasaki Exp $