Comments/September2016/

September 2016

Title	Commenter	Mail start	Edits made	Issue	Resolved
Labels for literals in sh:enumeration	Miika Alonen	[1]		ISSUE-179
"Defined" undefined	Peter Patel-Schneider	[2]	[3]	ISSUE-197
"Undefined" is used inconsistently	Peter Patel-Schneider	[4]		ISSUE-183	Yes (closed)
"Declared" and "defined" are undefined	Peter Patel-Schneider	[5]		ISSUE-197
"Deep copy" is undefined	Peter Patel-Schneider	[6]			Yes (0 in doc)
minCount definitions	Peter Patel-Schneider	[7]	[8]		Yes
Entailment	Peter Patel-Schneider		[9]
Filter shapes are not "evaluated"	Peter Patel-Schneider	[10]	[11] [12]		filters being removed
Failure in SHACL not adequately defined	Peter Patel-Schneider	[13]
Access to shapes graph/pre-binding	Peter Patel-Schneider	[14]
Recursion	Peter Patel-Schneider	[15]	[16]
Property paths	Peter Patel-Schneider	[17]		ISSUE-184	Yes (issue closed)
Different levels of SHACL implementation	Peter Patel-Schneider	[18] specific thread
Closing of ISSUE-107	Peter Patel-Schneider	[19]			[20]
Closing of ISSUE-106	Peter Patel-Schneider	[21]			[22]
Closing of ISSUE-163	Peter Patel-Schneider	[23]			[24]
Closing of ISSUE-155	Peter Patel-Schneider	[25]			[26]
Closing of ISSUE-142	Peter Patel-Schneider	[27]			[28]
Can literals be shapes?	Peter Patel-Schneider	[29]
Order of filters/evaluation order in SHACL v SPARQL	Peter Patel-Schneider	[30]		ISSUE-185	filters being removed
Levels of conformance	Peter Patel-Schneider	[31]	[32] [33]
$this in aggregations	Peter Patel-Schneider	[34]		ISSUE-208
Example for sh:datatype	Peter Patel-Schneider		[35]		[36]
on poor wording and loose terminology for prefix handling	Peter Patel-Schneider		[37]
What is a shape?	Peter Patel-Schneider	[38]	[39]	ISSUE-209
Expected type	Peter Patel-Schneider	[40] [41]	[42]	ISSUE-210
on failure and sh:hasShape	Peter Patel-Schneider	[43]	[44]		Need reply from Peter
on lists	Peter Patel-Schneider	[45]	[46]		Under discussion latest
parameter descriptions for constraint components	Peter Patel-Schneider	[47]	[48]	ISSUE-191	Done, awaiting discussion
	Peter Patel-Schneider	[mail]	[edits]

November, 2016

Title	Commenter	Mail start	Edits made	Issue	Resolved
Constraint component node unclear	Peter Patel-Schneider	[49]	[edits]		[50]
Graph is result of validation; report entities useful?	Peter Patel-Schneider	[51]	[edits]
"Processing" not defined	Peter Patel-Schneider	[52]	[edits]
How node target specifies targets?	Peter Patel-Schneider	[53]	[edits]
Filters do not filter out focus nodes	Peter Patel-Schneider	[54]	[edits]		filters being removed
filterShape needs explicit type	Peter Patel-Schneider	[55]	[edits]		filters being removed
Targets as values always ignored	Peter Patel-Schneider	[56]	[edits]	ISSUE-192 (parts)	filters being removed
Shape is not a focus node constraint	Peter Patel-Schneider	[57]	[edits]
Pre-binding in SHACL core	Peter Patel-Schneider	[58]	[edits]	ISSUE-202
Eliminate property constraints	Peter Patel-Schneider	[59]	[edits]	ISSUE-211
Property constraints and focus node constraints	Peter Patel-Schneider	[60]	[edits]	ISSUE-212
Finding shapes	Peter Patel-Schneider	[61]	[edits]	ISSUE-213

Unresolved carried over from August

See Wiki page for more detail

Most are covered on this wiki page

Title	Commenter	Mail start	Edits made	Issue	Resolved
Pre-binding	Peter Patel-Schneider	[62]	[edits]
Syntax of SPARQL variables	Peter Patel-Schneider	[63]	[64]
$this in aggregations	Peter Patel-Schneider	[65]		ISSUE-208
ASK syntax	Peter Patel-Schneider	[66]	[67]
Different levels of implementation	Peter Patel-Schneider	[68]	[edits]		?
Order of filters	Peter Patel-Schneider	[69]	[edits]		filters being removed
EXISTS and blank noes	Peter Patel-Schneider	[70]	[edits]
Union operation on data graphs and shapes graphs	Peter Patel-Schneider	[71]	[72]		?
$targetNode assumed bound	Peter Patel-Schneider	[73]	[edits]
Shapes graph determination	Peter Patel-Schneider	[74]	[edits]		?
Deep copy	Peter Patel-Schneider	[75]	[edits]		removed from document
Incomplete table	Peter Patel-Schneider	[76]	[77]		?

? means that it isn't clear if the edits resolved the issue.