XProc Last Call Comments

Last updated: 01 May 2008 at 13:12:03 UTC

137 comments, 137 closed (100.00%)

Hide closed

closed issues and issues where consensus on a resolution has been reached are colour-coded.

Siblings are date-ordered, the more recent the higher up.

Hover over a [+] to see the message date. Click on a [+]/[-] to toggle inline display of a message; Click on a subject to switch to the message itself in the archive.


137.[+] [Steve Ball] Re: [xml-dev] XML Pipelines list? from Henry S. Thompson on 31-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: [Steve Ball] Re: [xml-dev] XML Pipelines list? from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [Steve Ball] Re: [xml-dev] XML Pipelines list? from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  Re: [Steve Ball] Re: [xml-dev] XML Pipelines list? from Innovimax SARL
136.[+] Media type for pipeline docs and names for pipeline elts from Henry S. Thompson on 27-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Media type for pipeline docs and names for pipeline elts from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  [closed] Re: Media type for pipeline docs and names for pipeline elts from Norman Walsh
135.[+] Parameter input ports from Alessandro Vernet on 27-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Parameter input ports from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  Re: Parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Parameter input ports from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  [closed] Re: Parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Parameter input ports from Norman Walsh
134.[+] Variable and option binding proposal from Henry S. Thompson on 25-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Alessandro Vernet
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Variable and option binding proposal from Henry S. Thompson
133.[+] Fodder for the @name proposal from Norman Walsh on 21-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Fodder for the @name proposal from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Fodder for the @name proposal from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: An example of guaranteed proper protection against potential race conditions from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: An example of guaranteed proper protection against potential race conditions from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: An example of guaranteed proper protection against potential race conditions from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: An example of guaranteed proper protection against potential race conditions from Innovimax SARL
131.[+] Proposal for p:variable from Innovimax SARL on 20-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Proposal for p:variable from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Proposal for p:variable from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Proposal for p:variable from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Proposal for p:variable from Innovimax SARL
130.[+] Ditch value=? from Norman Walsh on 19-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Ditch value=? from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Ditch value=? from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: Ditch value=? from Norman Walsh
129.[+] subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Henry S. Thompson on 18-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Jeni Tennison
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Murray Maloney
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: subpipelines, Vnext and extension elements redux from Norman Walsh
128.[+] (atomic/compound) steps, containers and related issues from Henry S. Thompson on 17-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: (atomic/compound) steps, containers and related issues from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: (atomic/compound) steps, containers and related issues from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: (atomic/compound) steps, containers and related issues from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: (atomic/compound) steps, containers and related issues from Norman Walsh
127.[+] Uncle! New alternate draft from Norman Walsh on 13-Mar-2008
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [first set of comments] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [first set of comments] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [first set of comments] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [remainder of comments on section 2] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [remainder of comments on section 2] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [remainder of comments on section 2] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [remainder of comments on section 2] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [more comments through the end of section 4] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [more comments through the end of section 4] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [more comments through the end of section 4] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [more comments through the end of section 4] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Uncle! New alternate draft [comments on some of section 5] from Henry S. Thompson
126.[+] p:pipeline name attribute from James Fuller on 01-Mar-2008
[+]  RE: pipeline name attribute from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: pipeline name attribute from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: p:pipeline name attribute from Norman Walsh
125.[+] The 'href' attribute from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 21-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: The 'href' attribute from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: The 'href' attribute from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: The 'href' attribute from Norman Walsh
124.[+] p:log feels clunky from James Fuller on 17-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: p:log feels clunky from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:log feels clunky from James Fuller
[+]  Re: p:log feels clunky from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:log feels clunky from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: p:log feels clunky from Norman Walsh
123.[+] p:pipeinfo from James Fuller on 16-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: p:pipeinfo from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:pipeinfo from James Fuller
122.[+] Naming of p:declare-step from Jeni Tennison on 14-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: Naming of p:declare-step from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Naming of p:declare-step from Norman Walsh
121.[+] xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from James Fuller on 12-Feb-2008
[+]  RE: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from James Fuller
[+]  Re: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from James Fuller
[+]  Re: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: xproc static and dynamic error output as xml from Norman Walsh
120.[+] Parameter input ports with sequence="true" from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 11-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Parameter input ports with sequence="true" from Norman Walsh
119.[+] (editorial) p:directory-list from Rui Lopes on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: (editorial) p:directory-list from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: (editorial) p:directory-list from Norman Walsh
118.[+] Assigning values to options from Rui Lopes on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: Assigning values to options from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Assigning values to options from Norman Walsh
117.[+] Document input declarations from Rui Lopes on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Document input declarations from Norman Walsh
116.[+] clarify boolean from James Fuller on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  Fwd: clarify boolean from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: clarify boolean from Norman Walsh
115.[+] p:string-replace clarification from James Fuller on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  RE: string-replace clarification from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: string-replace clarification from James Fuller
[+]  Re: string-replace clarification from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: p:string-replace clarification from Norman Walsh
114.[+] p:insert and matching nothing from James Fuller on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  RE: insert and matching nothing from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: insert and matching nothing from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: insert and matching nothing from Norman Walsh
113.[+] some brief nitpicking re p:insert and p:add-attribute from James Fuller on 06-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: some brief nitpicking re p:insert and p:add-attribute from Norman Walsh
112.[+] propose a implementation defined warning mechanism from James Fuller on 05-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: propose a implementation defined warning mechanism from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: propose a implementation defined warning mechanism from James Fuller
111.[+] add to implementation defined section from James Fuller on 05-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: add to implementation defined section from Norman Walsh
110.[+] embed date in schema docs from James Fuller on 05-Feb-2008
[+]  Re: embed date in schema docs from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: embed date in schema docs from James Fuller
[+]  [closed] Re: embed date in schema docs from Norman Walsh
109.[+] Response headers in p:http-request from Vasil Rangelov on 03-Feb-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Response headers in p:http-request from Norman Walsh
108.[+] Serialization parameters as parameter ports from Vasil Rangelov on 02-Feb-2008
[+]  [CLOSED] Re: Serialization parameters as parameter ports from Alex Milowski
107.[+] Using options in XSLT match patterns from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 30-Jan-2008
[+]  RE: Using options in XSLT match patterns from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Using options in XSLT match patterns from Norman Walsh
106.[+] p:viewport cannot match PI or Comments from Innovimax SARL on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: p:viewport cannot match PI or Comments from Norman Walsh
105.[+] Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Innovimax SARL on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Innovimax SARL
[+]  [closed] Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part III) from Norman Walsh
104.[+] Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part II) from Innovimax SARL on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 ( part II) from Norman Walsh
103.[+] Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 (first part) from Innovimax SARL on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 (first part) from Innovimax SARL
[+]  Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 (first part) from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Remarks on W3C Editor's Draft 24 January 2008 (first part) from Norman Walsh
102.[+] Default bindings for non-primary inputs from Norman Walsh on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Default bindings for non-primary inputs from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  RE: Default bindings for non-primary inputs from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Default bindings for non-primary inputs from Norman Walsh
101.[+] Output from for-each that gets evaluated zero times from Norman Walsh on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Output from for-each that gets evaluated zero times from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  [closed] Re: Output from for-each that gets evaluated zero times from Norman Walsh
100.[+] A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 from Norman Walsh on 25-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 from Nikolay Fiykov
[+]  Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 - proposal for p:label-elements from Alex Milowski
[+]  Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 - proposal for p:label-elements from Nikolay Fiykov
[+]  Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 - proposal for p:label-elements from Alex Milowski
[+]  Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 - proposal for p:label-elements from Nikolay Fiykov
[+]  [closed] Re: A few items cherry-picked from comment #54 from Norman Walsh
099.[+] Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 24-Jan-2008
[+]  RE: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: Implicit parameter input on p:pipeline from Norman Walsh
098.[+] Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 23-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  RE: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: Execution order of steps in a pipeline from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
097.[+] Typo in p:label-elements from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 18-Jan-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: Typo in p:label-elements from Norman Walsh
096.[+] p:set-attributes - attributes with the "xmlns" prefix from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 18-Jan-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: p:set-attributes - attributes with the "xmlns" prefix from Norman Walsh
095.[+] Compound steps with empty subpipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 16-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Compound steps with empty subpipelines from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  Re: Compound steps with empty subpipelines from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Compound steps with empty subpipelines from Norman Walsh
094.[+] XSLT pattern matching in p:viewport - matching descendant nodes from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 15-Jan-2008
[+]  [closed] Re: XSLT pattern matching in p:viewport - matching descendant nodes from Norman Walsh
093.[+] p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 14-Jan-2008
[+]  RE: declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  RE: declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Vasil Rangelov
[+]  Re: declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  [closed] Re: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  RE: [closed] Re: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: [closed] Re: p:declare-step - atomic steps vs. empty pipelines from Norman Walsh
092.[+] Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com on 10-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Henry S. Thompson
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  RE: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Toman_Vojtech@emc.com
[+]  Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: Comments on Editor's Draft 9 January 2008 from Norman Walsh
091.[+] text output from xslt from Alex Milowski on 10-Jan-2008
[+]  Re: text output from xslt from Norman Walsh
[+]  Re: text output from xslt from Norman Walsh
[+]  [closed] Re: text