Meeting minutes
White paper maintenance
[xfq shares his screen]
QingAn: We also have a version of the white paper on GitHub, is this version identical with the version on Tencent Docs?
xfq: Our previous decision was to write it in here Tencent Docs now, and then convert it to a GitHub pull request for review by the whole group.
QingAn: do we have any update for the white paper?
Dan_Zhou: I haven't reviewed the update yet
… I will do it this week
QingAn: previously the TAG asked the origin question
https://
QingAn: we haven't defined origin in the white paper
… do you think we need to add something about origin in the white paper?
… it's more related to the security and privacy section
<QingAn> When a Miniapp is launched what origin can it be said to have, with regard to the web's security model? That would seem to be important from a lifecycle point of view.
Dan_Zhou: I don't know what origin means in your description
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Glossary/Origin
QingAn: previously we wrote the hosting app or OS is responsible for the security of the miniapp, but I'm not sure it's enough to answer the question from the TAG
Zitao_Wang: I think the origin issue is a common question about our work
… martin and I discussed this issue
… in the Addressing and Packaging specs we also need to consider this issue
… I agree with you that we need to reflect this idea in the white paper
… I volunteer to work with Dan to work on the security part
Dan_Zhou: I think the "origin" concept is like our domain check in the network request API
QingAn: maybe you could take the action to update this section?
Dan_Zhou: OK
xfq: we have some comments in Tencent Docs
[Discuss the comments in Tencent Docs]
QingAn: my suggestion is we finish the update next week
… hope to have a rough consensus to publish this in our next meeting
martin: I can add some additional text to the 'MiniApp in the Globe' section
QingAn: we can rename the 'MiniApp in the Globe' section to 'MiniApp Standardization in the Globe'
Zitao_Wang: I agree
Lifecycle
QingAn: I made some pull requests
[QingAn shares his screen]
https://github.com/w3c/miniapp-lifecycle/pull/18
QingAn: added two sentences about Service Workers and Page Visibility
xfq: this is not normative text, shall we point to the explainer in the White Paper?
Zitao_Wang: agree, it shall be good enough
https://github.com/w3c/miniapp-lifecycle/pull/21
QingAn: any comments?
xfq: I see that this is a read-only value? can it be changed? is it still "by default"?
QingAn: oh, it can be deleted
martin: if you want to keep it, we can add a note for clarification
… there are many examples there
Martin: it will be useful for the developers
QingAn: thank you for the suggestion, maybe I should add a note
https://github.com/w3c/miniapp-lifecycle/pull/19
[QingAn describes the PR]
QingAn: we can keep this open and give people time to think about it
Manifest
https://
martin: ^ wording fixes
https://
martin: ^ split the Privacy and Security sections
<martin> https://
[martin introduces the changes in the PR]
martin: saw questions from xfq
… haven't replied yet
xfq: is changing the UI more for security or for privacy?
martin: shall we move it to the Sec Consideration section?
xfq: maybe?
martin: it's more about security. If you want, I can move it to the Sec section?
xfq: yes...
QingAn: what's the plan to do a CfC in the group?
martin: it's ready to review when I finish some minor updates today
Packaging
https://github.com/w3c/miniapp-packaging/pull/45
martin: Fixed ReSpec warning
… unless you have any objection I plan to merge it
https://github.com/w3c/miniapp-packaging/pull/47
martin: will update this PR today
… after merging this we can discuss the CSP issue
Notes
QingAn: updates on Addressing and Widget Requirements?
Dan_Zhou: two editorial PR to Addressing from xfq
… I have merged them
xfq: will send transition request for Addressing and Widget Requirements
TPAC 2022 hybrid meeting
QingAn: survey from W3C
… online or F2F?
… survey is about whether we can meet in person
Zitao_Wang: need some time to investigate
… we can discuss this in the next meeting
<QingAn> https://
https://
QingAn: xfq could you send the questions to the group?
xfq: OK
AOB
QingAn: next meeting?
<martin> +1
<martin> (March 24)
March 24 (12:00 UTC)