This is the Disposition of Comments for the 02 November 2006 Candidate Recommendation of the Internationalization Tag Set 1.0 specification. This document lists the comments received during the Candidate Recommendation period and the extent to which the Internationalization Tag Set Working Group believes they have been addressed.
Last update: 2007-03-06.
Total number of comments: 12
| - | Reviewer satisfied | Reviewer not satisfied | No reply from reviewer |
| WG accepted comment | 12 | 0 | 0 |
| WG rejects comment | 0 | 0 | 0 |
The reviewer is not satisfied with the response of the Working Group.
Total number: 0.
The reviewer is satisfied with the response of the Working Group.
Total number: 12 (100%).
The Working Group declined to implement the change which the reviewer requested.
Total number: 0.
The reviewer did not respond to the decision of the Working Group.
Total number: 0.
The Working Group has accepted the proposal of the reviewer.
Total number: 12 (100%).
Comments from reviewers who are not participating in the Working Group.
Total number: 0.
To implement the comment, the Working Group made a non-editorial change to the specification. Nevertheless, the Working Group believes that the change does not invalidate previous reviews of the draft or implementation experiences, since no new concept was introduced, and no existing concept was modified.
Total number: 0.
| 3319: Namespace binding mechanism |
| First recorded: 2006-06-07 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-16 |
| Last modification: The ineroperability testing during CR phase should that the namespace binding via "xmlns" attributes can handle all functionality the specification needs. Hence, the alternative namespace binding via the "ns" element (a "feature at risk") was dropped from the specification. |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4096: Inheritance and overriding needs to be made clearer |
| First recorded: 2006-12-19 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modification: Resolved by the following reformulation of the list in sec. 5.4, see action item http://www.w3.org/2006/12/13-i18nits-minutes.html#action10 : 1.Implicit local selection in documents (ITS local attributes on a specific element) 2. Global selections in documents (using a rules element) Inside each rules element the precedence order is: 1. Any rules inside the rules element 2. Any rules linked via the XLink href attribute Note: If identical selections are defined in different rules elements within one document, the selection defined by the last takes precedence. Note: ITS doesn't define precedence related to rules defined or linked based on non-ITS mechanisms (such as processing instructions for linking rules). 3. Selections via defaults for data categories, see Section 6.1: Position, Defaults, Inheritance and Overriding of Data Categories |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4098: Need to make more explicit: what is possible with XSLT patterns realizing ITS selectors? |
| First recorded: 2006-12-19 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modification: Closed with text proposal at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-its/2006OctDec/0087.html . |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4099: Format for implementation output needs to be clear |
| First recorded: 2006-12-19 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-15 |
| Last modification: Format is described in implementation report at http://www.w3.org/International/its/itstagset/ImpReport#testsuite . |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4152: Need to make explicit that ITS attributes at its:span are not namespace qualified |
| First recorded: 2007-01-06 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-13 |
| Last modification: See latest update at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-its/2007JanMar/0091.html |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4289: Various mainly editorial changes |
| First recorded: 2007-01-31 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modification: Additional change to proposal described at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-i18n-its/2007JanMar/0071.html . |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4290: Create appendix about NVDL |
| First recorded: 2007-01-31 |
| Last modified: 2007-01-31 |
| Last modification: See proposal at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-i18n-its/2007JanMar/att-0061/nvdl.xml. Resolution: proposal accepted at http://www.w3.org/2007/01/31-i18nits-irc#T15-42-31 |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4291: Having the version attribute at its:rules in no namespace |
| First recorded: 2007-01-31 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-15 |
| Last modification: Issue closed with changes described at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-its/2007JanMar/0090.html . |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4293: Editorial fix in sec. 6.6.2 |
| First recorded: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-13 |
| Last modification: Felix made the change in version 1.126 |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4294: Add xlink:type to <its:rules> element |
| First recorded: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modification: See comment at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-its/2006OctDec/0073.html and discussion at http://www.w3.org/2006/12/20-i18nits-minutes#item04 . Resolution: WG agrees with the comment and adds the xlink:type attribute to the <its:rules> element. |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4295: Change of XPath expressions in schematron example |
| First recorded: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-02 |
| Last modification: See comment on schematron example at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-its/2006OctDec/0073.html . Resolution: Closed with the editors action item at http://www.w3.org/2006/12/20-i18nits-minutes.html#action14 . |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |
| 4322: Editors to go to the draft and check that there are no "CSS style elements" or the like |
| First recorded: 2007-02-13 |
| Last modified: 2007-02-13 |
| Last modification: Addressed in spec. version 1.128 |
| Review Status: Working Group accepted proposal. Reviewer is satisfied. |