W3C

XSL Working Group Patent Disclosures

The following statements are the patent disclosures and license commitments associated with the XSLT 2.0 and XPath 2.0 specifications as of July 10, 2002 and provided by members of the XSLT Working Group as required by W3C procedure.

W3C does not take a position regarding the validity or scope of any intellectual property right or other rights that might be claimed to pertain to the implementation or use of the technology, nor the extent to which any license under such rights might or might not be available. Copyright of the XSLT 2.0 and XPath 2.0 specifications and other WG deliverables is vested in theW3C.

Patent Statements for XSL specifications

This table summarizes patent statements for XSL that were made by XSL WG members in good standing. Members were asked to provide patent disclosures when they joined the Working Group. The 'license summary' column is a W3C Team characterization of the Member's statement into one of three general types of licenses: 1) Royalty-free, 2) Reasonable and non-discriminatory terms (RAND), or 3) no statement regarding IPR has been made. Members who offered a royalty free license were not required to declare patents. This summary is not offered to suggest the exact licensing terms. The precise terms of any licence, however, are governed entirely by the Member's statement. Please note that the links to the original IPR statements are only available to W3C members, but the statements themselves are available below.

Member Company

IPR Claims

License Summary
Philips None Known No statement
IBM [Team only] [Team only]
Bob Lojek None Known No statement
Pageflex None Known No statement
Arbortext None Known No statement
Software AG None No statement
Sun Microsystems None Known No statement
Novell None Known No statement
Microsoft [Team Only] [Team only]
Zarella Rendon (Invited Expert) None Royalty Free
AOL Time Warner None Known No statement
SAP Labs None Known No statement
Oracle Corp. [Member Only] [Member only]
Markup Technology None Royalty-Free
Health Level 7 None No statement
Evan Lenz (Invited Expert) None Known No statement
Jeni Tennison (Invited Expert) None No statement
ISOGEN International None Known No statement

Provided patent statements for the documents produced by the XSL WG

Intalio, Bob Lojek (AC Rep), 17 September 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I do not have any intellectual property rights relating to XSL.

9 July 2002 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

[X] I am not aware of any Philips intellectual property rights relating to XSL

Arbortext, Paul Grosso (AC Rep), 14 Feb 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I do not have personal knowledge of any IPR claims held by Arbortext regarding XSL as of the date of the submission of this statement.

XYZFind Corp, Bob Lord (AC Rep), 4 March 2002

To the best of my knowledge, we do not have intellectual property rights relating to XSL Working Group.

Software AG, Martin Meijsen (AC Rep), 30 September 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

We do not have intellectual property rights relating to XSL

Oracle Corp., Donald Deutsch (AC Rep), 6 March 2002 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

[Member only]

Zarella Rendon (Invited Expert), 11 March 2002 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

I, Zarella Rendon, will offer Royalty-Free Licenses to any Essential Claims owned or controlled by myself necessary to implement the specification(s) or "Note" produced by XSL working group or any W3C Recommendation-track or Recommendation-level specification based on work done in XSL working group. I expressly reserve all other rights it may have.

The definitions of "Essential Claims," "Member," "Affiliate," "RAND License," and "Royalty-Free License" in effect for the above statement are those found in the W3C Patent Policy Framework dated 16 August 2001, located at http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/WD-patent-policy-20010816/. I

do not have any IPR claims regarding work done by XSL working group.

Novell, Inc., Shon Vella, 22 April 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I do not have personal knowledge of any IPR claims held by Novell, Inc. regarding XSL as of the date of the submission of this statement.

Sun Microsystems Inc., Eduardo Gutentag (AC Rep), 12 June 2000 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

To the best of my knowledge, I believe my organization doesn't have IPR claims regarding the XSL work.

Pageflex, Inc. (Andrew Greene), 25 July 2000 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

To the best of my knowlege, we do not have intellectual property rights relating to XSL.

AOL Time Warner, Ray Whitmer (AC Rep), 29 July 2002 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

I am not personally aware of any AOL intellectual property rights relating to XSLT/XPath. This knowledge does not represent any search or solicitation for IPR within the company.

Health Level 7, Paul V. Biron (AC Rep), 30 July 2002 [w3c-archive@w3.org]

We do not have intellectual property rights relating to XSL

SAP AG, Franz-Josef Fritz (AC Rep), 26 June 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I do not have personal knowledge of any IPR claims held by SAP regarding the XSL and XSLT.

Markup Technology Ltd., Henry Thompson (AC Rep), 17 Jan 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

Markup Technology Ltd. will offer Royalty-Free Licences to any Essential Claims owned or controlled by Markup Technology necessary to implement any W3C Recommendation-track or Recommendation-level specification based on work done in the XML Core, XML Schema and XSL Working Groups, but only to the extent that would be necessary to implement them. Markup Technology expressly reserves all other rights it may have.

The definitions of the phrases 'Royalty-Free Licence' and 'Essential Claim' in effect for the above statement are those found in the W3C Patent Policy Framework dated 16 August 2001, located at http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/WD-patent-policy-20010816/.

I do not have personal knowledge of any IPR claims held by Markup Technology regarding work done by the XML Core, XML Schema and XSL Working Groups.

IBM, David Fallside (former AC Rep), 2 June 2000 [w3c-xsl-wg-call@w3.org]

[Team only]

Microsoft, David Turner (AC Rep), 12 June 2000 [w3c-xsl-wg-call@w3.org]

[Team only]

Evan Lenz (Invited Expert), 1 August 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I am not aware of any intellectual property rights I might have relating to XSL.

Jeni Tennison (Invited Expert), 20 September 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

I do not have any intellectual property rights relating to XSL.

ISOGEN International, George Kondrach (AC Rep), 26 Nov 2002 [patent-issues@w3.org]

On behalf of ISOGEN International, LLC I do not have personal knowledge of any IPR claims held by ISOGEN International, LLC regarding XSL as of the date of the submission of this statement.


Max Froumentin
$Id: Disclosures.html,v 1.13 2002/11/27 10:09:12 mf Exp $