- From: Jakob Sachse <jakobsa@gmail.com>
- Date: Sun, 27 Mar 2011 15:40:13 +0200
- To: www-multimodal@w3.org
Hallo,
I have been reviewing the current specification. Even though it yet makes
quite a mature impression I found some flaws that may should be revised.
The .xsd files in Appendix C require a valid mmi-representation to have
qualified attributes.
------------------------------------------------------------
attributeFormDefault="qualified"
elementFormDefault="qualified"
------------------------------------------------------------
Given that it seems Appendix B is not in line with the spec.
Examples there (see exerpt below) are not using qualified attributes.
------------------------------------------------------------
<mmi:newContextRequest source="someURI" target="someOtherURI"
requestID="request-1">
</mmi:newContextRequest>
------------------------------------------------------------
On the other side examples in Appendix E are valid to the xsd definition:
------------------------------------------------------------
<mmi:startRequest mmi:requestID="1.237204761416E12"
mmi:context="IM_dcc3c320-9e88-44fe-b91d-02bd02fba1e3"
mmi:target="GUI">
<mmi:contentURL>login</mmi:contentURL>
<mmi:data>
<gui resourceid="login" xml:lang="de-DE">
<data id="back" enabled="false"/>
<data id="next" enabled="false"/>
</gui>
</mmi:data>
</mmi:startRequest>
------------------------------------------------------------
Another minor issue I came across was that in Appendix F.2 the spec states:
------------------------------------------------------------
[...]The parameter timeout is optional and describes the maximum delay
in milliseconds.[...]
------------------------------------------------------------
Whereas the following sequence diagrams are using seconds as time unit.
------------------------------------------------------------
timeout:
e.g. 30 sec
------------------------------------------------------------
That's what I came across so far. Overall it is fair to say that the
working draft makes a good impression on me.
Regards,
Jakob Sachse.
Received on Monday, 4 April 2011 17:00:04 UTC