ISSUE-20: Statement 3004 lacks context, RFC 2119 keywords
Statement 3004 lacks context, RFC 2119 keywords
Statement 3004 lacks context, RFC 2119 keywords
- State:
- CLOSED
- Product:
- SOAP-JMS Binding specification
- Raised by:
- Eric Johnson
- Opened on:
- 2009-10-26
- Description:
- From email:
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-soap-jms/2009Oct/0027.html
Description:
The supposedly normative statement 3004 currently reads:
"SOAP/JMS properties which are declarable in WSDL 1.1 and WSDL 2.0
documents†"
This doesn't stand on its own, and it doesn't have RFC 2119 keywords.
Further soapAction is not really a SOAP/JMS property.
The point of the statement seems to be (based on WG discussions
http://www.w3.org/2009/10/20-soap-jms-minutes.html) that this
specification only defines what these elements mean in these specific
WSDL locations, and no others. What we want, then, is a normative
statement that says that a conforming implementation MUST use these
properties when found in those specific contexts, while saying nothing
about what they might mean in other contexts.
Proposal:
Replace the text of Section 3.6 with:
The XML elements jndiConnectionFactoryName, jndiInitialContextFactory,
jndiURL, deliveryMode, priority, timeToLive, and replyToName, in the
soapjms namespace, MUST be supported when used in the context of the
WSDL service, port/endpoint, and binding elements. This specification
does not define any use outside of those elements.
Section 3.6.1:
Replace: "For this specification, each property in the table above adds
a WSDL Component Model Property with the same name to the containing
WSDL 2.0 component."
with:
"For this specification, each property in the list
jndiConnectionFactoryName, jndiInitialContextFactory, jndiURL,
deliveryMode, priority, timeToLive, and replyToName, adds a WSDL
Component Model Property with the same name to the containing WSDL 2.0
component.
- Related Actions Items:
- No related actions
- Related emails:
- Agenda for the 2010-01-12 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2010-01-11)
- Re: Agenda for the 2009-12-15 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-12-15)
- RE: Agenda for the 2009-12-15 conference call (from Derek.Rokicki@softwareag.com on 2009-12-15)
- Re: Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from phil_adams@us.ibm.com on 2009-12-14)
- Agenda for the 2009-12-15 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-12-14)
- Re: Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-12-14)
- Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-12-14)
- Re: Agenda for 2009-12-08 conference call (from alewis@tibco.com on 2009-12-08)
- Re: Agenda for 2009-12-08 conference call (from M8PHILLI@uk.ibm.com on 2009-12-08)
- issue-20: update available (from phil_adams@us.ibm.com on 2009-12-07)
- Agenda for 2009-12-08 conference call (from phil_adams@us.ibm.com on 2009-12-07)
- Agenda for the 2009-12-01 conference call (from peaston@progress.com on 2009-11-30)
- Agenda for the 2009-11-17 conference call (from M8PHILLI@uk.ibm.com on 2009-11-16)
- Re: Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-11-03)
- RE: Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from Derek.Rokicki@softwareag.com on 2009-11-03)
- Agenda for the 2009-11-03 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-11-02)
- RE: Agenda for 2009-10-27 conference call (from peaston@progress.com on 2009-10-27)
- Action-119 - Raised two new issues, action complete. (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-10-26)
- Agenda for 2009-10-27 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-10-26)
- ISSUE-20 (Statement 3004 lacks context, RFC 2119 keywords): Statement 3004 lacks context, RFC 2119 keywords [SOAP-JMS Binding specification] (from sysbot+tracker@w3.org on 2009-10-26)
Related notes:
Opened as per: http://www.w3.org/2009/10/27-soap-jms-minutes.html
Eric Johnson, 2 Nov 2009, 21:32:56Accepted applied resolution as per: http://www.w3.org/2010/01/12-soap-jms-minutes.html
Eric Johnson, 19 Jan 2010, 01:54:15Completing historical record, issue resolved as per:
http://www.w3.org/2009/12/01-soap-jms-minutes.html
Display change log