Last Call Comments on 23 Jan 2003 RDF Working Drafts

RDF Primer

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
danc-03	rdf/xml reification examples	accepted	raised	Dan Connolly	accepted
pfps-15	Say anything quote	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-17	namespace v vocabulary	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted

Resource Description Framework (RDF): Concepts and Abstract Syntax

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
danc-01	graph equality	accepted	raised	Dan Connolly	none
danc-02	goofy literals	accepted	raised	Dan Connolly	accepted
efth-01	change namespace URIs	not accepted	raised	Nick Efthymiou	accepted
jsr188-01	Global Datatyping	not accepted	raised	Mark Butler for CC/PP JSR	accepted
macgregor-01	Distinguishing asserted and non-asserted triples	accepted	raised	Bob MacGregor	accepted
macgregor-02	Propositional attitudes	accepted	raised	Bob MacGregor	accepted
pfps-13	Datatype Facets	clarification	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-14	Social Meaning	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
			raised	Peter Crowther	accepted
			raised	Bijan Parsia	accepted
			raised	Jim Hendler for Webont	none
pfps-16	RDF's Expressive Power	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-18	namespace v vocabulary	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-22	reserved names in abstract syntax	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-23	sanctioned by?	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
reagle-01	XMLLiteral equality	accepted	raised	Eric Prud'hommeaux	none
			raised	Joseph Reagle	accepted
			raised	Jim Hendler for Webont	none
reagle-02	exc-c14n throughout	accepted	raised	Eric Prud'hommeaux	none
			raised	Joseph Reagle	accepted
tex-01	case of lang tags	clarification	raised	Tex Texin	accepted
tex-02	sub langauge literal compare	postponed	raised	Tex Texin	none
williams-01	What is a node in an RDF graph?	accepted	raised	Stuart Williams	accepted
williams-02	s/URIref/IRI/	not accepted	raised	Stuart Williams	accepted
			raised	Tex Texin	none
xmlsch-01	Typed Literal Structure	not accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-02	whitespace facet	accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	none
xmlsch-03	lexical mapping	clarification	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-04	values without lexical forms	clarification	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-05	character sequences	not accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-06	natural language data	accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted

RDF/XML Syntax Specification (Revised)

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
chas-01	aboutEachPrefix	not accepted	raised	Charles McCathieNevile	none
hendler-01	literals in parsetype collection	postponed	raised	Jim Hendler	accepted
			raised	Jim Hendler for Webont	accepted
krech-01	emptyPropertyElt ambiguity	accepted	raised	Daniel Krech	accepted
hodder-01	RDF in HTML	accepted	raised	Dave Hodder	accepted
pfps-19	namespace v vocabulary	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
timbl-01	bagid needed	accepted	raised	Tim Berners-Lee	accepted
timbl-03	collection clutter	accepted	raised	Tim Berners-Lee	none
xmlsch-08	xsi:type	accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-09	qnames	accepted	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted
xmlsch-10	cannonical syntax	postponed	raised	XML Schema WG	not accepted
xmlsch-11	layering on xml	clarification	raised	XML Schema WG	not accepted
xmlsch-12	capricious syntax	postponed	raised	Mark Butler	accepted
			raised	XML Schema WG	none

RDF Vocabulary Description Language 1.0: RDF Schema

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
danc-04	triviallyTrue predicate	not accepted	raised	Dan Connolly	none
			raised	Ian Horrocks	accepted
eikon-01	define rdfs:Schema	accepted	raised	Daniel "eikeon" Krech	accepted
pfps-11	rdfs:comment implies entailments	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-12	Lists are not well formed	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
			raised	Karsten Tolle	accepted
pfps-20	namespace v vocabulary	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-24	What is RDF Schema?	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	none
pfps-25	Schema semantics	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
qu-04	RDF/XML Representation	accepted	raised	Qu Yuzhong	accepted
vass-01	flat layering	not accepted	raised	Vassilis Christophides	none
vass-02	property instances	accepted	raised	Vassilis Christophides	none
webont-01	rename schema	not accepted	raised	Jim Hendler for Webont	accepted

RDF Semantics

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
horrocks-01	rdfs:comment semantics	not accepted	raised	Ian Horrocks	accepted
horst-01	RDFS entailment lemma	accepted	raised	Herman ter Horst	accepted
pan-01	Extending to FOL	postponed	raised	Jeff Z Pan	accepted
pfps-01	XML Schema datatypes	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-02	Lbase translation of XML Literals	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-03	translation to Lbase	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-04	RDF closure rules	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	not accepted
pfps-05	RDFS closure rules	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	not accepted
pfps-06	typed XML literals and LV	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-07	typed literals with lang tags	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-08	typed literals	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-09	datatypes	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-10	untyped literals	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
pfps-21	namespace v vocabulary	accepted	raised	Peter F. Patel-Schneider	accepted
timbl-02	reification semantics	not accepted	raised	Tim Berners-Lee	none
qu-01	Domain of rdfs:member	not accepted	raised	Qu Yuzhong	accepted
qu-02	rdfs:member functional?	not accepted	raised	Qu Yuzhong	none
qu-03	Ontology subset of RDFS	postponed	raised	Qu Yuzhong	accepted
reagle-03	must use xsd:?	not accepted	raised	Joseph Reagle	accepted
xmlsch-07	datatype definition	Resolution	raised	XML Schema WG	accepted

RDF Test Cases

id	title	wg response	raised	by	raiser's response
jang-01	datatype subclass entailment	accepted	raised	Jan Grant	none
jjc-01	rdfms-nested-bagIDs/test007.rdf	accepted	raised	Jeremy Carroll	accepted