<jeffh> hm, having headset troubles w/mic
<jeffh> hear me now?
<scribe> scribenick: weiler
apowers: I did a diff. not a CR build
weiler: i need the version with
the CR boilerplate
... I'll send instruction to adam
agl: fine by me
... trivial.
akshay: fine.
selfissued: fine
apowers: will merge
akshay will merge.
jfontana: ...
... sam proposed you keep doing what you're doing and figure
we'll work out details in the background.
jeffh: yes.
jeffh: I'm not going to get
anything done this week. I'll be back next week.
... I want to work on this one. needs polishing.
jfontana: those were the only 3 PRs under PR milestone.
jeffh: we need to triage 7 issues w/ no milestone
jeffh: this needs to get fixed.
it will break things.
... this is the kind of bug we get if we move too fast.
jcj: need to decide, change spec, change implementations, and do backward-compatibility
jeffh: do you agree with the two options?
jcj: not sure. but I see the problem
agl: no opinion re: answer. .... this is unfortunate, but it's hardly untrodden territory.
jcj: right answer might be member name without the dash. and pick what we're really doing.
jeffh: haven't heard from chrome or edge.
agl: need to gather chrome and edge and anyone else who wants to weigh in. and we need to pick.
agl & ahskay will explore.
jcj: I can do code changes at the end of the month
jfontana: can we do this on list before the next mtg?
jeffh: this is not highest priority;
sam: do you want to do a temporary patch?
jeffh: I'd do an inline issue
jfontana: sounds good.
jcj: +1
jefh: i'll do it.
jfontana: does this affect CR?
sam: no. just make sure adam generates the doc w/o this pull.
sam: that's already tagged for PR
agl: this may be a
misunderstanding on my part. i thought these were required,
when they're optional. might not be a problem.
... I think we should close it.
... default is optional
selfissued: close it.
agl: I'll write up something and close. and if emil wants to reopen it, he can.
sam: should this be with a PR milestone
jeffh: once this CR ships, should milestione to be moved from PR to Rec?
sam: my understanding is that
breaking changes require an eclusion opportunity.
... I don't see why 1004 would require that, thought
akshay: @@. would like google's opinion now.
christiaan: let's close this and move on. this is supposed to give you insight into the.... leave it the way it is.
selfissued: the functionality giri wants is not specific to safetynet. as described, this is misguided.
john_bradley: agree. removing this now will just cause us grief.
christiaan will write summary and close.
jeffh: this is reasonable. mark for PR.
selfissued: assign it to someone?
john_bradley: this is a bigger
problem than webauthn
... this is not about the authenticator. this is about the RP
having a different response.. in case someone is testing for
the existence of accounts.
... we could put something in. but this is very generic.
sam: this is far beyond our scope, but no harm in doing in.
john_bradley: I would not belabor
it.
... dashlane does it wrong.
agl: maybe if acct doesn't exist, they respond w/ randomly generated cred.id?
selfissued: can we file this v. tag doc and not here?
sam: no; think we should include it here.
agl: if RP really cares, suggest random?
chistiaan: some RPs don't care.
john_bradley: unless you track them v. accounts, attacker could see if they change.
agl: psedu randomfunc based on name
akshay: this is a general problem....
jfontana: add guidance and close it.
agl: if someone writes it. ....
selfissued: we should assign it or close it.
many voices say close.
sam: I think closing is wrong.
john_bradley: will write a sentence and close.
selfissued: should not just close.
adjourned.
This is scribe.perl Revision: 1.152 of Date: 2017/02/06 11:04:15 Check for newer version at http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/~checkout~/2002/scribe/ Guessing input format: Irssi_ISO8601_Log_Text_Format (score 1.00) Succeeded: s/agl/christiaan/ Succeeded: s/christiann/christiaan/ Succeeded: s/no/not/ Present: agl akshay christiaan jfontana john_Bradley LukeWalker selfissued apowers jeffh jcj_moz Found ScribeNick: weiler Inferring Scribes: weiler Found Date: 01 Aug 2018 People with action items: WARNING: IRC log location not specified! (You can ignore this warning if you do not want the generated minutes to contain a link to the original IRC log.)[End of scribe.perl diagnostic output]