Editor: Jon Gunderson
Last revised: $Date: 2002/07/04 18:32:34 $ by $Author: ijacobs $
This document lists the checkpoints of the 12 Sep 2001 Candidate Recommendation Version of UAAG 1.0 with low implementation experience; see the UAWG's Second Candidate Recommendation implementationr report. This document summarizes the UAWG's decisions about how to modify UAAG 1.0 in light of this implementation experience. This document was produced as part of work for the User Agent Accessibility Guidelines Working Group.
Checkpoints | Proposed Action | Discussed on Telecon | Comments |
---|---|---|---|
1.2 Activate event handlers (P1) 9.5 No events on focus change (P2) 9.6 Show event handlers (P2) |
Keep | 6 June | Group as a collection of checkpoints with one of the following
suggested labels:
|
4.4 Slow Multimedia (P1) | Keep | 6 June | Include implementation experience from:
|
5.3 Manual viewport open only (P2) 5.7 Manual viewport close only (P3) |
Keep 5.3; move 5.7 to note of 5.3 | 6 June |
Include implementation experience for 5.3 from:
See if we could get quick implementation for 5.7 from Mozilla |
3.5 Toggle content refresh (P1) | Keep, but drop the alert portion | 6 June | This is an important requirement for screen reader users.
Note: Aaron reports this is being planned for a future version of Mozilla, Ian will check with Opera |
10.5 Outline view. (P2) | Keep | 6 June |
Keep looking harder for implementation experience, potentially using the user style sheet capabilities in Opera and Internet Explorer. Note: Will use user style sheet implementations in Opera, IE and Konqueror; and Amaya outline view feature |
11.2 Current author bindings (P2) | Keep | 6 June | Consensus from the list to keep this requirement, even though we have low implementation experience |
2.11 Alert unsupported language (P3) | Keep | 6 June | Consensus from the list to keep this requirement, even though we have low implementation experience |
10.1 Table orientation (P1) | Make this for graphical user agents only | 20 June |
|
9.10 Configure important elements (P3) | Keep | 6 June | Keep since style sheets can be configured and we are using CSS as implementation expereince for 10.5 |
4.6 Position captions (P1) | Modify | 13 June |
|
2.10 Toggle placeholders (P3) | Drop | 6 June | Consensus from list discussion, move as an informative note somewhere else. |
4.8 Control other multimedia (P2) 4.7 Slow other multimedia (P2) 4.11 Control other volume (P2) |
Drop | 6 June | Consensus from list discussion, move as an informative note somewhere else. |
5.5 Confirm form submission (P2) | Keep | 13 June | There are many implementations of confirmation of form submission in an insecure setting. We are asking for an even more general configuration: don't submit any forms without my confirmation. |
3.6 Toggle redirects (P2) | Drop | 13 June | Move 3.6 from P2 checkpoint to informative Note under 3.5. We note that the user gets the final content anyway (after the redirect), perhaps with mild confusion due to unexpected change. |