W3C | TAG | Previous: 18 October 2004 Telcon | Next: 1 November 2004 Telcon

Agenda of 25th October 2004 TAG teleconference

Nearby: Teleconference details - issues list (handling new issues) - www-tag archive

1. Administrative (15 mins)

1. Roll call. Regrets: None

   Scribe: Chris Lilley volunteered for this meeting.

2. Meeting Records
   1. Accept minutes of 18th October telcon(see attachment)

3. Accept this agenda?

4. TAG Summaries

   Review of Monthy Summary Report

   From 5-7th Oct F2F :Paul volunteered to do the next monthly report and noted that the AC report is cumulative of the previous three reports.

   • ACTION PC: create draft summary for AC, get it to Steve Bratt by Oct 22
   • ACTION TBL: to investigate possible staff contact for TAG, due date 20 October 2004

   [will add pointers when available]

5. Date of next meeting: propose Monday 1 November 2004

   Appoint scribe for next meeting.

1.1 Technical Plenary

1. Observers - see email from Dan (member visible)
2. TAG Requested Liasons?

1.2 TAG Charter

1. Brief reminder that TAG feedback has been requested from TAG by 25 Oct (i.e.. today).

2. Technical (75 min)

See also open actions by owner and open issues.

2.1 Review of 2nd Last Call Document (30-45mins)

1. Report from the Editor:
   • Done ACTION: NDW to fix "One particularly useful mapping in the case of flat namespaces (specified, for example, in [RDFXML]) is to combine the namespace URI, a hash ("#"), and the local name, thus creating a URI for a secondary resource (the identified term)."
   • Done ACTION: NDW to fix "relevant specifications", incorporating a cross-reference to 3.1.1 Details of retrieving a representation.
   • Done ACTION: NDW to attempt to incorporate input from NM and RF etc. on generalizing representations.

   Resources

   • 19-October-2004 Editors Draft (and diff)
   • 21-October-2004 Editors Draft (and diff) (tentative integration of generalised representations from Noah)

2. Generalised Representations
   • Need to decide whether this is a direction we want to take (for this edition of Webarch).

3. Publication Schedule
   • PR Planning (email from DanC) (member visible)

     ACTION DC: draft a request for proposed recommendation, based on Norm's draft.

   • Open Threads (see below)
   • Decisions and/orRevise Plan? (from F2F?)

     ACTION CL: to cause draft of press release to happen

4. LC#2 Status Open Threads
   • Use of "assign" for URI -> resource
     • ...
     • 2004-10-11T15:39:27Z from skw
     • 2004-10-11T16:59:53Z from LMM

       ACTION: SW to Close that thread Use of "assign" for URI -> resource

     • 2004-10-15T19:34:49Z from connolly

   • Representation of a secondary resource?
     • 2004-09-21T15:54:05Z from jacek.kopecky

       Done ACTION: DC to to reply to commenter re primary and secondary resources. CONTINUES. with apologies

     • 2004-10-20T13:25:40Z from connolly
     • 2004-10-20T14:50:03Z from jacek.kopecky

   • KD005 thru KD016: Comments on Web Arch WD - 2004-07-05

     (see separate threads for each - how many can be closed?

     it may be useful to visit KD007, KD011 and KD014/015)

   • HTML WG last call comment on http://www.w3.org/TR/2004/WD-webarch-20040816/
     • ...

       Done ACTION: SW to update HTML WG on specific text re xlink

     • 2004-10-19T13:20:54Z from skw
     • 2004-10-20T15:41:07Z from steven.pemberton
     • 2004-10-20T16:27:08Z from connolly

   • non-authoritative syntaxes for fragment identifiers
     • ...
     • 2004-09-27T23:38:25Z from myriam.amielh
     • ACTION: RF to reply [closed] and pls fwd your question to www-tag for discussion re non-authoritative syntaxes for fragment identifier

   Any other open threads that we can usefully discuss (proposals can be added to the agenda).

Resources

1. 1st Last Call issues list (sorted by section)
2. 1st Last Call Annotated version of WebArch
3. List of actions by TAG participant
4. 2nd Last Call WD
5. Archive of public-webarch-comment
6. 2nd Last Call Comments Tracking page

2.2 Continue review of open issues

Review will continue starting with siteDate-36

2.2.1 status of Action Item status

Report on completed actions.

httpRange-14

ACTION DC: with Norm, develop a finding on httpRange-14 starting with the HashSlashDuality text

fragmentInXML-28

ACTION CONTINUES: Chris: Write up a summary of the resolutionhttp://www.w3.org/2004/05/14-tag-summary.html#fragmentInXML-28

xmlProfiles-29

ACTION Norm: Get XML Core WG to take on XMLProfiles-29

binaryXML-30

ACTION: Norm to add xbc use cases to binaryXML-30

ACTION Chris: Review the connection between the use cases and the taxomony on Chris's note

metadataInURI-31

ACTION Stuart revise finding (well overdue).

ACTION Paul find out what happened to DaveO's action item there.

mixedUIXMLNamespace-33

ACTION Norm update the issues list to point to "The W3C Workshop on Web Applications and Compound Documentshttp://www.w3.org/2004/04/webapps-cdf-ws/summary"

xmlFunctions-34

ACTION timbl take another stab at specifying the problem

XMLVersion-41

ACTION NDW: to report workplan and dates for Extensibilty and Versioning work..

ACTION PC: solicit QA WG review of draft extensibility/versioning finding

The TAG does not expect to discuss issues below this line.

3. Status report on these findings

See also TAG findings

• abstractComponentRefs-37:
  • 30 Oct 2003 draft finding "Abstract Component References"
• contentPresentation-26:
  • 30 June 2003 draft finding "Separation of semantic and presentational markup, to the extent possible, is architecturally sound"
• metadataInURI-31
• siteData-36
  • "There is no such thing as a Web site"
• xmlChunk-44
  • "XML Chunk Equality"