W3C

WoT Use Cases

14 December 2021

Attendees

Present
Kaz_Ashimura, Michael_Lagally, Michael_McCool, Ryuichi_Matsukura, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
Lagally
Scribe
kaz

Meeting minutes

Minutes

Dec-7

Lagally: (goes through the minutes)
… any problems?

(none; approved)

Conexxus use cases

PR 156

PR 156 - Insert digital-twin-use-case.md and use-case-opc-ua-binding.md into index.html|

Lagally: 2 things to do
… merge this PR itself
… then add Qing An to the contributor
… objections?

(none)

merged

subtopic PR 158

PR 158 - EdgeX Liaison Section

McCool: asked Farshid for comments, and got some
… please give me 10 more mins for some fix

Lagally: ok

PR 159 and PR 160

PR 159 - Presentation - Retail Pseudo Device (Conexxus)

PR 160 - Presentation - Retail User Stories - Priorities (Conexxus)

Lagally: (adds "Presentation" to PR 160)
… uploading slides

PR 161

PR 161 - Add 9 retail md files of conexxus into index.html

Lagally: thanks for working on this, Mizushima-san
… we have two "Retail" sections
… why don't we merge those two sections?
… section 2.5 and 2.6

Mizushima: so the content of 2.6 should go into 2.5?

Lagally: right
… will do the fix later
… any objections to merge this?

(no objections)

merged

PR 163

PR 163 - uploading on behalf of David Ezell, Conexxus

merged

PR 164

- integrating Conexxus

Lagally: some conflicts...

McCool: we did review the use case descriptions during the Security calls

Lagally: (skims the changes and resolve the conflicts)
… would merge this

merged

PR 165

PR 165 - adding digital microscopes

Lagally: (some conflicts)
… (resolves the conflicts)
… will work on the conflicts offline later

PR 166

PR 166 - add digital-microscopes.md into index.html

Mizushima: similar issue to PR 165

Lagally: need to look into the detail

PR 165 (revisited)

Lagally: (goes through the diff)
… (generates another PR for digital microscopes)

PR 167 - Update index.html

Lagally: (merges PR 167)

PR 168 in Contributors

PR 168 - Update index.html

Lagally: (adds Qing An)

McCool: (also suggests Farshid)

merged

PR 158

PR 158 - EdgeX Liaison Section

McCool: ready to merge now

merged

PR 169

PR 169 - commenting liaison sections without contents

merged

ack

Updated draft

WoT Use Cases and Requirements ED

Lagally: wondering about the red frame for the W3C logo

Kaz: that's caused by the new CSS setting for ED
… no impact for the publication version, e.g., WD and Note

Lagally: (merges section "2.5 Retail" and "2.6 Retail-2")

McCool: need some more edit...

Lagally: (creates a new PR)

PR 170 - merging retail sections

merged

McCool: one thing we should discuss is orchestration
… need to look into the definition of "Virtual Thing"

Kaz: btw, the merged "2.5 Retail" section is a bit odd
… we need to handle the table appropriately

McCool: yeah
… need to generate a small paragraph for the table
… would suggest comment out the table tentatively, and let's ask Conexxus about how to handle the table

Lagally: ok

PR 171 - removing table for now

Lagally: and McCool, could you generate another issue on how to deal with the table?

<mlagally_> proposal: approve the current editors draft for group wide review and as a candidate for publication

<mlagally_> proposal: approve the current editors draft for WoT WG/IG group wide review and as a candidate for publication

Kaz: to make sure, not "Wide Review" by horizontal groups but WoT groups' review for publication. right?

Lagally: right

<mlagally_> proposal: approve the current editors draft at https://github.com/w3c/wot-usecases for WoT WG/IG group wide review and as a candidate for publication

McCool: btw, just created an issue on the table

<McCool> https://github.com/w3c/wot-usecases/issues/172

RESOLUTION: approve the current editors draft at https://github.com/w3c/wot-usecases for WoT WG/IG group wide review and as a candidate for publication

Issue 172 - Revise introductory Retail use case - table, etc.

Lagally: thanks a lot for your contributions!
… aob?

Sebastian: would like to talk about OPC liaison during the main call tomorrow

Lagally: ok

[adjourned]

Summary of resolutions

  1. approve the current editors draft at https://github.com/w3c/wot-usecases for WoT WG/IG group wide review and as a candidate for publication
Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 185 (Thu Dec 2 18:51:55 2021 UTC).