Date: 11 December 2017
See also the Agenda and the IRC Log
Present: michaelS, ivan, renato, CarolineB, benws
Regrets: Linda, Victor
Chair: Renato
Scribe(s): CarolineB
renato: Welcome to our 78th Meeting of POE ;-)
renato: https://www.w3.org/2017/11/27-poe-minutes
CarolineB: approved
renato: we have 2 sets of test results. TR coming in
benws: we have some issues with SHACL shapes, but will
resolve these. Evaluation tests are coming out correct
… should we add the two additional test Michael suggested?
ivan: we need two implementations unless they are in the same feature
michaelS: they only extend some variants. There’s no urgent need.
ivan: and the extra vocabulary tests?
renato: yes, we’ve done those (See link)
renato: this url appears on the two documents - its
automatically generated from the Google doc
… when we’ve finished that we could just add the vocab test cases so there
is just one url
ivan: 2 urls would not be a problem as long as it is clear
benws: I should be able to update the sheet tomorrow
ivan: as soon as that’s been updated I can make a
transition
… is tomorrow realistic?
michaelS: yes, that’s ok for me
ivan: then I’ll issue the request tomorrow afternoon
… then both documents have to be ready and all editorial issues that refer
to them should be finalised
… then we can go for publication on 4th January
… then that’s it. I will ask for 1 month and we can publish the docs on
10th Feb
… if we have other notes or stuff to add we could publish all of them
together
renato: that’s all good
ivan: checking that there is a partial implementation in Vienna?
renato: I’ll check with Simon (and Stuart if they’ll be writing 2.2 code)
michaelS: talking to Ben about the implementors' page and how to name the TR contributions
Proposed resolution: provided that the implementation report is extended with the implementation of Thomson-Reuters, the group asks the Director to approve the publication of a Proposed Rec for the model and vocab documents. (ivan)
ivan: +1
benws: +1
renato: +1
CarolineB: +1
michaelS: ++1
renato: So, we’re done!
… aob? When do we next meet?
renato: 8th Jan?
benws: we will have to discuss the best practice and formal semantics documents but 8th may be a bit early
ivan: best pratice - yes. Should we update and republish the requirements doc?
renato: looking at what’s between now and end of Feb,
its the best practices one.
… Ben and Victor will go ahead with that?
benws: If we do 15th Jan then there will be ore
renato: that’s the next meeting date then