W3C

XML Protocol Comparisons

The purpose of this document is to compare and contrast a variety of XML protocols. It will probably take a while to flesh out the form and content. Viewers are invited to comment and contribute. The forum for discussing this page and the data within is xml-dist-app@w3.org. The list and archives are open, you may join xml-dist-app by sending mailto xml-dist-app-request@w3.org with the Subject: subscribe.

Since this document was created in March 2000, W3C chartered the XML Protocol Working Group whose task is to produce a simple XML-based messaging and remote procedure call protocol.

XML syntax
Protocol Organization Architects Status ns schema DTD Facets Example
generic XML protocols provide a mechanism to represent arbitrary data.
XML-RPC Userland Dave Winer (userland),
Bob Atkinson (microsoft),
Mohsen Al-Ghosein (microsoft),
Don Box (developmentor)		 deployed 0 0 1? 
[in a POST parameter]
<methodCall>
   <methodName>examples.getStateName</methodName>
   <params>
      <param>
         <value><i4>41</i4></value>
      </param>
   </params>
</methodCall>
SOAP
(mailing list)		 Ariba, Inc.
Commerce One, Inc.
Compaq Computer Corporation
DevelopMentor, Inc.
Hewlett Packard Company
International Business Machines Corporation
IONA Technologies
Lotus Development Corporation
Microsoft Corporation
SAP AG
UserLand Software Inc.		 Don Box, DevelopMentor
David Ehnebuske, IBM
Gopal Kakivaya, Microsoft
Andrew Layman, Microsoft
Noah Mendelsohn, Lotus Development Corp.
Henrik Frystyk Nielsen, Microsoft
Satish Thatte, Microsoft
Dave Winer, UserLand Software, Inc.		 coded
W3C NOTE		 2 2 0 
<SOAP-ENV:Envelope
  xmlns:SOAP-ENV="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/"
  SOAP-ENV:encodingStyle="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/"/>
   <SOAP-ENV:Body>
      <e:Book>
         <title>My Life and Work</title>
         <firstauthor href="#Person-1"/>
         <secondauthor href="#Person-2"/>
      </e:Book>
      <e:Person id="Person-1">
         <name>Henry Ford</name>
         <address xsi:type="m:Electronic-address">
             <email>mailto:henryford@hotmail.com</email>
             <web>http://www.henryford.com</web>
         </address>
      </e:Person>
      <e:Person id="Person-2">
         <name>Samuel Crowther</name>
         <address xsi:type="n:Street-address">
             <street>Martin Luther King Rd</street>
             <city>Raleigh</city>
             <state>North Carolina</state>
         </address>
      </e:Person>
   </SOAP-ENV:Body>
</SOAP-ENV:Envelope>
WDDX Allaire Simeon Simeonov (Allaire),
Nate Weiss (independent/JavaScript),
Spike Washburn (Allaire/Java),
Rasmus Lerdorf (PHP3),
Scott Guelich (Scripted.com/Perl)		 deployed 0 0 1 
<?xml version='1.0'?>
<!DOCTYPE wddxPacket SYSTEM 'wddx_0090.dtd'>
<wddxPacket version='0.9'>
<header/>
   <data>
      <struct>
         <var name='s'><string>a string</string></var>
         <var name='a'><array length='2'>
               <number>10</number>
               <string>second element</string></array></var>
         <var name='obj'><struct>
               <var name='s'><string>a string</string></var>
               <var name='n'><number>-12.456</number></var>
            </struct></var>
      </struct>
   </data>
</wddxPacket>
XMI Unisys Corporation
Fujitsu
IBM
DSTC
Recerca Informatica
Oracle
Daimler-Benz
Platinum Technology		 deployed
(Unisys)
(ArgoUML exports XMI)		 1 0 1 
[UML model in an XMI document]
<XMI xmi.version="1.1" xmlns:UML="org.omg/standards/UML">
   <XMI.header>
      <XMI.metamodel name="UML" version="1.3" href="UML.xml"/>
      <XMI.model name="example" version="1" href="example.xml"/>
   </XMI.header>
   <XMI.content>
      <UML:Class name="C1">
         <UML:Classifier.feature>
            <UML:Attribute name="a1" visibility="private"/>
         </UML:Classifier.feature>
      </UML:Class>
   </XMI.content>
</XMI>
Jabber Jabber.org Open Source Project Jeremie Miller deployed 1 0 1 not reviewed yet 
<stream:stream xmlns:stream="http://etherx.jabber.org/streams" 
               xmlns="jabber:client" to="jabber.org">
  <message to="jeremie@jabber.org">
    <subject>Test</subject>
    <body>This is a test message.</body>
  </message>
  <presence>
    <status>Working on Project XYZ</status>
    <show>away</show>
  </presence>
</stream:stream>
ebXML UN/CEFACT
oasis		 
from a message from Dick Brooks
SOAPAction: ebXML
Content-type: multipart/related; boundary="BoundarY"; type="text/xml";
        start=" <ebxhmheader111@imacompany.com>"

--BoundarY
Content-ID: <ebxhmheader111@imacompany.com>
Content-Type: text/xml; charset="UTF-8"

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<SOAP-ENV:Envelope
xmlns:SOAP-ENV='http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/'

xmlns:eb='http://www.ebxml.org/namespaces/messageHeader'>
<SOAP-ENV:Header>
	<eb:MessageHeader mustUnderstand="1" version="1.0">
		<From>
			<PartyId>urn:duns:123456789</PartyId>
		</From>
		<To>
			<PartyId>urn:duns:912345678</PartyId>
		</To>
		<CPAId>20001209-133003-28572</CPAId>
		<ConversationId>20001209-133003-28572</ConversationId>
		<Service type="proprietary">OrderProcessing</Service>
		<Action>NewXMLOrder</Action>
		<MessageData>
			<MessageId>mid:20001209-133003-28572@imacompany.com</MessageId>
			<TimeStamp>20010215T111212.000Z</TimeStamp>
                        <TimeToLive>20010215T112233.000Z</TimeToLive>
		</MessageData>
		<QualityofServiceInfo deliverySemantics="OnceAndOnlyOnce"
                                      messageOrderSemantics="NotGuaranteed"
                                      deliveryReceiptRequested="None"/>
                <Description xml:lang="en">A Purchase Order is
attached</Description>
	</MessageHeader>
</SOAP-ENV:Header>
<SOAP-ENV:Body>
	<eb:Manifest id="abc123" version="1.0">
		<Reference xlink:href="urn:cid:ebxmlpayload111@imacompany.com"
			   xlink:role="XLinkRole"
  		           xlink:type="simple"
			   xlink:label="XLinkLabel">
		    	   <Description xml:lang="en-us">Purchase Order 1</Description>
		</Reference>
	</Manifest>

</SOAP-ENV:Body>
</SOAP-ENV:Envelope>

--BoundarY
Content-ID: <ebxmlpayload111@imacompany.com>
Content-Type: text/xml

<purchase_order>
	<po_number>1</po_number>
	<part_number>123</part_number>
	<price currency="USD">500.00</price>
</purchase_order>

--BoundarY--
BizTalk
June 2000 spec
(graph discussion)		 Microsoft Satish Thatte ? 2 2 0 SOAPfacets plus: 
<SOAP-ENV:Envelope
                xmlns:SOAP-ENV="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/"
                xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/1999/XMLSchema-instance">
    <SOAP-ENV:Header>
       <dlv:delivery SOAP-ENV:mustUnderstand="1"
                     xmlns:dlv="http://schemas.biztalk.org/btf-2-0/delivery"
                     xmlns:agr="http://www.trading-agreements.org/types/">
           <dlv:to>
               <dlv:address xsi:type="agr:department">Book Order
Department</dlv:address>           
           </dlv:to>
           <dlv:from>
               <dlv:address xsi:type="agr:organization">Booklovers
Anonymous</dlv:address>           
           </dlv:from>
       </dlv:delivery>
       <prop:properties SOAP-ENV:mustUnderstand="1"
 
xmlns:prop="http://schemas.biztalk.org/btf-2-0/properties">
 
<prop:identity>uuid:74b9f5d0-33fb-4a81-b02b-5b760641c1d6</prop:identity>
           <prop:sentAt>2000-05-14T03:00:00+08:00</prop:sentAt>
           <prop:expiresAt>2000-05-15T04:00:00+08:00</prop:expiresAt>
 
<prop:topic>http://electrocommerce.org/purchase_order/</prop:topic>
       </prop:properties>
    </SOAP-ENV:Header>
    <SOAP-ENV:Body>
        <po:PurchaseOrder
xmlns:po="http://electrocommerce.org/purchase_order/">
            <po:Title>Essential BizTalk</po:Title>
        </po:PurchaseOrder>
    </SOAP-ENV:Body>
</SOAP-ENV:Envelope>
Wf-XML
mailing list		 Workflow Management Coalition WfMC Working Group 4 beta spec
V 1.0 due mid-April		 0
due in 1.0		 0
due in 1.0		 1 
<WfMessage Version= 1.0>
   <WfMessageHeader>
      <Request><ResponseRequired>Yes</ResponseRequired></Request>
      <Key>http://www.XYZcompany.com/wfprocess</Key>
      <Operation>CreateProcessInstance</Operation>
   </WfMessageHeader>
   <WfMessageBody>
      <CreateProcessInstance.Request>
         <Key>http://www.XYZcompany.com/wfprocess</Key>
         <ObserverKey>http://www.mycompany.com/mywork</ObserverKey>
         <ContextData>
            <Vehicle>
               <VehicleType>Car</VehicleType>
               <Specification>
                  <Manufacturer>Mercedes</Manufacturer>
                  <Model>450SL</Model>
               </Specification>
            </Vehicle>
            <Furniture>chair</Furniture>
         </ContextData>
         <StartImmediately>Yes</StartImmediately>
      </CreateProcessInstance.Request>
   </WfMessageBody>
</WfMessage>
LOTP not reviewed yet
web service-related XML protocols protocols with a fixed grammar targeting a particular application domain.
WSDLAriba
International Business Machines Corporation
Microsoft 		Erik Christensen (Microsoft)
Francisco Curbera (IBM)
Greg Meredith (Microsoft)
Sanjiva Weerawarana (IBM)		not reviewed yet 
from Web Services Description Language (WSDL) 1.0
You find find the colorized WSDL examples helpful.
<?xml version="1.0"?>
<definitions name="StockQuote"

targetNamespace="http://example.com/stockquote.wsdl"
          xmlns:tns="http://example.com/stockquote.wsdl"
          xmlns:xsd1="http://example.com/stockquote.xsd"
          xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/"
          xmlns="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/">

   <types>
       <schema targetNamespace="http://example.com/stockquote.xsd"
              xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/XMLSchema">
           <element name="TradePriceRequest">
              <complexType>
                  <all>
                      <element name="tickerSymbol" type="string"/>
                  </all>
              </complexType>
           </element>
           <element name="TradePrice">
              <complexType>
                  <all>
                      <element name="price" type="float"/>
                  </all>
              </complexType>
           </element>
       </schema>
   </types>

   <message name="GetLastTradePriceInput">
        <part name="body" element="xsd1:TradePrice"/>
    </message>

    <message name="GetLastTradePriceOutput">
        <part name="body" element="xsd1:TradePriceResult"/>
    </message>

    <portType name="StockQuotePortType">
        <operation name="GetLastTradePrice">
           <input message="tns:GetLastTradePriceInput"/>
           <output message="tns:GetLastTradePriceOutput"/>
        </operation>
    </portType>

    <binding name="StockQuoteSoapBinding" type="tns:StockQuotePortType">
        <soap:binding style="document" transport="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http"/>
        <operation name="GetLastTradePrice">
           <soap:operation soapAction="http://example.com/GetLastTradePrice"/>
           <input>
               <soap:body use="literal" namespace="http://example.com/stockquote.xsd"
                          encodingStyle="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/"/>
           </input>
           <output>
               <soap:body use="literal" namespace="http://example.com/stockquote.xsd"
                          encodingStyle="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/"/>
           </output>
        </operation>
    </binding>

    <service name="StockQuoteService">
        <documentation>My first service</documentation>
        <port name="StockQuotePort" binding="tns:StockQuoteBinding">
           <soap:address location="http://example.com/stockquote"/>
        </port>
    </service>

</definitions>
WIDLwebMethods Phillip Merrick (webMethods)
Charles Allen (webMethods)		 
from 4. WIDL Examples
<WIDL NAME="genericShipping" TEMPLATE="Shipping"
      BASEURL="http://www.shipping.com" VERSION="2.0">

<SERVICE NAME="TrackPackage" METHOD="Get" 
         URL="/cgi-bin/track_package"
         INPUT="TrackInput" OUTPUT="TrackOutput" />

<BINDING NAME="TrackInput" TYPE="INPUT">
   <VARIABLE NAME="TrackingNum" TYPE="String" FORMNAME="trk_num" />
   <VARIABLE NAME="DestCountry" TYPE="String" FORMNAME="dest_cntry" />
   <VARIABLE NAME="ShipDate" TYPE="String" FORMNAME="ship_date" />
</BINDING>

<BINDING NAME="TrackOutput" TYPE="OUTPUT">
   <CONDITION TYPE="Failure" REFERENCE="doc.title[0].text" 
              MATCH="Warning Form" REASONREF="doc.p[0].text" />
   <CONDITION TYPE="Success" REFERENCE="doc.title[0].text" 
              MATCH="Foobar Airbill:*" REASONREF="doc.p[1].value" />
   <VARIABLE NAME="disposition" TYPE="String" REFERENCE="doc.h[3].value" />
   <VARIABLE NAME="deliveredOn" TYPE="String" REFERENCE="doc.h[5].value" />
   <VARIABLE NAME="deliveredTo" TYPE="String" REFERENCE="doc.h[7].value" />
</BINDING>

</WIDL>
SCLorg1
org2 		name1 (co)
name2 (co)		not reviewed yet 
[comment]


    
UDDIARIBA
    not reviewed yet

from UDDI Data Structure Reference
<element name="businessEntity">
  <type content="elementOnly">
    <group order="seq">
      <element ref="discoveryURLs" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="1"/>
      <element ref="name"/>
      <element ref="description" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="*"/>
      <element ref="contacts" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="1"/>
      <element ref="businessServices" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="1"/>
      <element ref="identifierBag" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="1"/>
      <element ref="categoryBag" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="1"/>
    </group>
    <attribute name="businessKey" minOccurs="1" type="string"/>
    <attribute name="operator" type="string"/>
    <attribute name="authorizedName" type="string"/>
  </type>
</element>


    
DISCOMicrosoft
    not reviewed yet

from Draft: Discovery of Web Services (DISCO)
<disco:discovery>
  <disco:discoveryRef ref='folder/discovery'/>

  <-- elements from other namespaces -->
</disco:discovery>

<disco:discovery>
  <scl:contractRef ref='my1.sdl'>
  <scl:contractRef ref='my2.sdl' docRef='my.htm'>
</disco:discovery>

<disco:discovery>
  <schema:schemaRef ref='my1.xsd' targetNamespace='http://my.org/my1.xsd'/>
  <schema:schemaRef ref='my2.xsd'/>
</disco:discovery>


    
NASSLIBM
    Francisco Curbera

    Sanjiva Weerawarana

    Matthew J. Duftler		not reviewed yet

from NASSL paper
<?xml version="1.0"?>
<nsl:serviceDef name="StockQuoteService" 
                version="1.0" 
                xmlns:nsl="http://www.ibm.com/namespaces/NASSL"
                xmlns:sqs="http://www.getquote.com/ns/StockQuote"
                xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/1999/XMLSchema">
  <nsl:types>
    <nsl:typeDefs typeModel="http://www.w3.org/1999/XMLSchema">
      <xsd:schema targetNamespace="http://www.getquote.com/ns/StockQuote">
        <xsd:complexType name="stockquote">
          <xsd:element name="date" type="xsd:date"/>
          <xsd:element name="price" type="xsd:float"/>
          <xsd:element name="change" type="xsd:float"/>
          <xsd:element name="volume" type="xsd:int"/>
        </xsd:complexType>
      </xsd:schema>
    </nsl:typeDefs>
  </nsl:types>

  <nsl:interfaces>
    <nsl:interfaceDef name="GetQuote">
      <nsl:operationDef name="getQuote">
        <nsl:type name="sqs:stockquote"/>
        <nsl:parameters>
          <nsl:parameterDef name="symbol" direction="IN">
            <nsl:type name="xsd:string"/>
          </nsl:parameterDef>
        </nsl:parameters>
      </nsl:operationDef>
    </nsl:interfaceDef>
  </nsl:interfaces>

  <nsl:implementations>
    <nsl:implementationDef name="HTTP-POST-GetQuotes">
      <nsl:implements interface="GetQuote"/>
      <nsl:access protocol="HTTP-POST"/>
    </nsl:implementationDef>

    <nsl:implementationDef name="RPC-SOAP-HTTP-GetQuotes">
      <nsl:implements interface="GetQuote"/>
      <nsl:access protocol="RPC-SOAP-HTTP"/>
      <nsl:encoding styles="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/
                    http://www.ibm.com/namespaces/xmi"/>
      <nsl:protocolExtensions>
        <operationsURI value="urn:StockQuoteService"/>
        <methodNamespace value=""/>
        <action value="urn:get-quote-rpc-soap-http"/>
      </nsl:protocolExtensions>
    </nsl:implementationDef>
  </nsl:implementations>

  <nsl:providers>
    <nsl:providerDef>
      <nsl:provides implementation="HTTP-POST-GetQuotes"/>
      <nsl:endPoint url="http://www.getquote.com/cgi-bin/getquote.pl"/>
    </nsl:providerDef>

    <nsl:providerDef>
      <nsl:provides implementation="RPC-SOAP-HTTP-GetQuotes"/>
      <nsl:endPoint url="http://www.getquote.com/ibm-soap-1.2/rpcrouter.jsp"/>
    </nsl:providerDef>
  </nsl:providers>
</nsl:serviceDef>


    
    

      domain-specific XML
      protocols
      protocols with a fixed grammar targeting a particular
        application domain.
    

    
    

      ICE
      GCA
      Neil Webber, Vignette
        Corporation

        Conleth O'Connell, Vignette
        Corporation

        Bruce Hunt, Adobe Systems,
        Inc.

        Rick Levine, Sun
        Microsystems, Inc.

        Laird Popkin,
        Sothebys.com		
      deployed
      0
      0
      1
      
      
      
<?xml version="1.0"?>
<!DOCTYPE ice-payload
        SYSTEM "http://www.ice-ag.org/ICE.dtd">
<ice-payload
   payload-id="1998-07-05T02:02:23@xyz.com"
   timestamp="02:02:23,449"
   ice.version="1.0">
  <ice-header>
    <ice-sender
       sender-id="4af37b30-2c35-11d2-be4a-204c4f4f5020"
       name="XYZ Corporation"
       role="subscriber"/>
    <ice-user-agent>Acme Ray Gun ICE System, V0.9beta</ice-user-agent>
  </ice-header>
  <ice-request
     request-id="1998-07-05T02:02:23@xyz.com-1">
    <ice-nop/>
  </ice-request>
</ice-payload>

      		
    

    
    

      IOTP
      Commerce One
      David Burdett
      ?
      0
      0
      1
      
      
      
<BrandList ID='M1.2'
  XML:Lang='us-en'
  ShortDesc='Purchase book including s&h'
  PayDirection='Debit' >
  <Brand ID ='M1.30'
    BrandId='MasterCard'
    BrandName='MasterCard Credit'
    BrandLogoNetLocn='ftp://otplogos.mastercard.com/mastercardcredit'
    ProtocolAmountRefs='M1.33'>
  </Brand>
  <Brand ID ='M.31'
    BrandId='Visa'
    BrandName='Visa Credit'
    BrandLogoNetLocn='ftp://otplogos.visa.com/visacredit'
    ProtocolAmountRefs='M1.33'>
  </Brand>
  <Brand ID ='M1.32'
    BrandId='AmericanExpress'
    BrandName='American Express'
    BrandLogoNetLocn='ftp://otplogos.amex.com'
    ProtocolAmountRefs ='M1.33' >
  </Brand >
  <ProtocolAmount ID ='M1.33'
    PayProtocolRef='M1.35'
    CurrencyAmountRefs='M1.34'>
  </ProtocolAmount>
  <CurrencyAmount ID ='M1.34'
    Amount='10.95'
    CurrCode='USD'/>
  <PayProtocol ID ='M1.35'
    ProtocolId='SCCD1.0'
    ProtocolName='Secure Channel Credit/Debit'
    PayReqNetLocn='http://www.example.com/etill/sccd1' >
  </PayProtocol>
</BrandList>

      		
    

    
    

      eCo
      not reviewed yet
      
    

    
    

      XMOP
      not reviewed yet
      
    

    
    

      XIOP

        (spec)		
      Financial Toolsmiths AB
      Anders W. Tell (Financial
        Toolsmiths AB)
      Alpha 2Q 2000
      "http://xiop.org/"
      0 due in 1.0
      0 due in 1.0
      reviewed by Anders
        Tell

        no peer review yet...
      		
      
from http://xiop.sourceforge.net/doc/xiop_examples_1_2.html

        
<typecode> 
   <tk_struct repoid="IDL:/TheStruct:1.0"  
                name="TheStruct" 
             members="3"> 
     <tk_struct_member name="first"> 
       <typecode>   <!-- first members typecode --> 
         <tk_octet/>  
       </typecode> 
     </tk_struct_member> 
     <tk_struct_member name="next"> 
       <typecode> <tk_long/> </typecode> 
     </tk_struct_member> 
     <tk_struct_member name="last"> 
       <typecode> <tk_string max-length="100"/> </typecode> 
     </tk_struct_member> 
   </tk_struct> 
</typecode>

      		
    

    
    

      P3P
      W3C
      Lorrie Cranor
        (AT&T),

        Marc Langheinrich (ETH
        Zurich),

        Massimo Marchiori
        (W3C/MIT), 

        Martin Presler-Marshall (IBM), Joseph Reagle
        (W3C/MIT)		
      deployment status
      namespace
      schema
      dtd
      not reviewed yet
      
      
from example 3.1

        
<POLICY xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/P3Pv1"
  discuri="http://www.catalog.example.com/PrivacyPracticeBrowsing.html">
 <ENTITY>
  <DATA-GROUP>
   <DATA ref="#business.name">CatalogExample</DATA>
   <DATA ref="#business.contact-info.postal.street.line1">4000 Lincoln Ave.</DATA>
   <DATA ref="#business.contact-info.telecom.telephonenum.number">3926753</DATA>
  </DATA-GROUP>
 </ENTITY>
 <DISPUTES-GROUP>
  <DISPUTES resolution-type="independent"
    service="http://www.PrivacySeal.example.org"
    short-description="PrivacySeal.example.org">
   <REMEDIES><correct/></REMEDIES>
   <IMG src="http://www.PrivacySeal.example.org/Logo.gif"/>
  </DISPUTES>
 </DISPUTES-GROUP>
 <ACCESS><nonident/></ACCESS>
 <STATEMENT>
  <PURPOSE><admin/><develop/></PURPOSE>
  <RECIPIENT><ours/></RECIPIENT>
  <RETENTION><stated-purpose/></RETENTION>
  <DATA-GROUP>
   <DATA ref="#dynamic.clickstream.server"/>
   <DATA ref="#dynamic.http.useragent"/>
  </DATA-GROUP>
 </STATEMENT>
</POLICY>

      		
    

    
    

      CCPP
      W3C
      Franklin
        Reynolds (Nokia Research Center)

        Johan Hjelm (W3C/Ericsson)

        Spencer Dawkins (Nortel)

        Sandeep Singhal (IBM)		
      testing
      1
      RDF
      0
      not reviewed yet 
      
      
[from Inline example]

        
<?xml version="1.0"?>
<rdf:RDF
xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"
xmlns:prf="http://www.w3.org/TR/WD-profile-vocabulary#">
 <rdf:Description about="HardwarePlatform">
   <prf:Defaults Vendor="Nokia" Model="2160" Type="PDA" ScreenSize="800x600x24"
    CPU="PPC" Keyboard="Yes" Memory="16mB" Bluetooth="YES" Speaker="Yes" />
  <prf:Modifications Memory="32mB" />
 </rdf:Description>
 <rdf:Description about="SoftwarePlatform">
  <prf:Defaults OS="EPOC1.0" HTMLVersion="4.0" JavaScriptVersion="4.0"
   WAPVersion="1.0" WMLScript="1.0" />
  <prf:Modifications Sound="Off" Images="Off" />
 </rdf:Description>
 <rdf:Description about="EpocEmail1.0">
   <prf:Defaults HTMLVersion="4.0" />
 </rdf:Description>
  <rdf:Description about="EpocCalendar1.0">
  <prf:Defaults HTMLVersion="4.0" />
 </rdf:Description>
  <rdf:Description about="UserPreferences">
 <prf:Defaults Language="English"/>
 </rdf:Description>
</rdf:RDF>

      		
    

    
    

      E-Speak
      hp
      ???
      deployed?
      namespace
      schema
      dtd
      not reviewed yet
      
      
[comment]

        

      		
    

    
    

      transport/transfer protocols
      Transport and Transfer protocols designed to carry XML
        protocol payloads.
    

    
    

      BXXP

        app
        design

        protocol

        Note - these are broken links.
        Try incrementing the numbers at the end of the URL to see where they
        are now.

        older
        HTML version of protocol draft		
      - no research on this topic yet -
    

    
    

      Transaction Internet
        Protocol

        (part deux)		
      Microsoft

        Tandem		
      J. Lyon (Microsoft)

        K. Evans (Tandem)

        J. Klein (Tandem)		
      
      
      
      
      
      
      

      		
    

    
    

      HTTP-NG

        (architecture)		
      A layered distributed object system with underlying
        protocol support.
    

    
    

      WorldOS
      WorldOS Corp.
      Lucas Gonze
      deployed
      0
      0
      0
      
      
      
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> 
<msg> 
  <protocol> 
    <id>WorldOS</id> 
    <version>0.1</version> 
    <definition>http://www.worldos.org/WorldOS.xml</definition> 
    <checksum>-1</checksum> 
    <function>debug</function> 
  </protocol> 
  <funcdata /> 
</msg> 

      		
    

    
    

      non-XML protocols
      non-XML protocols that may have some interesting lessons
        for us.
    

    
    

      XDR
      XDR is Sun's RPC data format.
    

    
    

      RACE
      Global Financial Networks Limited
      Charles Kilkenny (Global
        Financial Networks Limited)
      draft
      N/A
      N/A
      N/A
      not independently reviewed yet
      
      
    

    
    
  




Facets



Below is the list of facets I have defined for characterizing these
protocols.



  
serialization

    
format for storing primitive data types (int, char, string),
      structures, and matrices

      grammar
      types:
      

        
custom

          
The XML schema is specific to the application, doesn't
            (intentionally) share characteristics with other applications.
            These almost always reflect the application data structure
            closely.

        
automatic

          
Generated XML that uses element names derived from application
            data structures through some type of mapping or rules.

        
fixed

          
Generated XML that uses fixed element names to serialize
            application data structures.

      

      data
      typing:
      

        
implicit (contextual)

          
does not carry detailed data types in the serialization or an
            external schema

        
explicit

          
data types with elements or in an external schema

      

    

  
extensibility

    
a mechanism allowing features and functionality to be added beyond
      what the architects can predict. Some protocols mention extensibility as
      a requirement without defining the mechanism. Generally, protocols that
      use namespaces and specify what to do with unknown namespaces get
      extensibility for free.

  
skinnyness

    
reduces to a minimal line protocol for communication between non-naive
      agents. This implies removing all schema information. Pairing this with
      interface discovery requires sufficient
      parameter identification that a naive agent may also participate with
      additional schema information.

  
protocol

    
definition of requests and responses. This implies state transitions
      and defined error messages when state transitions fail.

  
interface discovery

    
machine-readable markup allowing a naive application to access the
      typed data. Supporting schemas in turn supports interface
    discovery.

  
transactions (ACIDity)

    
atomicity and state clarity that allows an action to be partially
      completed and then undone. (ACID == atomicity, consistency, isolation
      and durability)

  
remote procedure

    
The protocol explicitly supports sending requests to a remote system
      to execute a designated function, method, or procedure defined by an
      application using the protocol rather than functions defined in or by
      the protocol itself.

  
business process

    
modeling of business workflow conventions

  
security

    
rules on how data should be digitally signed to prove authenticity and
      authorization of requested actions

  
routing

    
message forwarding from agent to agent depending on attributes of the
      message

  
packaging

    
Construction of multi-document messages including non-XML documents as
      attachments.  Usually includes mechanisms for constructing URI
      references to packaged documents.

  






  Valid HTML 4.0!
   Eric Prud'hommeaux,


but please post comments to


  xml-dist-app@w3.org




  @(#) $Id: 29-XML-protocol-matrix.html,v 1.41 2003/06/13 15:37:12 eric Exp $