W3C

Web Services Addressing WG Teleconference

31 Jan 2005

Agenda

See also: IRC log

Attendees

Present
Rebecca Bergersen (IONA Technologies, Inc.)
Francisco Curbera (IBM Corporation)
Glen Daniels (Sonic Software)
Paul Downey (BT)
Michael Eder (Nokia)
Robert Freund (Hitachi, Ltd.)
Martin Gudgin (Microsoft Corporation)
Hugo Haas (W3C)
Marc Hadley (Sun Microsystems, Inc.)
David Hull (TIBCO Software, Inc.)
Yin-Leng Husband (HP)
Anish Karmarkar (Oracle Corporation)
Philippe Le Hégaret (W3C)
Mark Little (Arjuna Technologies Ltd.)
Jonathan Marsh (Microsoft Corporation)
Mark Peel (Novell, Inc.)
Harris Reynolds (webMethods, Inc.)
Tony Rogers (Computer Associates)
Tom Rutt (Fujitsu Limited)
Davanum Srinivas (Computer Associates)
Greg Truty (IBM Corporation)
Steve Vinoski (IONA Technologies, Inc.)
Pete Wenzel (SeeBeyond Technology Corporation)
Steve Winkler (SAP AG)
Ümit Yalçınalp (SAP AG)
Absent
Ugo Corda (SeeBeyond Technology Corporation)
Jacques Durand (Fujitsu Limited)
Yaron Goland (BEA Systems, Inc.)
Marc Goodner (SAP AG)
Arun Gupta (Sun Microsystems, Inc.)
Jeff Mischkinsky (Oracle Corporation)
Eisaku Nishiyama (Hitachi, Ltd.)
Ales Novy (Systinet Inc.)
David Orchard (BEA Systems, Inc.)
Rich Salz (DataPower Technology, Inc.)
Jiri Tejkl (Systinet Inc.)
Chair
Mark Nottingham
Scribe
Tony Rogers

Contents


 

<mnot> Scribe: Tony Rogers

<plh> http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/addr/minutes.html

<pauld> http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/addr/minutes.html

<hugo> ScribeNick: TonyR

Previous minutes

corrrections to the minutes

<mnot> http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/addr/5/01/18-ws-addr-minutes.html#item02

[paco] removing references to identification as well as removing Reference Properties

<plh> Paco: in addition to removing ref props, we agreed to remove indications that ref props were used for identification.

<Paco> Issue 1 closed with the removal of refprops.

<Paco> ... and removal of all references ot the use of EPRs as identifiers

Chair: clarify minutes by removing identifiers

MarkH: clarify identification, not remove

Glen: removing from throughout spec

Chair: removing comparison section was left for a while

Paco: asked during vote whether to remove

Chair: removing all reference to identifiers was covered

Chair: do we change the minutes?

Chair: little dispute about direction - just do we change the minutes?

i047

MarcH: doesn't have reservations, but doesn't recall it that way

Chair: change approved

Minutes approved without dissent - 17, 18, 19 January

Minutes of 24th January - request to postpone approval until next week

Action Items

Action Items - going through list

<Gudge> ACTION: jmarsh to make a specific proposal for text to be added to the spec regarding IRIs

Chair: reaching Last Call within the month lies within our charter. Failing that means that we are outside charter and must go to AC.

Schedule

<Marsh> March -1 through 1 :-)

Chair: schedule an April FtF about mid-April, then a June FtF.

Chair: looking for an April FtF host - preferably on West Coast

Chair: have a host in Berlin for June.

Coordination

Chair: TAG have raised an issue and asking us for more detail

Chair: will someone take on the issue and prepare a response for the TAG

<MSEder> Steve Maine's blog http://hyperthink.net/blog/

<Gudge> first item: http://hyperthink.net/blog/PermaLink,guid,8c9c4e73-24d0-4f9b-b28b-a7f6a858d721.aspx

<Gudge> second item: http://hyperthink.net/blog/PermaLink,guid,7de8743c-29e0-46a9-ba8f-ee86c4198813.aspx

<Gudge> my first post on the issue: http://pluralsight.com/blogs/mgudgin/archive/2005/01/25/5438.aspx

Chair: looking for a brief discussion to aid the TAG

<Gudge> my second post: http://pluralsight.com/blogs/mgudgin/archive/2005/01/26/5454.aspx

<Gudge> ACTION: Jonathan to flesh out discussion of EndpointRefs47 TAG issue

Working Draft publication

<Gudge> Mark Baker's first post: http://www.markbaker.ca/2002/09/Blog/2005/01/25#2005-01-maine-tag

<Gudge> Mark Baker's second post: http://www.markbaker.ca/2002/09/Blog/2005/01/25#2005-01-gudge-tag

Editors have produced drafts

<scribe> ACTION: editors to revise to incorporate resolution of Issue 1

Chair: either release next week, or leave until Tech Plenary

Proposed and New Issues

MarcH: on I047

Marc: listing which URIs must be absolute - there are a few questionable ones

Jonathan: is this just a serialisation issue?
... should we require that they be serialised as absolute URIs?

Chair: do we record this in the Core, or in the SOAP binding?

Philippe: does this exclude fragment identifier? absolute URI means no fragment id

<scribe> ACTION: Marc to construct a proposal to resolve issue 47, specifying where in the document

issue 48

Chair: do we remove section 2.3?

Paco: result of removing reference properties surprised people

<plh> Paco: as a result of issue 1 resolution, there is less need for section 2.3. we could add a bit on how people are going to attach metadata to EPR. so the proposal is to strike section 2.3.

<plh> Marc: is there anything that you were disgreeing with 2.3?

Paco: result of removing RefProps is that same address means same metadata, and that's the problem
... the example of an enterprise gateway
... different EPRs with different metadata, but with the same address

<hugo> </div>

<hugo> s/</div>//

The discussion is about the inference that same address -> same metadata

Chair: looks like we cannot move on issue 48 quickly

Issue 15

Marc: proposal in response to this issue

<plh> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-addressing/2005Jan/0180.html

Marc: WS Context addresses this better

<plh> http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/documents.php?wg_abbrev=ws-caf

Resolution: Drop this issue with no action

Topic Issue 17

Issue 17

Anish: depending on discussion in WSDL WG
... WSDL WG dropped action from required to best practice

Jonathan: good place for cross-reference between WSDL and WS-Addressing specs

<scribe> ACTION: Anish to adjust Issue 17 proposal in light of outcome in WSDL WG

<scribe> ACTION: Jonathan to make proposal for Issue 17b

Issue 18

Issue 20

Issue 42

Chair: assigned to David Orchard, but he is not available for 2 weeks - will someone else step up?

Jonathan: I'll take a pass at this

<Gudge> ACTION: Jonathan to make a proposal for issue 42

Issue 43

Gudge: 3 approaches
... 1. remove 2.3
... 2. add text describing how to compare using exc canonicalisation
... 3. have the text from 2., but add "try not to use QNames"

<mnot> Gudge's proposal: http://www.w3.org/mid/DD35CC66F54D8248B6E04232892B633804A02932@RED-MSG-43.redmond.corp.microsoft.com

Chair: this is inter-dependent with resolution of Issue 48

Chair: discuss this on the list, put this on agenda for next week.

Issue 44

<plh> http://www.w3.org/mid/20050117002757.GB3952@w3.org

Philippe: refer to binding as well

Marc: let protocol binding specify how to use the EPR

<scribe> ACTION: Hugo to restate resolution to issue 44 in a day or two

Issue 46

Jonathan: posted a cleaned-up version of the proposal

Yin-Leng: concern if destination is comparable using char-by-char

Jonathan: worried about precluding some use-cases

Chair: close with Jonathan's proposal minus the two enhancements?

Resolution: Issue 46 closed with Jonathan's proposal, minus the enhancement

Issue 7

Issue 26

<plh> Mark: proposed resolution for issues 24 and 26.

<mnot> http://www.w3.org/mid/13AC4E67178F4D4EA31BB1BA645303132DC19B@amereast-ems2.boston.amer.iona.com

<plh> [Steve presents the proposals]

Chair: people need time to evaluate these proposals

Chair: develop proposal into full spec replacement text

Topic Issue 41

Issue 41

Hugo: test suite can be a recommendation, but that makes it harder to change

[general agreement to keep test suite outside the spec]

<scribe> ACTION: Bob to reissue template with modifications

<scribe> ACTION: Paul to test the test suite when reissued

<scribe> ACTION: Hugo to make mailing list for test cases discussion

Chair: WRT issue 046; should go into the abstract properties part of the core; editors have license to put it elsewhere if necessary

Summary of Action Items

[NEW] ACTION: Anish to adjust Issue 17 proposal in light of outcome
... in WSDL WG
[NEW] ACTION: Bob to reissue template with modifications
[NEW] ACTION: editors to revise to incorporate resolution of Issue
... 1
[NEW] ACTION: Hugo to make mailing list for test cases discussion
[NEW] ACTION: Hugo to restate resolution to issue 44 in a day or
... two
[NEW] ACTION: jmarsh to make a specific proposal for text to be
... added to the spec regarding IRIs
[NEW] ACTION: Jonathan to flesh out discussion of EndpointRefs47
... TAG issue
[NEW] ACTION: Jonathan to make a proposal for issue 42
[NEW] ACTION: Jonathan to make proposal for Issue 17b
[NEW] ACTION: Marc to construct a proposal to resolve issue 47,
... specifying where in the document
[NEW] ACTION: Paul to test the test suite when reissued
 
[End of minutes]

Minutes formatted by David Booth's scribe.perl version 1.109 (CVS log)
$Date: 2005/02/02 00:21:48 $