W3CNOTE-sgml-xml-971215


Comparison of SGML and XML

World Wide Web Consortium Note 15-December-1997


This version:
http://www.w3.org/TR/NOTE-sgml-xml-971215
Author:
James Clark <jjc@jclark.com>

Status of this document

This document is a NOTE made available by the W3 Consortium for discussion only. This indicates no endorsement of its content, nor that the Consortium has, is, or will be allocating any resources to the issues addressed by the NOTE.
Errors or omissions in this document should be reported to the author.


Abstract

This document provides a detailed comparison of SGML (ISO 8879) and XML.


Comparison of SGML and XML

Version 1.0

Table of Contents

1. Differences Between XML and SGML
2. Transforming SGML to XML
3. SGML Declaration for XML

1. Differences Between XML and SGML

XML allows only documents that use the SGML declaration in this note. This declares all the following SGML features as NO:

Note that it differs from the reference concrete syntax in a number of ways:

The following constructs which are permitted in SGML when SHORTTAG is YES are not allowed in XML:

NET delimiters can be used only to close an empty element. In SGML without the Web SGML Adaptations Annex, the NET delimiter is declared as />. With this approach, XML is not allowing null end-tags and is allowing net-enabling start-tags only for elements with no end-tag. In SGML with the Web SGML Adaptations Annex, there is a separate NESTC (net-enabling start tag close) delimiter. This allows the XML <e/> syntax to be handled as a combination of a net-enabling start-tag <e/ and a null end-tag >. With this approach, XML is allowing a net-enabling start-tag only when immediately followed by a null end-tag.

XML imposes the following restrictions not in SGML:

XML predefines the semantics of the attributes xml:space and xml:lang. It also reserves all attribute, element type and notation names beginning with [Xx][Mm][Ll].

XML requires that an SGML parser use an entity manager that behaves as follows:

XML imposes requirements on the information that a parser must make available to an application.

XML depends on the following changes to SGML made by Web SGML Adaptations Annex:

The Web SGML Adaptations Annex also enables some XML restrictions to be enforced in SGML:

2. Transforming SGML to XML

For most restrictions in XML that go beyond SGML, it is possible to transform an SGML document automatically into a document that meets the restrictions, and is equivalent in the sense that it has the same ESIS. There are a number of restrictions for which this is not the case:

External SDATA entities, external CDATA entities
These could be transformed into NDATA entities.
Subdocument entities
These could be converted into NDATA entities with a notation that indicates that they are SGML or XML.
References to external data entities in content
These could be transformed into an empty element with an attribute whose declared value is ENTITY.
Data attributes
Since an external data entity can only be used in an ENTITY or ENTITIES attribute on an element, these could be transformed into other attributes on the element.
Internal SDATA entities
References could be transformed into numeric character references to the appropriate Unicode character; if used in an entity or entities attribute, the entity will have to be made external.
Internal CDATA entities
If used in an ENTITY or ENTITIES attribute, the entity will have to be made external (references to CDATA entities are not part of ESIS).
PI entities
If they contain ?>, they cannot be converted into an XML PI. It could be an application convention that entity references are replaced in PIs. Also if they do not start with a name, they cannot be converted into a well-formed XML PI.
names
An SGML document can have a concrete syntax which allows characters in names that XML does not allow in names.

3. SGML Declaration for XML

The following SGML declaration takes advantage of the Extended Naming Rules Technical Corrigendum to ISO 8879, but does not make use of the Web SGML Adaptations Annex:

<!SGML -- SGML Declaration for XML --
     "ISO 8879:1986 (ENR)"

     CHARSET
         BASESET
             "ISO Registration Number 176//CHARSET
             ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993 UCS-4 with implementation 
             level 3//ESC 2/5 2/15 4/6"
         DESCSET
                0       9       UNUSED
                9       2       9
                11      2       UNUSED
                13      1       13
                14      18      UNUSED
                32      95      32
                127     1       UNUSED
                128     32      UNUSED
                160     55136   160
                55296   2048    UNUSED  -- surrogates --
                57344   8190    57344
                65534   2       UNUSED  -- FFFE and FFFF --
                65536   1048576 65536
     CAPACITY SGMLREF
         -- Capacities are not restricted in XML --
         TOTALCAP 99999999
         ENTCAP   99999999
         ENTCHCAP 99999999
         ELEMCAP  99999999
         GRPCAP   99999999
         EXGRPCAP 99999999
         EXNMCAP  99999999
         ATTCAP   99999999
         ATTCHCAP 99999999
         AVGRPCAP 99999999
         NOTCAP   99999999
         NOTCHCAP 99999999
         IDCAP    99999999
         IDREFCAP 99999999
         MAPCAP   99999999
         LKSETCAP 99999999
         LKNMCAP  99999999


     SCOPE DOCUMENT

     SYNTAX
         SHUNCHAR NONE
         BASESET "ISO Registration Number 176//CHARSET
                 ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993 UCS-4 with implementation 
                 level 3//ESC 2/5 2/15 4/6"
         DESCSET
             0 1114112 0
         FUNCTION
             RE    13
             RS    10
             SPACE 32
             TAB   SEPCHAR 9

         NAMING
             LCNMSTRT ""
             UCNMSTRT ""
             NAMESTRT
                 58 95 192-214 216-246 248-305 308-318 321-328
                 330-382 384-451 461-496 500-501 506-535 592-680
                 699-705 902 904-906 908 910-929 931-974 976-982
                 986 988 990 992 994-1011 1025-1036 1038-1103
                 1105-1116 1118-1153 1168-1220 1223-1224
                 1227-1228 1232-1259 1262-1269 1272-1273
                 1329-1366 1369 1377-1414 1488-1514 1520-1522
                 1569-1594 1601-1610 1649-1719 1722-1726
                 1728-1742 1744-1747 1749 1765-1766 2309-2361
                 2365 2392-2401 2437-2444 2447-2448 2451-2472
                 2474-2480 2482 2486-2489 2524-2525 2527-2529
                 2544-2545 2565-2570 2575-2576 2579-2600
                 2602-2608 2610-2611 2613-2614 2616-2617
                 2649-2652 2654 2674-2676 2693-2699 2701
                 2703-2705 2707-2728 2730-2736 2738-2739
                 2741-2745 2749 2784 2821-2828 2831-2832
                 2835-2856 2858-2864 2866-2867 2870-2873 2877
                 2908-2909 2911-2913 2949-2954 2958-2960
                 2962-2965 2969-2970 2972 2974-2975 2979-2980
                 2984-2986 2990-2997 2999-3001 3077-3084
                 3086-3088 3090-3112 3114-3123 3125-3129
                 3168-3169 3205-3212 3214-3216 3218-3240
                 3242-3251 3253-3257 3294 3296-3297 3333-3340
                 3342-3344 3346-3368 3370-3385 3424-3425
                 3585-3630 3632 3634-3635 3648-3653 3713-3714
                 3716 3719-3720 3722 3725 3732-3735 3737-3743
                 3745-3747 3749 3751 3754-3755 3757-3758 3760
                 3762-3763 3773 3776-3780 3904-3911 3913-3945
                 4256-4293 4304-4342 4352 4354-4355 4357-4359
                 4361 4363-4364 4366-4370 4412 4414 4416 4428
                 4430 4432 4436-4437 4441 4447-4449 4451 4453
                 4455 4457 4461-4462 4466-4467 4469 4510 4520
                 4523 4526-4527 4535-4536 4538 4540-4546 4587
                 4592 4601 7680-7835 7840-7929 7936-7957
                 7960-7965 7968-8005 8008-8013 8016-8023 8025
                 8027 8029 8031-8061 8064-8116 8118-8124 8126
                 8130-8132 8134-8140 8144-8147 8150-8155
                 8160-8172 8178-8180 8182-8188 8486 8490-8491
                 8494 8576-8578 12295 12321-12329 12353-12436
                 12449-12538 12549-12588 19968-40869 44032-55203

             LCNMCHAR ""
             UCNMCHAR ""
             NAMECHAR
                 45-46 183 720-721 768-837 864-865 903 1155-1158
                 1425-1441 1443-1465 1467-1469 1471 1473-1474
                 1476 1600 1611-1618 1632-1641 1648 1750-1764
                 1767-1768 1770-1773 1776-1785 2305-2307 2364
                 2366-2381 2385-2388 2402-2403 2406-2415
                 2433-2435 2492 2494-2500 2503-2504 2507-2509
                 2519 2530-2531 2534-2543 2562 2620 2622-2626
                 2631-2632 2635-2637 2662-2673 2689-2691 2748
                 2750-2757 2759-2761 2763-2765 2790-2799
                 2817-2819 2876 2878-2883 2887-2888 2891-2893
                 2902-2903 2918-2927 2946-2947 3006-3010
                 3014-3016 3018-3021 3031 3047-3055 3073-3075
                 3134-3140 3142-3144 3146-3149 3157-3158
                 3174-3183 3202-3203 3262-3268 3270-3272
                 3274-3277 3285-3286 3302-3311 3330-3331
                 3390-3395 3398-3400 3402-3405 3415 3430-3439
                 3633 3636-3642 3654-3662 3664-3673 3761
                 3764-3769 3771-3772 3782 3784-3789 3792-3801
                 3864-3865 3872-3881 3893 3895 3897 3902-3903
                 3953-3972 3974-3979 3984-3989 3991 3993-4013
                 4017-4023 4025 8400-8412 8417 12293 12330-12335
                 12337-12341 12441-12442 12445-12446 12540-12542

             NAMECASE
                 GENERAL NO
                 ENTITY  NO


         DELIM
             GENERAL SGMLREF
             NET "/>"
             PIC "?>"
             SHORTREF NONE
         NAMES
             SGMLREF


         QUANTITY SGMLREF
             -- Quantities are not restricted in XML --
             ATTCNT      99999999
             ATTSPLEN    99999999
             -- BSEQLEN  not used --
             -- DTAGLEN  not used --
             -- DTEMPLEN not used --
             ENTLVL      99999999
             GRPCNT      99999999
             GRPGTCNT    99999999
             GRPLVL      99999999
             LITLEN      99999999
             NAMELEN     99999999
             -- no need to change NORMSEP --
             PILEN       99999999
             TAGLEN      99999999
             TAGLVL      99999999


     FEATURES
         MINIMIZE
             DATATAG NO
             OMITTAG NO
             RANK NO
             SHORTTAG YES -- SHORTTAG is needed for NET --
         LINK
             SIMPLE NO
             IMPLICIT NO
             EXPLICIT NO
         OTHER
             CONCUR NO
             SUBDOC NO
             FORMAL NO
     APPINFO NONE
>

The following SGML declaration takes advantage of the Web SGML Adaptations Annex to ISO 8879:

<!SGML -- SGML Declaration for XML --
     "ISO 8879:1986 (WWW)"

     CHARSET
         BASESET
             "ISO Registration Number 176//CHARSET
             ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993 UCS-4 with implementation 
             level 3//ESC 2/5 2/15 4/6"
         DESCSET
                0       9       UNUSED
                9       2       9
                11      2       UNUSED
                13      1       13
                14      18      UNUSED
                32      95      32
                127     1       UNUSED
                128     32      UNUSED
                160     55136   160
                55296   2048    UNUSED  -- surrogates --
                57344   8190    57344
                65534   2       UNUSED  -- FFFE and FFFF --
                65536   1048576 65536
     CAPACITY NONE

     SCOPE DOCUMENT

     SYNTAX
         SHUNCHAR NONE
         BASESET "ISO Registration Number 176//CHARSET
                 ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993 UCS-4 with implementation 
                 level 3//ESC 2/5 2/15 4/6"
         DESCSET
             0 1114112 0
         FUNCTION
             RE    13
             RS    10
             SPACE 32
             TAB   SEPCHAR 9

         NAMING
             LCNMSTRT ""
             UCNMSTRT ""
             NAMESTRT
                 58 95 192-214 216-246 248-305 308-318 321-328
                 330-382 384-451 461-496 500-501 506-535 592-680
                 699-705 902 904-906 908 910-929 931-974 976-982
                 986 988 990 992 994-1011 1025-1036 1038-1103
                 1105-1116 1118-1153 1168-1220 1223-1224
                 1227-1228 1232-1259 1262-1269 1272-1273
                 1329-1366 1369 1377-1414 1488-1514 1520-1522
                 1569-1594 1601-1610 1649-1719 1722-1726
                 1728-1742 1744-1747 1749 1765-1766 2309-2361
                 2365 2392-2401 2437-2444 2447-2448 2451-2472
                 2474-2480 2482 2486-2489 2524-2525 2527-2529
                 2544-2545 2565-2570 2575-2576 2579-2600
                 2602-2608 2610-2611 2613-2614 2616-2617
                 2649-2652 2654 2674-2676 2693-2699 2701
                 2703-2705 2707-2728 2730-2736 2738-2739
                 2741-2745 2749 2784 2821-2828 2831-2832
                 2835-2856 2858-2864 2866-2867 2870-2873 2877
                 2908-2909 2911-2913 2949-2954 2958-2960
                 2962-2965 2969-2970 2972 2974-2975 2979-2980
                 2984-2986 2990-2997 2999-3001 3077-3084
                 3086-3088 3090-3112 3114-3123 3125-3129
                 3168-3169 3205-3212 3214-3216 3218-3240
                 3242-3251 3253-3257 3294 3296-3297 3333-3340
                 3342-3344 3346-3368 3370-3385 3424-3425
                 3585-3630 3632 3634-3635 3648-3653 3713-3714
                 3716 3719-3720 3722 3725 3732-3735 3737-3743
                 3745-3747 3749 3751 3754-3755 3757-3758 3760
                 3762-3763 3773 3776-3780 3904-3911 3913-3945
                 4256-4293 4304-4342 4352 4354-4355 4357-4359
                 4361 4363-4364 4366-4370 4412 4414 4416 4428
                 4430 4432 4436-4437 4441 4447-4449 4451 4453
                 4455 4457 4461-4462 4466-4467 4469 4510 4520
                 4523 4526-4527 4535-4536 4538 4540-4546 4587
                 4592 4601 7680-7835 7840-7929 7936-7957
                 7960-7965 7968-8005 8008-8013 8016-8023 8025
                 8027 8029 8031-8061 8064-8116 8118-8124 8126
                 8130-8132 8134-8140 8144-8147 8150-8155
                 8160-8172 8178-8180 8182-8188 8486 8490-8491
                 8494 8576-8578 12295 12321-12329 12353-12436
                 12449-12538 12549-12588 19968-40869 44032-55203

             LCNMCHAR ""
             UCNMCHAR ""
             NAMECHAR
                 45-46 183 720-721 768-837 864-865 903 1155-1158
                 1425-1441 1443-1465 1467-1469 1471 1473-1474
                 1476 1600 1611-1618 1632-1641 1648 1750-1764
                 1767-1768 1770-1773 1776-1785 2305-2307 2364
                 2366-2381 2385-2388 2402-2403 2406-2415
                 2433-2435 2492 2494-2500 2503-2504 2507-2509
                 2519 2530-2531 2534-2543 2562 2620 2622-2626
                 2631-2632 2635-2637 2662-2673 2689-2691 2748
                 2750-2757 2759-2761 2763-2765 2790-2799
                 2817-2819 2876 2878-2883 2887-2888 2891-2893
                 2902-2903 2918-2927 2946-2947 3006-3010
                 3014-3016 3018-3021 3031 3047-3055 3073-3075
                 3134-3140 3142-3144 3146-3149 3157-3158
                 3174-3183 3202-3203 3262-3268 3270-3272
                 3274-3277 3285-3286 3302-3311 3330-3331
                 3390-3395 3398-3400 3402-3405 3415 3430-3439
                 3633 3636-3642 3654-3662 3664-3673 3761
                 3764-3769 3771-3772 3782 3784-3789 3792-3801
                 3864-3865 3872-3881 3893 3895 3897 3902-3903
                 3953-3972 3974-3979 3984-3989 3991 3993-4013
                 4017-4023 4025 8400-8412 8417 12293 12330-12335
                 12337-12341 12441-12442 12445-12446 12540-12542

             NAMECASE
                 GENERAL NO
                 ENTITY  NO

         DELIM
             GENERAL SGMLREF
             HCRO "&#38;#x" -- 38 is the number for ampersand --
             NESTC "/"
             NET ">"
             PIC "?>"
             SHORTREF NONE

         NAMES
             SGMLREF

         QUANTITY NONE

         ENTITIES
             "amp" 38
             "lt" 60
             "gt" 62
             "quot" 34
             "apos" 39

     FEATURES
         MINIMIZE
             DATATAG NO
             OMITTAG NO
             RANK NO
             SHORTTAG
                 STARTTAG
                     EMPTY NO
                     UNCLOSED NO 
                     NETENABL IMMEDNET
                 ENDTAG
                     EMPTY NO 
                     UNCLOSED NO
                 ATTRIB
                     DEFAULT YES
                     OMITNAME NO
                     VALUE NO
             EMPTYNRM YES
             IMPLYDEF
                 ATTLIST YES
                 DOCTYPE YES
                 ELEMENT YES
                 ENTITY YES
                 NOTATION YES
         LINK
             SIMPLE NO
             IMPLICIT NO
             EXPLICIT NO
         OTHER
             CONCUR NO
             SUBDOC NO
             FORMAL NO
             URN NO
             KEEPRSRE YES
             VALIDITY TAG
             ENTITIES
                 REF ANY
                 INTEGRAL YES
     APPINFO NONE
     SEEALSO "ISO 8879//NOTATION Application Requirements for XML//EN"
>