Reviewers of Last Call UA Guidelines

This document lists potential and actual of the last call Working Draft of the User Agent Accessibility Guidelines. Note. This page is provided for convenience only. The definitive record of comments is the w3c-wai-ua mailing list archive.

Refer to the Issues list for documentation of issues raised and their resolutions.

Completed Reviews
Reviews outstanding
Dependencies on W3C Groups

Here are some of the calls for review of the last call UAGL:

5 November last call to UAGL WG.
5 November last call to chairs (and individuals) (Member only link).
19 November reminder to Chairs (Member only link).
29 November reminder to Chairs (Member only link). In addition, Ian sent out reminders to chairs of WGs with dependencies 29 November (refer to Team archives).

Last modified: $Date: 2000/11/08 07:48:45 $

Completed Reviews

From invited reviewers

The following people were invited to review the document individually and completed their reviews.

Patrick Burke: Organization: UCLA; E-mail:burke@ucla.edu; Reference: Al Gilman
Jim Fruchterman: Organization: Arkenstone; E-mail: jim@arkenstone.org
John Gardner(11/2/99): Organization: Oregon State University; E-mail: john.gardner@orst.edu
Markku T. Hakkinen(11/2/99): Organization:ProdWorks; E-mail: hakkinen@prodworks.com
Chuck Hitchcock: Organization: CAST, Inc.; E-mail: chitchcock@cast.org
Geoff Freed (11/2/99): Organization: CPB/WGBH National Center for Accessible Media; E-mail: geoff_freed@wgbh.org
Earl Johnson: Organization: SUN; E-mail: Earl.Johnson@Eng.Sun.COM
Peter Korn: Organization: SUN; E-mail: Peter.Korn@Eng.Sun.COM
Håkon Wium Lie (11/3/99): Organization: Opera Software; E-mail: howcome@opera.com
Steve McAdoo: Organization: Real Networks; E-mail: madaus@real.com; Originally confirmed: George Madaus
Richard Premack (11/3/99): Organization: Internext phone browser; E-mail: richardp@akamail.com; Reference: David Poehlman
Liam Quinn: Organization: Web Design Group; E-mail:liam@htmlhelp.com; Reference: Harvey Bingham
T.V. Raman: Organization: IBM Research: Human Language Technologies; E-mail: tvraman@us.ibm.com
Lakespur Roca: Organization: Netscape; E-mail: lake@netscape.com
Terry Sullivan: Organization:; E-mail: terry@pantos.org; Reference: Bryan Campbell
Gregg Vanderheiden(11/2/99): Organization: Trace Center; E-mail: gv@trace.wisc.edu

From other reviewers

The following people also submitted reviews. Thank you!

Reviews outstanding

From confirmed reviewers

The following people confirmed that they would review the Guidelines but have not.

Doug Geoffray: Organization:GW-Micro; E-mail: geoffray@gwmicro.com
Ben Wiess: Organization:AI Squared; E-mail: bweiss@aisquared.co
Fraser Shein: Title: Coordinator, Microcomputer Applications Program; Organization: Bloorview MacMillan Centre; E-mail: Fraser_shein@msn.com
Bryan Campbell: E-mail: bryany@pathcom.com
Mike Paciello: Organization:; E-mail: paciello@pop.ma.ultranet.com; Reference: Harvey Bingham
Janina Sajka: Title: Director of Information Systems Research and Development; Organization: AFB; E-mail: janina@afb.net; Reference: Kitch Barnicle
Eric Freese: Organization: Electronic Data Foundry; E-mail: efreese@datafoundry.com; Reference: Harvey Bingham
Patrick Sheehan (11/2/99): Organization: Veterans Administration; E-mail: pat.sheehan@mail.va.gov; Reference: Al Gilman
Constantine Stephanidis (11/8/99): Organization: Foundation for Research and Technology - Hellas; E-mail: cs@ics.forth.gr
Linda Boyer (11/8/99): Organization: IBM ViaVoice group; E-mail:lboyer@us.ibm.com; Reference: Rich Schwerdtfege
Steve Anderson: Organization: Dragon Systems; E-mail:steve_anderson@dragonsys.com; Reference: Harvey Bingham
Mary Beth Janes: Organization: Apple Computer; E-mail: mjanes@apple.com; Reference: Mark Novak
Steven Mendelsohn: E-mail: smendel@panix.com; Reference: Susan Goodman, UCP, sgoodman@ucpa.org
David Clark: Organization: CAST; E-mail: dmclark@cast.org

From invited reviewers

The following people were invited to review the Guidelines but have not.

Chris Wilson: Organization: Microsoft Internet Explorer Team; E-mail: cwilso@MICROSOFT.com
Tim Lacy: Organization: Microsoft Accessibility Team; E-mail:
Barry Smith: Title: Program manager; Organization: Conversa; E-mail: Barrys@conversa.com
Curtis Chong: Organization: NFB; E-mail: chong99@concentric.net
Peter Young: Organization: JBliss Imaging Systems; E-mail: pyoung@ix.netcom.com
Alan Cantor: Organization: Cantor + Associates; E-mail: acantor@interlog.com
Urlene Hughes: Organization: American Council of the Blind; E-mail:; Reference:David Poehlman
Judith Dixon: Organization: Library of Congress; E-mail:jdix@loc.gov; Reference: Harvey Bingham
Ralph Ferris: Organization: Fujitsu; E-mail: ralph@fsc.fujitsu.com; Reference:
Bill Smith: Organization:SUN; E-mail: Bill.Smith@eng.Sun.COM; Reference: Harvey Bingham
Foteos Macrides: Organization: Worcester Foundation for Biomedical Research (lynx developer); E-mail:; Reference: Gregory J. Rosmaita
Klaus Weide: Organization: Lynx Developer; E-mail:kweide@tezcat.com; Reference:Gregory J. Rosmaita
Wayne Buttles: Organization: Lynx Developer; E-mail:buttles@wsb.champlain.edu; Reference: Gregory J. Rosmaita
Kelly Ford: Organization: WebWatch; E-mail:kford@teleport.com; Reference: Al Gilman
Mary Zajicek: Organization:; E-mail: mzajicek@brookes.ac.uk; Reference:

W3C Dependencies

(WAI) Protocols & Formats WG (PFWG public page):: UAWG provides input on accessibility requirements with regard to W3C technologies for which PFWG manages dependencies;; Co-Chairs: Al Gilman and Daniel Dardailler
(WAI) Web Content Accessibility Guidelines WG: UAWG ensures that the "until user agent" clauses in WCAG are addressed in user agents. Refer to coordination issues with Web Content Guidelines.; Co-Chairs: Chuck Letourneau and Gregg Vanderheiden,
(WAI) Authoring Tool Guidelines WG: UAWG coordinates on common component of user interface accessibility; Chair: Jutta Treviranus; Discussed 1 December teleconf. No resolution.
(WAI) Education & Outreach WG: EOWG will assist in promoting awareness & implementation of User Agent Accessibility Guidelines; Chair: Judy Brewer; 2 December call for review to EO WG
CSS/FP WG (CSS public page): UAWG will provide input on accessibility requirements in CSS; Discussed at 29 November CSS teleconf
DOM WG (DOM public page): UAWG will provide input on accessibility requirements for DOM; DOM comments
I18N Working Group: The I18N WG offered to review the Guidelines.; Comments from Martin Dürst: I18N Part I, I18N Part II, I18N Part III; Mobile Access IG comments
HTML WG (HTML public page): UAWG will provide input on potential improvements to XHTML accessibility features.; Comment from Steven Pemberton Another comment from Steven Pemberton
Mobile Access IG: UAWG and Mobile Access IG will coordinate to ensure consistent approaches on guidelines development and on CC/PP (Composite Capability Preferences Profile);; Mobile Access IG comments
MathML WG (MathML public page): UAWG will provide input on accessibility requirements for MathML
SYMM WG (SYMM public page): UAWG will provide input on accessibility requirements in SMIL; SYMM WG comments.
Voice Browsing WG (Voice Browser public page): UAWG will provide input on accessibility requirements in Voice Browsing .; 2 December: Jim Larson sends call for review to Voice WG (Member only link).