ISSUE-240

validityToDeclaredDTD

Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD

State:

CLOSED

Product:

mobileOK Basic tests

Raised by:

Dominique Hazaël-Massieux

Opened on:

2008-03-13

Description:

validity to self-declared DTD is problematic for implementations:
 * it requires having SGML validation in checkers (for non XML versions of HTML)
 * it requires downloading DTDs from unknown locations when a page uses a non-standard doctype.

We could:
 * remove that test (given that we already have a fairly stringeant test of XHTML Basic validity)
 * replace it by requiring that step only when the System ID matches a well-known DTD (which would be listed in the spec)

Related Actions Items:

No related actions

Related emails:

1. RE: Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from miguel.garcia@fundacionctic.org on 2008-04-22)
2. Re: Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from srowen@google.com on 2008-04-18)
3. RE: Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from jrabin@mtld.mobi on 2008-04-18)
4. Re: Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from chaals@opera.com on 2008-04-18)
5. Re: Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from srowen@google.com on 2008-04-17)
6. Latest thoughts about ISSUE-240 (DTD Validation) (from miguel.garcia@fundacionctic.org on 2008-04-17)
7. [minutes] Thursday 17 April 2008 Teleconf (from fd@w3.org on 2008-04-17)
8. Re: mobileOK basic issues (from jeffs@it.rit.edu on 2008-04-17)
9. RE: mobileOK basic issues (from miguel.garcia@fundacionctic.org on 2008-04-17)
10. RE: mobileOK basic issues (from jrabin@mtld.mobi on 2008-04-16)
11. RE: mobileOK basic issues (from k.scheppe@telekom.de on 2008-04-16)
12. Re: mobileOK basic issues (from srowen@google.com on 2008-04-15)
13. mobileOK basic issues (from dom@w3.org on 2008-04-14)
14. RE: ISSUE-240: Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD [mobileOK Basic tests] (from ignacio.marin@fundacionctic.org on 2008-03-13)
15. Re: ISSUE-240: Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD [mobileOK Basic tests] (from srowen@google.com on 2008-03-13)
16. RE: ISSUE-240: Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD [mobileOK Basic tests] (from ignacio.marin@fundacionctic.org on 2008-03-13)
17. RE: ISSUE-240: Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD [mobileOK Basic tests] (from jrabin@mtld.mobi on 2008-03-13)
18. [minutes] Thursday 13 February 2008 Teleconf (from dom@w3.org on 2008-03-13)
19. ISSUE-240: Remove requirement of validity to self-declared DTD [mobileOK Basic tests] (from sysbot+tracker@w3.org on 2008-03-13)

Related notes:

Display change log