XProc CR Disposition of Comments

Last updated: 25 Feb 2010 at 17:38:25 UTC

193 comments, 193 closed (100.00%)

Hide closed

Admin off

closed issues and issues where consensus on a resolution has been reached are colour-coded.

Siblings are date-ordered, the more recent the higher up.

Hover over a [+] to see the message date. Click on a [+]/[-] to toggle inline display of a message; Click on a subject to switch to the message itself in the archive.


193.[+][X] Options whose names conflict with local step attributes from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 17-Dec-2009 [W]
[+]  [closed] Re: Options whose names conflict with local step attributes from Norman Walsh
192.[+][X] p:http-request: authentication concerns from Florent Georges on 16-Dec-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: p:http-request: authentication concerns from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:http-request: authentication concerns from Florent Georges
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: p:http-request: authentication concerns from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:http-request: authentication concerns from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:http-request: authentication concerns from Vasil Rangelov
191.[+][X] Version attribute issues from Norman Walsh on 08-Dec-2009 [W]
[+]  RE: Version attribute issues from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Version attribute issues from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Version attribute issues from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Version attribute issues from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Version attribute issues from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Version attribute issues from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Version attribute issues from Norman Walsh
190.[+][X] Nodelists as values from Henry S. Thompson on 01-Dec-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Nodelists as values from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Nodelists as values from Norman Walsh
189.[+][X] Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Norman Walsh on 01-Dec-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Florent Georges
[+]  [closed] Re: Namespace attribute for steps that take wrappers? from Norman Walsh
188.[+][X] p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from Henry S. Thompson on 26-Nov-2009 [D]
[+]  RE: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from Philip Fennell
[+]  Re: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from mozer
[+]  Re: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from mozer
[+]  Re: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: p:value-available not as useful as I'd like. . . from mozer
187.[+][X] re p:filter-002 from James Fuller on 26-Nov-2009 [D]
[+]  RE: re p:filter-002 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: re p:filter-002 from James Fuller
[+]  RE: re p:filter-002 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: re p:filter-002 from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: re p:filter-002 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: re p:filter-002 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
186.[+][X] No media type from Norman Walsh on 23-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  Re: No media type from Innovimax W3C
[+]  Re: No media type from Alex Milowski
[+]  Re: No media type from murray
[+]  [closed] Re: No media type from Norman Walsh
185.[+][X] encoding and charset from Norman Walsh on 23-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  RE: encoding and charset from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: encoding and charset from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: encoding and charset from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: encoding and charset from Norman Walsh
184.[+][X] Iteration position and size from Norman Walsh on 23-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  Re: Iteration position and size from Innovimax W3C
[+]  RE: Iteration position and size from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Iteration position and size from Norman Walsh
183.[+][X] Re: XML namespaces on the Web - proposal restated from Krzysztof Maczyński on 21-Nov-2009 [C]
182.[+][X] Tests validxsd-004 and validxsd-012 contradictory from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 20-Nov-2009 [W]
181.[+][X] Using tokens to refer to the context step... from Philip Fennell on 17-Nov-2009 [D]
[+]  [closed] Re: Using tokens to refer to the context step... from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Alex Muir
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from James Sulak
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Alex Muir
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from James Sulak
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Leif Warner
[+]  Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Alex Muir
[+]  [closed] Re: How to pass a boolean value true or false using with-param when the required param type is xs:boolean; from Norman Walsh
179.[+][X] Help: use-when and p:episode from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  RE: Help: use-when and p:episode from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Innovimax W3C
[+]  Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Help: use-when and p:episode from Norman Walsh
178.[+][X] exclude-inline-prefixes question from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  Re: exclude-inline-prefixes question from Innovimax W3C
[+]  Re: exclude-inline-prefixes question from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: exclude-inline-prefixes question from Innovimax W3C
[+]  RE: exclude-inline-prefixes question from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: exclude-inline-prefixes question from Norman Walsh
177.[+][X] p:use-when on non-XProc elements from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Nov-2009 [W]
[+]  RE: use-when on non-XProc elements from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: use-when on non-XProc elements from Innovimax W3C
[+]  Re: use-when on non-XProc elements from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:use-when on non-XProc elements from Innovimax W3C
[+]  Re: p:use-when on non-XProc elements from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: p:use-when on non-XProc elements from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: p:use-when on non-XProc elements from Norman Walsh
176.[+][X] p:output and connections from Vasil Rangelov on 06-Nov-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: p:output and connections from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  RE: p:output and connections from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: p:output and connections from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:output and connections from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:output and connections from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: p:output and connections from Vasil Rangelov
175.[+][X] Subtlety about p:xquery from Florent Georges on 27-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: Subtlety about p:xquery from Norman Walsh
174.[+][X] RE: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Vasil Rangelov on 25-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] RE: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  [closed] Re: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Norman Walsh
173.[+][X] Change p:system-property to return untyped atomic from Norman Walsh on 24-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: Change p:system-property to return untyped atomic from Norman Walsh
172.[+][X] New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Norman Walsh on 24-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  RE: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: New XProc editor's WG reflects latest proposals from Norman Walsh
171.[+][X] Default binding for variable, option, parameter definitions from Norman Walsh on 22-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Default binding for variable, option, parameter definitions from James Sulak
[+]  Re: Default binding for variable, option, parameter definitions from Florent Georges
[+]  RE: Default binding for variable, option, parameter definitions from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Default binding of parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Default binding of parameter input ports from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Default binding of parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Default binding of parameter input ports from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Default binding of parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Default binding for variable, option, parameter definitions from Norman Walsh
170.[+][X] Test p:import #006 from Norman Walsh on 20-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  RE: Test p:import #006 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Test p:import #006 from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Test p:import #006 from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Test p:import #006 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Test p:import #006 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Test p:import #006 from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Test p:import #006 from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Test p:import #006 from Norman Walsh
169.[+][X] p:xquery & statically known namespaces from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 16-Oct-2009 [C]
[+]  RE: xquery & statically known namespaces from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: p:xquery & statically known namespaces from Norman Walsh
168.[+][X] A imports B, B imports A from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 15-Oct-2009 [W]
[+]  Re: A imports B, B imports A from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: A imports B, B imports A from Norman Walsh
167.[+][X] Runtime semantics of p:try from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 25-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Runtime semantics of p:try from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Runtime semantics of p:try from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Runtime semantics of p:try from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Runtime semantics of p:try from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Runtime semantics of p:try from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Runtime semantics of p:try from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Runtime semantics of p:try from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Runtime semantics of p:try from Norman Walsh
166.[+][X] Steps with no type in p:library from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 23-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: Steps with no type in p:library from Norman Walsh
165.[+][X] Step type exports definition from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 17-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: Step type exports definition from Norman Walsh
164.[+][X] Bag-merge definition from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 17-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  [closed] Re: Bag-merge definition from Norman Walsh
163.[+][X] Output port may be connected to... from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 17-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  RE: Output port may be connected to... from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Output port may be connected to... from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Output port may be connected to... from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Output port may be connected to... from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Output port may be connected to... from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Output port may be connected to... from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Output port may be connected to... from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Output port may be connected to... from Norman Walsh
162.[+][X] No binding for a non-primary input port from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 14-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  RE: No binding for a non-primary input port from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: No binding for a non-primary input port from Norman Walsh
161.[+][X] Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Vasil Rangelov on 05-Sep-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: Concerns about forwards-compatible mode from Norman Walsh
[+]  Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from James Fuller
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Florent Georges
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from mozer
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Alternate draft for revised versioning proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Florent Georges
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from David A. Lee
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from David A. Lee
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from David A. Lee
[+]  Re: Another take on versioning from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: Another take on versioning from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  top-level? (was Re: A (hopefully comprehensive) versioning proposal) from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: top-level? from Norman Walsh
160.[+][X] Accomodation for JSON from Justin Johansson on 10-Aug-2009 [C]
[+]  Re: Accomodation for JSON from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Accomodation for JSON from Norman Walsh
159.[+][X] p:choose/p:xpath-context question from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 07-Aug-2009 [C]