User:Danbri/UniversalTopics

Rough notes, discussion w/ Aida

JSON

JSON.parse('{ "vocab": "http://udcdata.info/", "342615":"", "3163677": "-0552", "796815":"", "640443": ["(41771)", "(0476)"] }')

Example

https://twitter.com/#!/vb2b/status/182062616737349633 "Metadata boot camp: @jodbod challenges @iptc experts to tag story called "Woman in sumo wrestler suit assaulted by ex-girlfriend in gay pub""
From a real story, e.g. see http://www.irishcentral.com/news/news_from_ireland/Woman-in-sumo-wrestler-suit-assaults-ex-girlfriend-after-waving-at-man-dressed-as-Snickers-bar-97262439.html

"Woman in sumo wrestler suit assaults ex-girlfriend who waved at man dressed as Snickers bar A fancy dress party in one of Dublin's best known gay bars took a sinister turn when a woman attacked her ex-girlfriend Adrienne Martin in a row over a dress-up sumo wrestler's suit."

UDC version

342.615:316.367.7-055.2:796.815:640.443(417.71)(047.6) Assault/Bodily hurt related to homosexual relationships (between females) and sumo wrestlers - in pub - in Dublin - news item [this kind of indexing will enable retrieval of anything to do with homosexual relationships - it means that the issue is relationship/social interaction - and in this indexing there is no confusion that the assault happened within the

red sumo wrestling - see below this can be expressed more precisely .

This is where these numbers come from

342.615 Assault. Bodily hurt (Criminal law) (417.71) Dublin 640.443 Pubs 316.367.7 Homosexual relations (social aspect) 796.815 Sumo wrestling -051 Person peforming the action - hence 796.815-051 sumo wrestlers -055.2 Female

form of the document/ type of resource (we can add here many things such as online/journal/digital in English language etc. but there is no need to go that far) (047.6) Brief reports, notices. News items. Press cuttings

The other option was to use 342.615-055.34-055.2 ... - Asault - Person:homosexual - Person- female ... but this solution would not make it clear whether assault happened between homosexuals or on homosexuals (by someone else) - so using the number from sociology to focus on 'homosexual relationships' is much more precise...

"many would say that the distinction between 796.815 Sumo wrestling and 796.815-051 Sumo wrestlers (i.e.adding -051 persons doing the action) would be a bit over the top but in UDC this option comes handy occasionally to make the difference between e.g. person assaulting and person being assaulted by adding -051 doers and -052 persons as targets"

Typo: typo in the first number it is 343.615 not 342.615 (fixme)

Public data

This much you can find in public UDC Summary: 342.6:316.36-055.2:796.8:640(417)(046)

Offence against person - to do with marriage and family - female - combat sports - in some kind of household establishment in Ireland - newspaper article

See how much meaning is being lost - marked red. (UDC summary is less than 4% of UDC)

343.6 Offences against person (good) Including: Homicide. Physical injury. Intentional, deliberate killing. Murder. Violence. Assault. Manslaughter. Suicide. Offences against the helpless: neglect, exploitation, cruelty
316.36 Marriage and family. Including: Types of marriages. Family units. Sexual relations and practices (!!! you lose the aspect of homosexual relationships)
-055.2 female (good)
796.8 Combat sport. Including: Wrestling. Boxing. Martial arts (judo, karate). Fencing. Weightlifting. Tug-of-war (!!!you loose sumo)
640.4 Type of houshold. Including: Housekeeping. Hotel and catering industry. Hospitality management. Large households (!!! you lose pub)
(417) Republic of Ireland (you loose Dublin)
(047) Reports. Notices. Bulletins - I would replace this with (046) Newspaper articles

URIs (append .rdf for RDF):