RDF Data Shapes Working Group Resolutions

Below is a compilation of the resolutions made by the RDF Data Shapes Working Group as of 14 12 2016 (DD MM YYYY).

2016/12/14 - Close ISSUE-209 as addressed by https://github.com/w3c/data-shapes/commit/bec7b6852529acc80954dbc38cf4e435861238a2 plus restructure of Focus node and Shapes sections by describing the commonalities, e.g. every constraint has a severity
2016/12/14 - Close ISSUE-212 as resolved by https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0129.html and replace the term "focus node constraint" with "shape" throughout the document.
2016/12/14 - Close ISSUE-197 as resolved by https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0130.html
2016/12/14 - Close ISSUE-211 as already discussed (extensively) and too late for such a fundamental change, see https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0117.html
2016/12/14 - Open ISSUE-215, ISSUE-216, ISSUE-217
2016/12/14 - Approve minutes of the 30 Nov 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/11/30-shapes-minutes.html
2016/11/30 - reserve the use of MUST to requirements on the processor, use "is" or "are" to describe the language, and add a section on expectated input graphs and treatment of errors (or not)
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-210, as addressed in the latest editor's draft, where the definitions of expected types have been updated and explicitly exclude the troublesome values
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-207 as addressed in the latest editor's draft as explained in https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0115.html
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-205 as addressed by the recent introduction of sh:ValidationReport and the corresponding edits by Dimitris https://github.com/w3c/data-shapes/commit/1b38515bd5a3a3c6829bd9765e0df2878a871314 adding that this is the minimum requirement and other information can be added to the report
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-201 as addressed: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0079.html
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-198 as addressed by https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0083.html and https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0094.html, changing "implies" to "means" in the reference to rdf:langString
2016/11/30 - Close ISSUE-213 as duplicate of ISSUE-209
2016/11/30 - Approve minutes of the 23 Nov 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/11/23-shapes-minutes.html
2016/11/23 - Amend resolution on ISSUE-196 to "Close ISSUE-196, (1) deleting filter shape and (2) adding a boolean flag sh:disabled which (if true) means that all focus nodes are considered conforming/valid."
2016/11/23 - Separate the target* parsing from validation with a structure like the revision suggested above
2016/11/23 - Rename sht:node to sht:focus
2016/11/23 - Remove the "sht:data-format sht:TURTLE" triple.
2016/11/23 - Open ISSUE-197, ISSUE-198, ISSUE-201, ISSUE-202, ISSUE-203, ISSUE-204, ISSUE-205, ISSUE-207, ISSUE-208, ISSUE-209, ISSUE-210, ISSUE-211, ISSUE-212, ISSUE-213
2016/11/23 - Approve minutes of the 16 Nov 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/11/16-shapes-minutes.html
2016/11/16 - make calls 2h, starting at 8am Eastern
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-187, as resolved as part of ISSUE-178
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-176 due to lack of time and out of scope
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-188, replace instances of "validates" meaning "is true" with a version of the verb "conforms"
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-189, adopting Dimitris and Karen's proposal: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Nov/0051.html
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-186, adding new properties as proposed by Holger in https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Oct/0040.html
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-180, accepting Holger's proposed changes (in the issue description)
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-185 and ISSUE-192 as now irrelevant
2016/11/16 - Close ISSUE-196, deleting filter shape and instead, adding a boolean flag sh:disabled which (if true) means that a shape or constraint is ignored (i.e., any node is considered conforming/valid).
2016/11/16 - open ISSUE-195 and ISSUE-196
2016/11/16 - Approve minutes of the 9 Nov 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/11/09-shapes-minutes.html
2016/11/09 - Close ISSUE-184, agreeing that on property constraints with sh:path the value nodes are a set with no duplicate value nodes.
2016/11/09 - Close ISSUE-183, accepting the edits made by the editors to eliminate the term undefined which alters the definition of the sh:hasShape SPARQL function
2016/11/09 - close issue-140 by adding some consistent style and a link to say that target* is not needed for invocations by API
2016/11/09 - Open ISSUE-194
2016/11/09 - Virtual F2F scheduled on 16 Nov 08:00-12:00 EST
2016/11/09 - Change time of regular weekly call to 8:30am US Eastern
2016/11/09 - Approve minutes of the 2 Nov 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/11/02-shapes-minutes
2016/11/02 - close ISSUE-191 accepting <https://github.com/w3c/data-shapes/commit/292f12936181ca2d3fd5c096a7880f2de6054f02> modulo changing 2119 keywords
2016/11/02 - open ISSUE-193
2016/11/02 - Approve minutes of the 26 Oct 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/10/26-shapes-minutes
2016/10/26 - Close ISSUE-158, requiring implementations to check well-formedness for built-in datatypes covered in SPARQL 1.1 Query for sh:datatype
2016/10/26 - Close ISSUE-146 and ISSUE-190 as no longer relevant given the removal of sh:hasShape
2016/10/26 - Open ISSUE-192
2016/10/26 - Approve minutes of the 19 Oct 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/10/19-shapes-minutes.html
2016/10/19 - Close ISSUE-131, removing sh:hasShape
2016/10/19 - Open ISSUE-190, ISSUE-191
2016/10/19 - Move weekly calls back to Wednesday
2016/10/19 - Approve minutes of the 11 Oct 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/10/11-shapes-minutes.html
2016/10/11 - Close ISSUE-178, accepting the proposal to allow sh:message to be used in core on a constraint to override the implementation default message
2016/10/11 - Open ISSUE-186, ISSUE-187, ISSUE-188, ISSUE-189
2016/10/11 - Approve minutes of the 4 Oct 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/10/04-shapes-minutes.html
2016/10/04 - Retain the current Editor's Draft wording (modulo language cleanup) of "3.1.1 Recursive shapes", and table ISSUE-22 to whatever extent it is related
2016/10/04 - Open ISSUE-180, ISSUE-181, ISSUE-182, ISSUE-183, ISSUE-184, ISSUE-185
2016/10/04 - Approve minutes of the 27 Sept 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/09/27-shapes-minutes.html
2016/09/27 - Close ISSUE-155 as handled by the current draft
2016/09/27 - Close ISSUE-142 as addressed by the Terminology section and its use throughout the document, separate issues should be raised against specific terminology issues
2016/09/27 - Close ISSUE-107 leaving annotation properties as currently specified
2016/09/27 - Close ISSUE-106 as addressed by this change: https://github.com/w3c/data-shapes/compare/da0f0fbdc4...8e8401ab9d
2016/09/27 - Close ISSUE-163, as addressed
2016/09/27 - Open ISSUE-179
2016/09/27 - despite the challenges it represents for Pano to attend, we will have our calls on Tuesday
2016/09/27 - Approve minutes of the 21 Sept 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/09/21-shapes-minutes.html
2016/09/21 - Open ISSUE-178
2016/09/21 - Close ISSUE-105 adopting the so called "decomposed prefixes in Turtle" proposal drafted by Holger in https://rawgit.com/w3c/data-shapes/bf5efb571196cf3c6b63137302c9c13a369e3466/shacl/index.html#sparql-prefixes
2016/09/21 - Close ISSUE-71, as is - not enough time left to tackle this issue in this version of SHACL
2016/09/21 - next meeting on Tuesday 27
2016/09/21 - Approve minutes of the 14 Sept 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/09/14-shapes-minutes.html
2016/09/14 - Close ISSUE-137, adding sh:languageIn as outlined in Holger's email https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Sep/0033.html
2016/09/14 - Open ISSUE-177
2016/09/14 - Approve minutes of the 8 Sept 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/09/08-shapes-minutes.html
2016/09/08 - Future meetings Wed 0900 US Eastern
2016/09/08 - Approve minutes of the 1 Sept 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/09/01-shapes-minutes
2016/09/01 - close issue-150 based on previous two resolutions
2016/09/01 - the severity of violations of nested shapes is determined only by the severity of the constraint in which the violation occured
2016/09/01 - Approve minutes of the 25 August 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/08/25-shapes-minutes
2016/08/25 - SHACL does not treat sh:Violation differently from other severities to determine if a node validates against a shape
2016/08/25 - open ISSUE-176
2016/08/25 - publish updated Abstract Syntax Draft as shortname shacl-abstact-syntax
2016/08/25 - Approve minutes of the 11 August 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/08/11-shapes-minutes.html
2016/08/11 - Publish Abstract syntax draft as First Public Working Draft (FPWD)
2016/08/11 - Publish latest editor's draft of SHACL
2016/08/11 - Approve minutes of the 4 August 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/08/04-shapes-minutes.html
2016/08/04 - Close ISSUE-169, rename sh:targetProperty to sh:targetObjectsOf and sh:targetInverseProperty to sh:targetSubjectsOf
2016/08/04 - Close ISSUE-175, changing "scope" to "target"
2016/08/04 - Approve minutes of the 28 July 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/07/28-shapes-minutes.html
2016/07/28 - Close issue 141, mixed ranges can be expressed with sh:or
2016/07/28 - Remove sh:datatypeIn and sh:classIn components as they can be expressed with sh:or
2016/07/28 - Close ISSUE-135, no longer relevant
2016/07/28 - Close ISSUE-133, based on the series of related resolutions
2016/07/28 - Merge Shape and NodeConstraint
2016/07/28 - Close ISSUE-134 as no longer relevant
2016/07/28 - Open ISSUE-175
2016/07/28 - Approve minutes of the 21 July 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/07/21-shapes-minutes.html
2016/07/21 - Close ISSUE-139, adopt Holger's compromise proposal https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Jul/0062.html
2016/07/21 - Approve minutes of the 14 July 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/07/14-shapes-minutes.html
2016/07/14 - Approve minutes of the 7 July 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/07/07-shapes-minutes.html
2016/07/07 - Close ISSUE-52, put Eric's proposed abstract syntax into a Working Draft (Editor's draft)
2016/07/07 - Close ISSUE-166, keeping the spec as one document
2016/07/07 - Close ISSUE-65, no longer relevant given all the changes made to the draft
2016/07/07 - Close ISSUE-41, based on previous resolution and latest editor's draft
2016/07/07 - Close ISSUE-132 as no longer relevant, ?predicate is no longer used in the latest editor's draft
2016/07/07 - Approve minutes of the 30 June 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/06/30-shapes-minutes.html
2016/06/30 - change PropertyConstraint and InversePropertyConstraint to one type of Constraint with either a predicate (which implies arcs-out) or a path. The path does not include * or + and cardinalities on the resulting node value set are satisfied by combination of cardinalities on the steps. Exact syntax (e.g. nested paths, behavior of bnodes) to be resolved.
2016/06/30 - open issue-171, issue-172
2016/06/30 - open issue-170
2016/06/30 - Approve minutes of the 23 June 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/06/23-shapes-minutes.html
2016/06/23 - we'll wait for the community to come up with an erratum for SPARQL we can use regarding EXISTS, if this doesn't pan out we will have to investigate defining our own extension instead
2016/06/23 - Close ISSUE-168, without adding min/maxInstanceCount as not motivated enough
2016/06/23 - Open ISSUE-169
2016/06/23 - Approve minutes of the 16 June 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/06/16-shapes-minutes.html
2016/06/16 - Change resolution of ISSUE-128, dropping sh:defautValueType, without mandating the rdf:type triple on constraints
2016/06/16 - Close ISSUE-22, leaving recursion to implementations
2016/06/16 - Open ISSUE-168
2016/06/09 - add property paths to SHACL, using an rdf list based syntax
2016/06/09 - Approve minutes of the 2 June 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/06/02-shapes-minutes.html
2016/06/02 - Close ISSUE-148, resolved given previous resolutions
2016/06/02 - Delete AllObjectsScope and AllSubjectsScope from Core, not to become Advanced. Anyone who wants this functionality is left to write their own SPARQL.
2016/06/02 - Approve minutes of the 26 May 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/05/26-shapes-minutes.html
2016/05/26 - For propertyScope and inverse property scopes, do not use sh:scope but the dedicated properties sh:scopeProperty and sh:scopeInverseProperty that point to a property directly. e.g. ex:shape sh:propertyScope ex:myPredicate
2016/05/26 - sparql constraints will be defined with the sh:sparql predicate and rename the existing sh:sparql to sh:select and sh:ask
2016/05/26 - Simplify sh:constraint and allow only sh:NodeConstraints, SPARQL constraints will be defined with a separate property
2016/05/26 - Close ISSUE-160, renaming sh:valueShape to sh:shape, adding sh:NodeConstraint to its context
2016/05/26 - Publish current SHACL editor's draft to TR space
2016/05/26 - Send Peter's proposed response as the WG's response to Tom's comments https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016May/0224.html
2016/05/26 - Open ISSUE-163, ISSUE-166
2016/05/26 - Approve minutes of the 19 May 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/05/19-shapes-minutes.html
2016/05/19 - Approve minutes of the 12 May 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/05/12-shapes-minutes.html
2016/05/12 - amend property constraint and inverse property constraint to take logical operations sh:and, sh:or, sh:not
2016/05/12 - Close ISSUE-78, dropping sh:abstract
2016/05/12 - Open ISSUE-160
2016/05/12 - Approve minutes of the 5 May 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/05/05-shapes-minutes.html
2016/05/05 - Close ISSUE-123, dropping sh:directType
2016/05/05 - Open ISSUE-158
2016/05/05 - Approve minutes of the 28 April 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/04/28-shapes-minutes.html
2016/04/28 - Close ISSUE-110 as addressed by the current draft
2016/04/28 - Close ISSUE-126 and ISSUE-127 as no longer relevant
2016/04/28 - Open ISSUE-152, ISSUE-153, ISSUE-154, ISSUE-155, ISSUE-157
2016/04/28 - Editorial issues should have [Editorial] in the subject line and can be opened and closed by the editors and/or commenters without formal resolution from the WG
2016/04/28 - Approve minutes of the 21 April 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/04/21-shapes-minutes.html
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-124, as addressed by the current draft
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-57, group cardinality won't be addressed in this version of SHACL
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-129, as addressed by the change of sh:notEquals to sh:disjoint
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-125, as fixed in the latest draft.
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-144, addressed in the latest draft
2016/04/21 - Close ISSUE-101, as no longer relevant.
2016/04/21 - Open ISSUE-148, ISSUE-149, ISSUE-150, ISSUE-151
2016/04/21 - Approve minutes of the 14 April 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/04/14-shapes-minutes.html
2016/04/14 - it is legal to have constraint components appear multiple times within the same constraint for all single argument constraints (excluding sh:predicate)
2016/04/14 - Close ISSUE-138, saying no, we won't use rdf:Lists for property
2016/04/14 - Close ISSUE-95, adopting Proposal 3 https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/ISSUE-95:_Metamodel_simplifications#Proposal_3
2016/04/14 - Close ISSUE-143, ISSUE-145, ISSUE-147, open ISSUE-144, ISSUE-146
2016/04/14 - Approve minutes of the 7 April 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/04/07-shapes-minutes.html
2016/04/07 - Close ISSUE-96, sh:sourceTemplate fulfills this needs
2016/04/07 - Close ISSUE-136, keeping sh:equals, sh:lessThan, sh:lessThanOrEquals, changing sh:notEquals to sh:disjoint
2016/04/07 - Close ISSUE-80, adding sh:stem to the spec outlined in Eric's email https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Mar/0311.html
2016/04/07 - Approve minutes of the 31 March 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/03/31-shapes-minutes.html
2016/03/31 - Close ISSUE-99, issue has been addressed, related proposals on handling of rdf:List should be made related to ISSUE-119, which would then need to be re-opened
2016/03/31 - Open ISSUE-142: loose terminology
2016/03/31 - Approve minutes of the 24 March 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/03/24-shapes-minutes.html
2016/03/24 - Close ISSUE-130, as is - the latest draft doesn't require/assume a dataset
2016/03/24 - Reopen ISSUE-41, based on Peter's email https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Mar/0290.html
2016/03/24 - Close ISSUE-128, without action.
2016/03/24 - Open ISSUE-138 Property constraints as lists, ISSUE-139 Universal applicability, ISSUE-140 Individual validation, ISSUE-141 Mixed ranges
2016/03/24 - Approve minutes of the 17 March 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/03/17-shapes-minutes.html
2016/03/17 - Open ISSUE-134 knowing inverse, ISSUE-135 and/or syntactic sugar, ISSUE-136 Property pair names, ISSUE-137 language tag
2016/03/17 - Approve minutes of the 10 March 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/03/10-shapes-minutes.html
2016/03/10 - Close ISSUE-99, based on the related resolutions from 3 March 2016
2016/03/10 - Open ISSUE-124 sh:group, ISSUE-125 sh:NodeConstraint missing, ISSUE-126 sh:TemplateConstraint undefined, ISSUE-127 sh:TemplateScope undefined, ISSUE-128 rdfs:range, ISSUE-129 existential constraints, ISSUE-130 rdf dataset assumption, ISSUE-131 sh:hasShape ill defined, ISSUE-132 sh:predicate in constraints, ISSUE-133 syntax
2016/03/10 - Approve minutes of the 3 March 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/03/03-shapes-minutes.html
2016/03/03 - sh:NodeKind should be extended with sh:BlankNodeOrIRI, sh:BlankNodeOrLiteral, sh:IRIorLiteral
2016/03/03 - No special treaments of rdf:List and rdf:Resource at sh:class. This means that Turtle lists don't validate against sh:class rdf:List and that many nodes don't validate against rdfs:Resource.
2016/03/03 - Open ISSUE-123 DirectType syntax
2016/03/03 - Approve minutes of the 25 February 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/02/25-shapes-minutes.html
2016/02/25 - Approve minutes of the 18 February 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/02/18-shapes-minutes.html
2016/02/18 - Close ISSUE-121, the SHACL owl:Ontology include the # character
2016/02/18 - Close ISSUE-47, stating that: Not all execution environments can support $shapesGraph access, just like not all platforms have to support SPARQL extensions in general. However, for those environments that do, the spec should define $shapesGraph access and clarify that it is an optional feature. Implementations that do not support it may report a Failure. For the core built-ins, these implementations may use alternative approaches such as custom SPARQL code generators but that is left as an implementation detail.
2016/02/18 - Approve minutes of the 11 February 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/02/11-shapes-minutes.html
2016/02/11 - Close ISSUE-119, not expanding core to handle lists but adding a section on how to do so using the extension mechanism
2016/02/11 - Close ISSUE-122, as is, we can revisit this if it becomes a problem later on
2016/02/11 - Open ISSUE-121 Should the SHACL owl:Ontology include the # character
2016/02/11 - Approve minutes of the 4 February 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/02/04-shapes-minutes.html
2016/02/04 - Close ISSUE-117, dropping from Section 3.1.1 sh:class the sentence "The values of sh:class must be classes (instances of rdfs:Class)." and any assertions that sh:predicate must be an rdfs:Property
2016/02/04 - Put F2F6 on hold indefinitely, we'll have ad hoc calls instead
2016/02/04 - Approve minutes of the 28 January 2016 Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/01/28-shapes-minutes.html
2016/01/28 - Close ISSUE-118, validation results are the product of validation of the data graph only
2016/01/28 - Close ISSUE-23, based on resolution regarding ShapeClass (dropped) and implicit scopeClass
2016/01/28 - In the case where a shape is also a class, a SHACL processor MUST include all the instances of the class in the scope of the shape, exactly as if an explicit sh:scopeClass triple was present. An explicit sh:scopeClass triple is not required but MAY be included for clarity.
2016/01/28 - Close ISSUE-120 as editorial, once doc is updated specific issues may be raised
2016/01/28 - Open ISSUE-119
2016/01/28 - Approve minutes of the 21 January Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/01/21-shapes-minutes.html
2016/01/21 - Pending edits regarding issue-23 and issue-115, publish the updated SHACL draft
2016/01/21 - Change Resolution of ISSUE-115 to have sh:closed on sh:NodeConstraint instead of sh:Shape, and define sh:Closed as syntactic sugar
2016/01/21 - Publish the latest UCR Editor's draft http://w3c.github.io/data-shapes/data-shapes-ucr/
2016/01/21 - Approve minutes of the 14 January Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/01/14-shapes-minutes.html
2016/01/14 - Close ISSUE-115, adopting sh:closed on sh:Shape
2016/01/14 - Close ISSUE-49, adopting Arthur's and Peter's suggestions https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Jan/0024.html https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2016Jan/0025.html
2016/01/14 - Open ISSUE-117 and ISSUE-118
2016/01/14 - Approve minutes of the 7 January Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2016/01/07-shapes-minutes.html
2016/01/07 - drop ShapeClass
2016/01/07 - Approve minutes of the 15-17 December F2F: http://www.w3.org/2015/12/15-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/12/16-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/12/17-shapes-minutes.html
2016/01/07 - Approve minutes of the 10 December Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/12/10-shapes-minutes.html
2015/12/17 - Close ISSUE-108, the one specified way to invoke SHACL validation is an interface that takes a data graph and a shapes graph.
2015/12/16 - Open ISSUE-115
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-102, based on resolution for maxCount and leaving the question of how closed shape are specified to a separate issue
2015/12/16 - Leave SHACL as is, but create a maxCount value in the high-level language that is interpreted as the maxCount default in SHACL
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-73, no need until evidence of an actual problem, addressed with previous resolution of execution order doesn't matter
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-66 as being covered (for now) by the previous resolution. Recursion in shapes will need to cover data loops, as indicated in ISSUE-22
2015/12/16 - The starting point for recursion in SHACL is that shapes graphs with dependency loops are invalid, suitable limitations of this will be explored
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-114, adding property groups as proposed
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-113, with no action
2015/12/16 - Close ISSUE-100, add a property sh:order (datatype: xsd:decimal) to property constraints (and inverse ones), to represent the relative ordering of property constraints, for uses such as form building
2015/12/15 - Close ISSUE-109, keeping with the current spec - no wrapper function
2015/12/15 - Prohibit recursion in sh:Function
2015/12/15 - Close ISSUE-63, adding sh:hasShape as proposed understanding that if recursion is added, it will impact sh:hasShape
2015/12/15 - Arthur to draft a semantics doc for the WG to consider, that would complement the current SHACL spec
2015/12/10 - Close ISSUE-104, as proposed, using the properties sh:classIn and sh:datatypeIn, and noting that every case should be examined to see whether it deserves to have the same feature
2015/12/10 - Close ISSUE-103, accepting the proposed simplification except for closed shapes which should be treated differently
2015/12/10 - Approve minutes of the 3 December Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/12/03-shapes-minutes.html
2015/12/03 - Approve minutes of the 19 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/11/19-shapes-minutes.html
2015/11/19 - Close ISSUE-87 with two files: shacl-vocab.ttl and shacl.shacl.ttl as per Arthur Ryman's proposal http://www.w3.org/mid/CAApBiOn9eBvt99Eyu%253DjGUL9FxGHB%252B4r6%253DmPrUrwzCAHjmsQpSA%2540mail.gmail.com
2015/11/19 - Close ISSUE-112 by *within constraint* Use sh:name and sh:description for the property and rdfs:label and rdfs:comment for the constraint, renaming the issue to be specifically about rfs:label and rdfs:comment
2015/11/19 - Close ISSUE-97, adding sh:derivedValues as suggested
2015/11/19 - Open ISSUE-113, ISSUE-114
2015/11/19 - Approve minutes of the 12 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/11/12-shapes-minutes.html
2015/11/12 - Open ISSUE-111, and move question about sh:defaultValue to a separate issue
2015/11/12 - Open ISSUE-112
2015/11/12 - Approve minutes of the 5 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/11/05-shapes-minutes.html
2015/11/05 - sh:scopeNode triples need to conceptually be in the shapes graph at validation time, then close ISSUE-61
2015/11/05 - replacing sh:nodeShape with sh:scopeNode, which points from a shape to a node
2015/11/05 - Close ISSUE-88, no longer needed - sh:qualifiedValueShape can be used with a shape that applies to literals
2015/11/05 - Close ISSUE-84, node constraints are now addressed with sh:in
2015/11/05 - Open ISSUE-105, ISSUE-106, ISSUE-107, ISSUE-108, ISSUE-109, ISSUE-110
2015/11/05 - Approve minutes of the 29 October Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/10/29-shapes-minutes.html
2015/10/29 - open issue-104
2015/10/29 - Approve minutes of the 22 October Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/10/22-shapes-minutes.html
2015/10/22 - Close ISSUE-86, one can use sh:shapesGraph for this purpose
2015/10/22 - Open ISSUE-103
2015/10/22 - Approve minutes of the 15 October Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/10/15-shapes-minutes.html
2015/10/15 - Close ISSUE-98, adopting Holger's proposed changes, renaming sh:allowedValues to sh:in
2015/10/15 - Open ISSUE-102, changing the title to: missing a way to explicitly state unbound cardinality and open shapes
2015/10/15 - Approve minutes of the 8 October Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/10/08-shapes-minutes.html
2015/10/08 - Close ISSUE-91, keep 0 and unbound as defaults, in line with resolution of ISSUE-59
2015/10/08 - Open ISSUE-98, ISSUE-99, ISSUE-100, ISSUE-101
2015/10/08 - Approve minutes of the 1 October Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/10/01-shapes-minutes.html
2015/10/01 - Close ISSUE-82, adding support for unique language constraint with sh:uniqueLang
2015/10/01 - Close ISSUE-90, supporting literals as focus nodes
2015/10/01 - Close ISSUE-89 stating that this is valid, although maybe not very useful, and will be treated consistently with how recursion is defined
2015/10/01 - Close ISSUE-77, adding support for the same flags as SPARQL
2015/10/01 - Open ISSUE-93, ISSUE-94, ISSUE-95, ISSUE-96, ISSUE-97
2015/10/01 - Approve minutes of the 24 September Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/09/24-shapes-minutes.html
2015/09/24 - publish a pro-forma document as a stake in the ground for the namespace along with FPWD
2015/09/24 - Publish SHACL Editor's draft as a FPWD
2015/09/24 - Open ISSUE-90, ISSUE-91, ISSUE-92
2015/09/24 - Publish UCR Editor's draft, with added changes section
2015/09/24 - Approve minutes of the 17 September Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/09/17-shapes-minutes.html
2015/09/17 - Close ISSUE-51, adopting with the latest editor's draft renaming sh:Error as sh:Violation
2015/09/17 - Close ISSUE-83, the specification says this is actually invalid syntax in section 3.1 https://w3c.github.io/data-shapes/shacl/#constraints-property (note that the same result can however be achieved using multiple property constraints)
2015/09/17 - Close ISSUE-75 with F2F resolution "limit reporting to validation results, and not include runtime errors"
2015/09/17 - Close ISSUE-85, dropping XorConstraint altogether
2015/09/17 - Open ISSUE-85, ISSUE-86, ISSUE-87, ISSUE-88, ISSUE-89
2015/09/17 - Approve minutes of the 8, 9, and 10 September F2F: http://www.w3.org/2015/09/08-shapes-minutes.html, http://www.w3.org/2015/09/09-shapes-minutes.html, http://www.w3.org/2015/09/10-shapes-minutes.html
2015/09/17 - Approve minutes of the 3 September Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/09/03-shapes-minutes.html
2015/09/10 - limit reporting to validation results, and not include runtime errors
2015/09/10 - all SPARQL snippets should use $ for variables that represent arguments, e.g. $minCount, while all other variables remain ?
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-42, as no longer relevant, given resolutions of ISSUE-41 and ISSUE-81
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-81, resolved as proposed in Holger's email https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015Aug/0133.html, pending better suggestions for the names
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-41, do not add support for property paths to Core
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-28, as no longer relevant
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-29, as already resolved using "SPARQL plus an extension function for recursive shapes"
2015/09/09 - Close ISSUE-44, based on the last two resolutions (sh:shapesGraph and owl:imports)
2015/09/09 - add a note stating that owl:imports can be used for general inclusion (data to data and schema to schema)
2015/09/09 - call the mechanism to link a data graph to a schema sh:shapesGraph
2015/09/09 - have a mechanism to link a data graph to a schema
2015/09/09 - have a mechanism to include a schema into another schema
2015/09/08 - Confirm resolution of ISSUE-74 as is
2015/09/08 - fix the spec so that the Core doesn't depend on shacl-ref, adding definitions in english along with SPARQL snippets where possible
2015/09/03 - Close ISSUE-70, stating that rdf:type statements are optional but SHOULD be included whenever possible on IRI nodes. omitting rdf:type statements may have various negative effects
2015/09/03 - Open ISSUE-84: Constraint to limit IRIs of focus nodes to a given enumeration (similar to owl:oneOf)
2015/09/03 - Approve minutes of the 27 August Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/08/27-shapes-minutes.html, noting objection from Peter on resolution of ISSUE-74
2015/08/27 - Close ISSUE-74, answer is no but we'll add some informative text to the spec talking about the pitfalls of validating against a SPARQL endpoint and we should keep in mind that some people will want to validate against an endpoint so we don't make it arbitrarily difficult
2015/08/27 - Open ISSUE-83: multiple sh:qualifiedValueShapes
2015/08/27 - Approve minutes of the 20 August Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/08/20-shapes-minutes.html
2015/08/20 - Close ISSUE-76, stating that execution order does NOT matter
2015/08/20 - Close ISSUE-79, per Holger's proposal
2015/08/20 - Open ISSUE-79, ISSUE-80, ISSUE-81, ISSUE-82
2015/08/20 - Approve minutes of the 13 August Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/08/13-shapes-minutes.html
2015/08/13 - Close ISSUE-53 as addressed by the current editor's draft with sh:qualifiedValueShape
2015/08/13 - Close ISSUE-58, as proposed by Holger in his email: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015Jul/0114.html
2015/08/13 - Close ISSUE-72, adopting sh:qualifiedValueShape as currently specified in editor's draft
2015/08/13 - Approve minutes of the 6 August Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/08/06-shapes-minutes.html
2015/08/06 - Close ISSUE-26, stating that extensions can invoke the high-level language referring to named shapes
2015/08/06 - Close ISSUE-3, specifying that a SHACL processor is invoked with an RDF dataset (or RDF graph) as its data and a shapes graph for control, per Holger's email
2015/08/06 - Open ISSUE-77: sh:pattern flags, and ISSUE-78: sh:abstract
2015/08/06 - Approve minutes of the 30 July Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/07/30-shapes-minutes.html
2015/07/30 - Close ISSUE-69, defining a new datatype sh:text
2015/07/30 - Close ISSUE-32, it was addressed by the adoption of the current editor's draft.
2015/07/30 - High-level refers to the part of SHACL that does not require use of an extension language, Core is the built-in High-Level language we define as part of SHACL, Human-friendly means compact, e.g., ShExC
2015/07/30 - Close ISSUE-2, it is no longer relevant.
2015/07/30 - Approve minutes of the 23 July Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/07/23-shapes-minutes.html
2015/07/23 - Close ISSUE-64, adding minInclusive/minExclusive/maxInclusive/maxExclusive, minLength/maxLength (dropping xsd:length), pattern (regex)
2015/07/23 - Close ISSUE-59, sticking with the current draft which is {0, unbound/unlimited}
2015/07/23 - Close ISSUE-37, keeping sh:nodeKind
2015/07/23 - Close ISSUE-5 based on resolution of ISSUE-62, per Holger's email https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015Jul/0067.html
2015/07/23 - Approve minutes of the 16 July Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/07/16-shapes-minutes.html
2015/07/16 - Close ISSUE-62 adopting Holger's proposal, drafted in http://w3c.github.io/data-shapes/shacl/index-2015-07-13.html#scopesAndFilters
2015/07/16 - Open ISSUE-73-76
2015/07/16 - Approve minutes of the 9 July Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/07/09-shapes-minutes.html
2015/07/09 - Approve minutes of the 2 July Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/07/02-shapes-minutes.html
2015/07/02 - Approve minutes of the 25 June Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/06/25-shapes-minutes.html
2015/06/25 - Close ISSUE-1, based on previous resolutions
2015/06/25 - SHACL shall include a high-level mechanism, functionally equivalent to what would be called sh:directScopeType, to express the scope of direct instances
2015/06/25 - (revising earlier resolution) sh:valueClass must also include nodes with an rdf:type link to nodes connected to the class via the transitive closure of rdfs:subClassOf
2015/06/25 - sh:scopeClass must also include nodes with an rdf:type link to nodes connected to the class via the transitive closure of rdfs:subClassOf
2015/06/25 - SHACL shall include another property sh:directValueType that matches ?focusNode rdf:type ?type (for OSLC use case)
2015/06/25 - sh:valueClass must also match subclasses, with its SPARQL implementation using rdfs:subClassOf* as described in http://w3c.github.io/data-shapes/shacl/#sparql-AbstractValueTypePropertyConstraint
2015/06/25 - SHACL includes a proerty sh:entailment that can be set on the shapes graph to ensure that a certain entailment regime is activated on the dataset.
2015/06/25 - Open ISSUE-72: Qualified Cardinality Restrictions
2015/06/25 - Open raised issues: ISSUE-69: status of rdf:langString values with xsd:string datatype, ISSUE-70: special treatment of blank node types, ISSUE-71: SHACL Endpoint Protocol
2015/06/25 - Approve minutes of the 18 June Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/06/18-shapes-minutes.html
2015/06/18 - Open ISSUE-68: pre-binding not defined in SHACL spec
2015/06/18 - Open ISSUE-66: SHACL spec ill-founded due to non-convergence on data loops
2015/06/18 - Approve minutes of the 11 June Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/06/11-shapes-minutes.html
2015/06/11 - Close ISSUE-60: Shall SHACL support other extension languages beside SPARQL (like JavaScript)? saying yes, even though we may not define any such extension at this point, the design should allow it.
2015/06/11 - Based on Doodle Poll the F2F4 in Lille will take place on September 8-10, 2015
2015/06/11 - Approve minutes of the 4 June Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/06/04-shapes-minutes.html
2015/06/04 - Open ISSUE-52, ISSUE-53, ISSUE-57-65
2015/06/04 - open ISSUE-51
2015/06/04 - Approve S47: Clinical data constraints (modulo turning it into a story and putting the technicalities into requirements in the UC&R doc) https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/User_Stories#S47:_Clinical_data_constraints
2015/06/04 - Approve S46: Software regression testing with SHACL https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/User_Stories#S46:_Software_regression_testing_with_SHACL
2015/06/04 - Approve S45: Linked Data Update via HTTP GET and PUT https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/User_Stories#S45:_Linked_Data_Update_via_HTTP_GET_and_PUT
2015/06/04 - Approve minutes of the 28 May Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/05/28-shapes-minutes.html
2015/05/28 - As described in https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015May/0175.html, adopt Holger's draft as the basis for the SHACL specification, leveraging Peter's proposal to improve it, and define a compact syntax starting with ShEx
2015/05/28 - Close ISSUE-50 adopting Peter's proposal as much as possible
2015/05/28 - Approve minutes of F2F: http://www.w3.org/2015/05/19-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/05/20-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/05/21-shapes-minutes.html
2015/05/28 - Approve minutes of the 14 May Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/05/14-shapes-minutes.html
2015/05/20 - Close Issue-45, stating that SHACL shall include SPARQL as an extension language, without making it a required feature for compliance (possibly via profiles) and without implying that SHACL must be implemented in SPARQL
2015/05/20 - Close ISSUE-31, agreeing that we will only have one single governing semantics for all of SHACL
2015/05/20 - Close ISSUE-24, stating that specialization can be achieved via conjunctions
2015/05/20 - Close ISSUE-25, as is - this will be defined over time on a case by case basis
2015/05/14 - Close ISSUE-48 by adding a requirement that the effect of expressive scopes be in SHACL
2015/05/14 - Postpone ISSUE-49
2015/05/14 - Close ISSUE-46 by adding requirements 2.6.12 and 2.6.13 as proposed by Richard in: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015May/0017.html
2015/05/14 - Approve minutes of the 7 May Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/05/07-shapes-minutes.html
2015/05/07 - Open ISSUE-47 and ISSUE-48
2015/05/07 - Close ACTION-19
2015/05/07 - Approve minutes of the 30 April Telecons: http://www.w3.org/2015/04/30-shapes-minutes.html
2015/04/30 - Close ISSUE-36 by calling value type facet "sh:valueType" and revert resolution of ISSUE-39 to use "sh:valueShape" rather than "sh:shape"
2015/04/30 - Approve 2.6.11 Expressivity: Closed Shapes https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/Requirements#Expressivity:_Closed_Shapes
2015/04/30 - Approve Karen's description as S40
2015/04/30 - Approve minutes of the 23 April Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/04/23-shapes-minutes.html
2015/04/23 - Close ISSUE-27 by saying yes: extension constraints can be used in the high-level language
2015/04/23 - Close ISSUE-30 as is/unanswered
2015/04/23 - Open ISSUE-45, Should SPARQL be a built-in extension language
2015/04/23 - close ISSUE-35 per Jose's suggestion to add a requirement as detailed in email: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-data-shapes-wg/2015Apr/0218.html
2015/04/23 - Open ISSUE-46: Support for RDF Collections?
2015/04/16 - Open ISSUE-44: How to express dependencies between graphs
2015/04/16 - Close ISSUE-43 Proposal for creating the FPWD of SHACL Part 1, it's not a real issue and should be addressed at the F2F
2015/04/16 - All proposals to be considered should be in decent shape by the end of the month (30 April) or will be dropped
2015/04/16 - Change F2F3 to Virtual F2F - roughly 6h/day over 3 days between 9am and 5pm ET
2015/04/16 - Approve minutes of the 2 and 9 April Telecons: http://www.w3.org/2015/04/02-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/04/09-shapes-minutes.html
2015/04/09 - Close ISSUE-39 using shape (not valueShape)
2015/04/09 - Close ISSUE-38, using minCount and maxCount (no count)
2015/04/09 - Approve 2.7.2 Function and Property Macros https://www.w3.org/2.7.2 Function and Property Macros2014/data-shapes/wiki/Requirements#Function_and_Property_Macros
2015/04/09 - open ISSUE-41, ISSUE-42
2015/04/09 - ISSUE-33 is closed
2015/04/09 - open ISSUE-36 through ISSUE-39
2015/04/09 - Open ISSUE-35
2015/04/02 - open all raised issues: ISSUE-22 through ISSUE-34
2015/04/02 - Implementation of "SHACL high level" shall not require SPARQL
2015/04/02 - Approve 2.10.2 Human-readable Violation Messages
2015/04/02 - Approve S42: Constraining RDF graphs for better mapping to JSON
2015/04/02 - Approve minutes of the 26 March Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/03/26-shapes-minutes.html
2015/03/26 - Approve 2.8 Specialization of Shapes https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/Requirements#Specialization_of_Shapes
2015/03/26 - Approve 2.11.8 Evaluating Constraints for a Single Node Only https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/Requirements#Evaluating_Constraints_for_a_Single_Node_Only
2015/03/26 - Approve S41: Validating schema.org instances against model and metamodel https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/User_Stories#S41:_Validating_schema.org_instances_against_model_and_metamodel
2015/03/26 - approve S39 Arbitrary Cardinality https://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/wiki/User_Stories#S39_Arbitrary_Cardinality
2015/03/26 - Approve minutes of the 19 March Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/03/19-shapes-minutes.html
2015/03/19 - Approved requirements 2.14.1 Property Default Value, 2.14.2 Property Labels at Shape, 2.14.3 Property Comment in a Shape
2015/03/19 - publish UCR as a FPWD http://w3c.github.io/data-shapes/data-shapes-ucr/
2015/03/19 - close ISSUE-15, accepting Harold's revision
2015/03/19 - Approve minutes of the 12 March Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/03/12-shapes-minutes.html
2015/03/12 - Approve requirements 2.5.9.1, 2.5.9.2, 2.5.9.3, without implying how/where it is addressed
2015/03/12 - Approve requirements 2.12.1, 2.12.2, 2.12.3, with 2.12.1 renamed "Select whole graph"
2015/03/12 - close action-12
2015/03/12 - Close Action 16
2015/03/12 - Approve minutes of the 05 March Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/03/05-shapes-minutes.html
2015/03/05 - Approve 2.11.7 Separation of structural from complex constraints
2015/03/05 - change 2.11.7 per Richard's proposal amended by Jose
2015/03/05 - ISSUE-16, dropping S18
2015/03/05 - Close ISSUE-14
2015/03/05 - close ISSUE-21, asking for people to clarify which version of ShEx they refer to when they use that term
2015/03/05 - Approve minutes of the F2F2: http://www.w3.org/2015/02/17-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/02/18-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2015/02/19-shapes-minutes.html
2015/03/05 - Approve minutes of the 26 February Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/02/26-shapes-minutes.html
2015/02/26 - Approve minutes of the 30 and 31 of October 2014 F2F: http://www.w3.org/2014/10/30-shapes-minutes.html http://www.w3.org/2014/10/31-shapes-minutes.html
2015/02/26 - Approve minutes of the 12 February Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/02/12-shapes-minutes.html
2015/02/19 - Approve 2.10.1 Severity Levels (hearing no objection)
2015/02/19 - Change description to: The language should allow the creation of error responses that can include severity levels as desired
2015/02/18 - Use "sh" as our prefix
2015/02/18 - Adopt "SHACL" as the name for our specification
2015/02/18 - Review and raise issues against the revised ldom proposal by 26 February (Chair's Note: rendered moot by change of plans regarding the draft)
2015/02/18 - Define semantics using SPARQL as much as possible
2015/02/18 - Start from Eric's Revised LDOM proposal, and explore ways to combine shapes and classes such as punning
2015/02/17 - Approve 2.6.8 Expressivity: Transitive Traversal of Properties
2015/02/17 - Change title to: Expressivity: Transitive Traversal of Properties
2015/02/17 - Change description to: Some constraints need to be able to traverse a property transitively, such as parent-child or partOf relationships
2015/02/17 - Approve 2.5.5 Property's RDF Node Type (e.g. only IRIs are allowed)
2015/02/17 - Approve 2.5.4 Property Type (as reworded)
2015/02/17 - Replace Property Type description with "The values of a property may be limited by their type, e.g., all children have to be of type person"
2015/02/17 - Replace description with: There must be an "easy" way of associating a shape with a class, meaning that nodes in a graph that are instances of that class must conform with that shape
2015/02/17 - Move Property Comment to the category "Non validation related requirements"
2015/02/17 - Move Property Labels at Shape to the category "Non validation related requirements", specifying this is intended for human consumption such as documentation or UI
2015/02/17 - Move Property Default Value to a new category "Non validation related requirements"
2015/02/17 - Close ISSUE-12, accepting Dean's addition
2015/02/17 - Close ISSUE-11 accepting Ted's revised proposed change
2015/02/17 - Close ISSUE-8 as the User Story is no longer in the Wiki
2015/02/17 - Close ISSUE-13 as per Sandro's email and Peter's edits
2015/02/12 - Approve requirements 2.5.2,2.5.10, 2.5.11, 2.6, 2.7, 2.7.1, 2.7.4, 2.9
2015/02/12 - Approve minutes of the 5 February Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/02/05-shapes-minutes.html
2015/02/05 - Add S38 to the the User Stories - status approved
2015/02/05 - Close ISSUE-17, as is (would still be nice to have an example)
2015/02/05 - Close ISSUE-9, deleting S7
2015/02/05 - Minutes of 29 January approved
2015/02/05 - Minutes of 22 January approved
2015/01/29 - Approve requirements 2.6.2, 2.6.3, 2.6.4, 2.6.5, 2.6.6, 2.6.7, 2.7.3, 2.10, 2.10.3, 2.11.5
2015/01/29 - close issue-20
2015/01/22 - ISSUE-18 and ISSUE-19 are closed
2015/01/22 - ISSUE-6 is closed
2015/01/22 - Approve minutes of the 15 January Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2015/01/15-shapes-minutes.html
2015/01/15 - issue 8-9 are closed with no objections
2015/01/15 - minutes from 8 January 2015 approved without objections http://www.w3.org/2015/01/08-shapes-minutes.html
2015/01/08 - open in bulk the 15 raised issues on User Stories
2015/01/08 - Minutes of 12 December 2014 approved
2014/12/18 - People should add their name (initials) to requirements they think ought to be considered, if there are at least three persons endorsing a requirement it is then "under consideration"
2014/12/18 - "Freeze" the user stories we've collected as of 18 December 2014
2014/12/18 - Approve minutes of the 11 December Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2014/12/11-shapes-minutes.html
2014/12/11 - Open ISSUE-5: How is a resource associated with shapes?
2014/12/11 - Approve minutes of the 04 December Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2014/12/04-shapes-minutes.html
2014/12/04 - F2F2 meeting at MIT the 17-19 February 2015
2014/12/04 - Approve minutes of the 20 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2014/11/20-shapes-minutes.html
2014/11/20 - open ISSUE-3 Shape Association
2014/11/20 - open ISSUE-2, changing it to be about what users and agents are expected to consume this technology and their associated skills and capabilities
2014/11/20 - open ISSUE-1 http://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/track/issues/1
2014/11/20 - Approve minutes of the 12 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2014/11/12-shapes-minutes.html
2014/11/20 - Approve minutes of the 5 November Telecon: http://www.w3.org/2014/11/05-shapes-minutes.html
2014/10/31 - Next face to face, 10-12 Feb
2014/10/30 - accept E08 "Discover shapes" defn: "annotate shapes and query over annotations"
2014/10/30 - accept R147 "addressable schemas" and R148 "addressable constraints" as requirements
2014/10/30 - accept R184 defined as "concise language" as a requirement
2014/10/30 - R111, "Basic use cases covered by constraint language", and R176, "high-level vocab for common cases" are redundant against R103
2014/10/30 - accept R-103 (as defined earlier in this meaning) as a requirement
2014/10/30 - define R-103 as "higher-level language for 1. definitional capabilities, e.g. macro rolling up and naming, 2. control infrastructure for e.g. recursion"