Disposition of comments for the Device and Sensors Working Group

paged view

In the table below, red is in the WG decision column indicates that the Working Group didn't agree with the comment, green indicates that a it agreed with it, and yellow reflects an in-between situation.

In the "Commentor reply" column, red indicates the commenter objected to the WG resolution, green indicates approval, and yellow means the commenter didn't respond to the request for feedback.

Commentor	Comment	Working Group decision	Commentor reply
LC-2965 Tobie Langel `<tobie.langel@gmail.com>` (archived comment)	Hi, I don't understand why this API is developed separately from other sensor APIs. It would be much better for developers if all sensor APIs were consistent. The API difference between DeviceOrientation and Geolocation was bad enough. Why are we repeating such mistakes over and over again? Sorry for the late and negative feedback. --tobie	Continue Battery API with current approach given we have two implementations and support for the API as-is and no significant technical issue to support a late-stage restart. Can consider alternatives for a v.next as appropriate. http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2014Sep/0054.html	yes