This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.
In the CVS version of the XQFTTS (as of 2009-11-25), I found a number of cases with whitespace issues: examples-23-q3 examples-23-q4 The expected results should allow for different order (as this a scoring case) and the presence of whitespace between the top-level elements (or not) - in total 4 results. The provided results contain one order with whitespaces, the other one without, so in total just 2. examples-37-1 The expected result contains whitespace (newline, intendation) between the contents of the <result> tag - as the boundary whitespace mode is not changed from the default (strip), this whitespace should not be present FTIgnore-q1, FTIgnore-q3, FTIgnore-q4, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q1, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q3, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q4 Expected result contain newlines between the titles, while they should not: Expected: <results><title>Software For Fun and Profit</title> <title>Software For Fun and Profit, 2nd edition</title> <title>No Bad Software</title> <title>Ninja Coder</title></results> Correct: <results><title>Software For Fun and Profit</title><title>Software For Fun and Profit, 2nd edition</title><title>No Bad Software</title><title>Ninja Coder</title></results>
examples-23-q3, examples-23-q4: We agree that the whitespacing should be consistent between the examples. This is fixed. Note that comparison should be based on canonicalization of both the test output and the expected output, however, so that insignificant whitespace introduced by a serializer does not need to be represented in alternatives. Since this is an XML fragment, the presence or absence of whitespace between the root elements is up to the serializer's discretion. examples-37-1 We agree. Fixed. FTIgnore-q1, FTIgnore-q3, FTIgnore-q4, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q1, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q3, FTIgnore-unconstrained-q4 We agree. Fixed. If you are satisified with this resolution, please mark the bug as CLOSED.