W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT Profile

20 July 2022

Attendees

Present
Ben_Francis, Ege_Korkan, Kaz_Ashimura, Michael_Lagally, Michael_McCool, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
Lagally
Scribe
Ege, kaz

Meeting minutes

Minutes Review

<kaz> July-13

Ege: the initials can be replaced

Kaz: Done, please refresh

Lagally: then we can publish

schedule

<kaz> wg-2021-extension-plan.md

Lagally: looking at the profiles, we should feature freeze today
… CR after testfest

Ben: I think we need to extend this, spec is not ready

McCool: start with thinking how much we can push it

Kaz: two possible options here
… 1. publishing a smaller stable spec this period or
… 2. publishing a full stable spec next Charter period
… the second option requires us to include it into the new Charter

(some more discussion)

McCool: could focus on some specific protocols, etc.
… we need to think about what to be done during this period

Lagally: we have to put all the remaining issues on the table
… and think about which to be deferred

McCool: right

Lagally: let's try to distinguish issues

Call logistics

Lagally: proposal of merging the Architecture call and the Profile call

Lagally: I would propose merging the arch and profile calls

Kaz: you mean just for one hour, either this slot or Thursday?

Lagally: I'm flexible

Ben: I can work only one day per week

Lagally: another possibility would be to start 1h earlier

Lagally: we reuse the existing slot and move discussion slot to wednesdays that concern ben

Ege: thursday slot is annoying for me

Lagally: what about starting an hour later on thursday

<mlagally> proposal: 2 hour slot on Thursday 11am UTC-1pm UTC,

Kaz: given the current two slots, one on Wednesday (the Profile call now) and another on Thursday (the Architecture call) are OK by all, I'd suggest we simply continue use those slots for a while until the Architecture spec is really finalized.

McCool: we can wait for the CR transition of arch. btw, Kaz, are you available at the proposed time above?

Kaz: I cannot make the second hour

McCool: we can start earlier today and move chairs call as well

Lagally: let's do a doodle poll

Issues

Issue 246

<kaz> Issue 246 - Refine assertions around 3xx redirect responses

Ben: I was surprised to see this text

Lagally: let's see the text

McCool: we can say that don't do 3xx unless it is for security

Lagally: is the behavior on 3xx well defined?

Lagally: for now, it seems safer to remove this assertion

Ben: these codes already have a meaning by the HTTP spec

<benfrancis> List of 3xx responses https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status#redirection_messages

PRs

PR 93

<kaz> PR 93 - WIP: reworking data model section

Lagally: this is a tracker like PR, it will never be merged

PR 119

<kaz> PR 119 - Add timestamps to event protocol binding - closes #100

Ben: this is simple and follows the recommendation of the SSE

Ege: I think that it is not good that two event profiles have different payload requirements

Lagally: that is another discussion, we can do talk about this later

Ben: ege's point is that PR 235 needs to be revisited

<benfrancis> Cloud Events issue: https://github.com/w3c/wot-profile/issues/126

<benfrancis> Suggest revisiting https://github.com/w3c/wot-profile/pull/235

PR 235

<kaz> PR 235 - CloudEvents as message payload format for WebHooks

Lagally: we can add this to the agenda

Ege: I think cloudevents in wot as a greenfield proposal is fundamentally wrong

Lagally: we should not open this discussion now, do it next meeting

Kaz: given we only have 5 more minutes, I'd suggest we open a new issue about this and deal with the issue next week.

Ben: I agree with Ege's points

Lagally: I will put this issue 126 in the next agenda

<kaz> Issue 126 - Dependency on Cloud Events

PR 121

<kaz> PR 121 - Add Discovery section to HTTP Baseline Profile - closes #112

Ben: My main proposal is that a TD should have a HTTP URL

Lagally: aob?

<kaz> (none)

<kaz> [adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 192 (Tue Jun 28 16:55:30 2022 UTC).