This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.
The specification requires "Identify deprecated features." Even in version 1 of a specification? (Yes, it can happen that version 1 formalizes industry practice, so defines and immediately deprecates something). Conversely, is it required to state explicitly "there are no deprecated features" to meet this requirement? Otherwise, its hard to distinguish between a pass (there are no deprecated features listed) and a fail (deprecated features are there, but were not identified as such). We suggest that a bullet "It has no deprecated features" be added to the bulleted list under "Conformance criteria".
The Working Group agreed to require a positive statement when there are no deprecated feature, with a modulation for version 1 of a specification.
added in "what does it mean" re deprecated features: "If the specified technology has already been published in a previous version of the specification, indicate which features from the previous version have been deprecated or state that none were deprecated in the conformance section"
setting version to LC in case of future use