Teleconference.2009.03.25/Agenda

Call in details

• Date of Call: Wednesday March 25, 2009
• Time of Call: 1700 UTC, 10:00 (West US), 13:00 (East US), 17:00 (London), 18:00 (Paris) NOTE CHANGE!!!
• Dial-In #: +1.617.761.6200 (Cambridge, MA)
• Dial-In #: +33.4.89.06.34.99 (Nice, France)
• Dial-In #: +44.117.370.6152 (Bristol, UK)
• Participant Access Code: 69594# (OWLWG)
• IRC Channel: irc.w3.org port 6665 channel #owl ([irc:irc.w3.org:6665/owl])
• Web-based IRC (member-only): http://www.w3.org/2001/01/cgi-irc (Firefox IRC addon: chatzilla)
• Duration: 90 minutes
• Chair: Alan Ruttenberg
• Scribe: Zhe Wu (Scribe List)
• Link to Agenda: http://www.w3.org/2007/OWL/wiki/Teleconference.2009.03.25/Agenda

Agenda

• Admin
  • Roll call
  • Agenda amendments?
  • PROPOSED: Accept Previous Minutes (18 March)
  • Action items status
    • Pending Review Actions
      • Action 270 Add new examples in response to IH1 / Boris Motik
      • Action 301 Contact Andy Seaborn and try to make sure he's happy with our work on rdf:text, and will talk to use about any remaining issues / Jie Bao
      • Action 283 Add an ontology header and a comment to each of the test cases from WebOnt that are prevented from being syntactically OWL 2 DL only be the absence of this header and create content for errata on webont tests / Michael Smith
      • Action 310 Review rdf:text document http://www.w3.org/2007/OWL/wiki/InternationalizedStringSpec / Peter Patel-Schneider
      • Action 309 Review QRG / Bernardo Cuenca Grau
      • Action 308 Review QRG / Bijan Parsia
      • Action 307 Review QRG / Christine Golbreich
      • Action 323 Help Sandro / Bijan Parsia
    • Due and overdue Actions
      • Action 292 Talk to RIF to see what datatypes in OWL must not be in OWL-RL / Sandro Hawke
      • Action 299 Find and fix the to-wiki-links Jeremy complains about / Sandro Hawke
      • Action 321 Review NF&R (perhaps after some editing) / Elisa Kendall
• Documents and Reviewing
  • All documents should now be ready for review
    • With exception of (at least) rdf:text!
    • Technical issue: Character set infinite/finite - how to resolve
  • Appendices on "Changes since Last Call"?
  • All documents now have [reviewers assigned] and eager to start work
• Last Call Comments (see [1] and Responses to Last Call Comments)
  • Responses ready to send - for quick approval
    • ML1 18 QL typos/extension
    • MZ1 19 QL comments
    • IH3 59 QL sameAs
      • Related: Ivan's comment suggesting additional QL intro text
    • BP2 40 XML syntax
    • JR6a 52a RDF Semantics editorial
    • JR6b 52b OWL 2 DL definition
    • AR1 66 Datatype map conformance thread
  • Draft responses for discussion and potential approval
    • GRDDL TM1 17 GRDDL
  • Non-positive Acknowledgments
    • MK1 47 Functional properties for keys see Bijan's comment, notes from followup with Marijke
    • RM1 51(a) Data properties should be functional (2nd reply sent 18th March)
• (Technical) Issues Arising
  • Treatment of xsd:dateTimeStamp (see SS&FS and thread)
    • PROPOSED: OWL will use the standard XML Schema definition of xsd:dateTimeStamp (i.e., time zones are carried into the semantics of OWL).
  • CURIEs (see thread)
    • PROPOSED: OWL will send comments on CURIEs spec
    • PROPOSED: OWL will not rely on CURIEs spec but will define it's own IRI abbreviation mechanism compatible with the one used by SPARQL (see proposal)
  • Naming scheme for OWL
  • Differences between OWL 1 and OWL 2 -- where should they be documented? (NF&R or Primer)
• Open Issues potentially affecting Last Call
  • Issue 146 Specify use of labels in addition to/instead of entity URIs in serialization
    • PROPOSED: Schedule vote for next week (1st April) to close this issue.
• Test Cases
  • PROPOSED: Don't use :DL and :FULL as tags for semantics
  • Problems with approved test cases?
  • Progress on tool support, e.g., for "species validation"?
  • How to organize related tests - e.g. same input but different results for DL versus Full/RL (e.g. punning/sameas)
  • PROPOSED: Approve some/all of the test cases currently in the test queue
• Features "At-Risk" (just a reminder)
  • owl:rational support
  • rdf:XMLLiteral support
• Additional other business

Regrets

• Achille Fokoue (travelling)
• Elisa Kendall (OMG Technical Meeting conflict)
• Evan Wallace (at risk due to OMG meeting)

back to Meetings