TouchEvents-LCWD-13-Sep-2011

NOTE: the Web Events Working Group closed in November 2013 because it completed its technical work with the publication of the 10 October 2013 Touch Events Recommendation. As such, this document is NO longer maintained.

This is the comment tracking document for the 13-Sep-2011 Touch Events v1 Last Call Working Draft.

The comment ids are numbered in the order the comments were submitted (e.g. LC-1 submitted before LC-2).

LC-7

• Commenter: Michael Cooper (for WAI P&F WG); 28-Sep-2011
• Title: The relation between touch events and mouse events should be explained in more detail
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0091.html>
• Status: discussed during 11-Oct-2011 call; Rejected the request for more explanatory information added to the spec but created Action-85 to create related tutorial/primer type information during CR. Accepted PFWG's 30-Nov-2011 follow-up which proposed a non-substantive addition and that was added to the spec via a 30-Nov-2011 changeset.
• WG Responses: 13-Oct-2011 WG Response; 30-Nov-2011 WG response which accepts PFWG's proposed addition (see changeset)
• Commenter Reply: WG's Response is OK

LC-6

• Commenter: Michael Cooper (for WAI P&F WG); 28-Sep-2011
• Title: Minor editorial issues with the spec
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0091.html>
• Status: Accepted during 11-Oct-2011 call
• WG Response: Response, change agreed and submitted (see changeset#1 and changeset#2)
• Commenter Reply: WG's Response is OK

LC-5

• Commenter: Greg Dennis ; 15-Sep-2011
• Title: Add a table for each touch event type
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0065.html>
• Status: accepted during 20-Sep-2011 call; discussed during 11-Oct-2011 call
• WG Response: change agreed and submitted (see changeset)
• Commenter Reply: WG's Response is OK

LC-4

• Commenter: Anne van Kesteren; 13-Sep-2011
• Title: use "partial interface Document" (and not DocumentTouch) to extend the Document interface
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0053.html>
• Status: accepted
• WG Response: Changeset submitted
• Commenter Reply: WG's Response is OK

LC-3

• Commenter: Anne van Kesteren; 13-Sep-2011
• Title: Use event constructors ala DOM4 and not initTouchEvent method
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0053.html>
• Status: accepted; Issue-23
• WG Response: Changeset to remove initTouchEvent submitted; DOM4 event constructor will be used in v2
• Commenter Reply: WG's response is OK

LC-2

• Commenter: Cathy Chan; 7-Sep-2011
• Title: Does an element have to also register for touchstart event in order to receive touchend/touchmove events
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0046.html>
• Status: accepted; Issue-22
• WG Response: change agreed and submitted (see changeset)
• Commenter Reply: OK (Cathy submitted the above changset)

LC-1

• Commenter: Cathy Chan; 7-Sep-2011
• Title: Description of touchcancel event is missing some details
• URL: <http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webevents/2011JulSep/0046.html>
• Status: accepted; Issue-21
• WG Response: change agreed and submitted (see changeset)
• Commenter Reply: OK (Cathy submitted the above changset)