W3C

CC/PP: Structure and Vocabularies Implementation Report

Editor:
Luu Tran luu.tran@sun.com, Sun Microsystems

Introduction

This document records the results of running implementations against the CC/PP Test Suite which was designed to validate the CC/PP: Structure and Vocabularies specification.

Test Results

Producers

The following profiles are produced by commercial implementations and pass the profile validity tests.

Consumers

Although the behavior of a consumer when accepting and extracting information from an invalid profile is beyond the scope of this test suite, we show below the results of various implementations when consuming the sample invalid profiles. These results are indicated by (A) and (B).

General area of feature Consumer Implementations
ID Specific area of feature Sample valid profile(s) Sample invalid profile(s) JSR188 Reference Implementation Sun ONE Portal Server, Mobile Access IBM UCP
RDF/XML
1 MUST be valid RDF serialized in XML 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06, 07, 08, 09, 10, 11
passed passed passed
2 MUST use valid syntax for namespace declarations 01
passed passed passed
CC/PP Profile Components
3 profile MUST contain one or more components 01 32 passed passed passed
4 each component MUST contain one or more attributes 01 31 passed passed passed
5 component name MAY be in rdf:about or rdf:ID attributes 12, 13
passed passed passed
6 components MUST be indicated using a ccpp:component property where the namespace used to qualify component is the CC/PP namespace or a UAProf namespace 14 30 passed (B) passed
7 component names, component types, and attribute names must all refer to different URIs within a profile 01 34 passed (A) passed
8 component type given as an element name and in an rdf:type element MUST be consistent 35 36 passed (B) passed
CC/PP Profile Defaults
9 default references MUST be valid URLs 15, 16
passed passed passed
10 defaults MAY be written as ccpp:defaults or ccpp:Defaults 15, 16
passed passed passed
11 defaults MUST be indicated using a ccpp:defaults or ccpp:Defaults property where the namespace used to qualify defaults or Defaults is the CC/PP namespace or a UAProf namespace 17 33 passed (B) passed
12 MAY contain both a default value and a directly applied value, directly applied value takes precedence 18
passed passed passed
13 MAY contain inline defaults 37
passed passed passed
14 MUST NOT contain both inline and referenced defaults 37 38 passed (B) passed
15 MAY reference a default document which does not have an rdf:type 37
passed passed passed
CC/PP Profile Attributes
16 MAY contain attributes that are sets of values (Bags) 23, 24
passed passed passed
17 MAY contain attributes that are sequences of values (Seq) 25, 26
passed passed passed
18 MAY contain attributes that are Text values 27
passed passed passed
19 MAY contain attributes that are Integer numbers 28
passed passed passed
20 MAY contain attributes that are Rational numbers 29
passed passed passed
21 MUST NOT contain multiple values for the same attribute in the same component 01
passed passed passed
22 MAY contain attributes of the same name in more than one component 40 41 passed (C) passed
23 MAY use multiple namespaces for attributes 19, 20, 21, 22
passed passed (C)
Interoperability
24 Openwave SDK 6.2

passed passed (C)
25 Panasonic GD67 0.4 (D)

passed passed passed
26 Panasonic GD67 R1 (D)

passed passed passed
27 Panasonic GD87 R1 (D)

passed passed passed
28 Panasonic GD88 R1 (D)

passed passed passed

passed: indicates that the implementation succesfully accepted and extracted the appropriate information from the valid profile(s) and indicated invalidity on the invalid profile(s)

(A): indicates that the consumer implementation succesfully accepted and extracted the appropriate information from the valid profile(s) but failed on the invalid profile(s)

(B): indicates that the consumer implementation succesfully accepted and extracted the appropriate information from the valid profile(s) but also accepted and extracted information from invalid profile(s) without an indication of invalidity

(C): indicates that the consumer implementation succesfully accepted but only partially extracted the appropriate information from the valid profile(s)

(D): these producer implementation profiles reference a vocabulary schema that is slightly inconsistent (the WmlScriptVersion and WmlVersion attributes are defined with inconsistent compositions) but the consumers accepted and extracted information from the profiles appropriately

Valid XHTML 1.0!