W3C | TAG | Previous: 9 Feb teleconf | Next: 2 Mar

Agenda of 23 February 2004 TAG Teleconference

Nearby: Teleconference details · issues list (handling new issues)· www-tag archive

1. Administrative (20min)

1. Roll call.
2. Proposed to accept minutes of the 9 Feb teleconf
3. Accept this agenda?
4. Proposed next meeting: 2 Mar 2004
5. Proposed to cancel 8 Mar 2004 teleconference (and reconvene 15 Mar)
6. Finalize meeting dates in August in Ottawa?

   Action PC 2004/02/09: Propose August ftf meeting dates. (done)

1.1 Technical Plenary

1. Liaisons update
2. Plenary day planning
   1. Intro to TAG and Web Arch (Stuart)
   2. Namespace documents (Dan C)
   3. Web Identifiers (Roy F? Qnames, Ids, FragID, URI andIRI)

      Action SW 2004/02/09: Find a volunteer to discuss identifiers at Tech Plenary

   4. Boilerplate:
      1. Outline issue
      2. Why TAG interested. What's difficult?
      3. Known positions around issue
      4. Encourage discussion/debate
3. TAG 2 Mar 2004 ftf meeting page
   • Review Plenary day materials
   • Webarch Last Call
   • Liasons with other WGs

2. Technical

See also open actions by owner and open issues.

2.1 Update on findings

• qnameAsId-18
  • 14 Jan 2004 draft finding "Using Qualified Names (QNames) as Identifiers in Content"
  • Action CL, TB, TBL 2004/01/26: Read finding due 9 Feb 2004.
• contentTypeOverride-24:
  • 18 Feb 2004 draft finding "Authoritative Metadata"

2.2 Follow-up on namespaceDocument-8

• namespaceDocument-8
  1. RDDL2 Background from Tim Bray.
  2. grokRDDL.xsl mapping to RDF from Dan Connolly.

2.3 Web Architecture Document Last Call

• Issues that are open and that we expect to close by the end of last call:
  • rdfmsQnameUriMapping-6
  • whenToUseGet-7
  • contentTypeOverride-24
• Review and acknowledge comments sent to public-webarch-comments@w3.org
• Action IJ 2004/02/09: Incorporate editorial suggestions (see minutes of that meeting for details).
• Action NW 2004/02/09: Respond to Hammond's comments in light of TAG discussion.
• Action PC 2004/02/09: Respond to Tom Worthington's comments in light of TAG discussion. Done. Reviewer satisfied that TAG has done due diligence, but unhappy with outcome
• Action PC 2004/02/09: Respond to Martin Dürst, acknowledging the dependency (Done).
• Action TBL 2004/02/09: Respond to David Booth on TAG's choice of agent - the status quo.
• Action SW 2004/02/09: Propose to the TAG a reponse to Patrick Stickler's message. (Done)

2.3.1 Peter Patel-Schneider

1. Comments from Peter Patel-Schneider
2. Many of the comments concern notions of authority and ownership; see related comment from David Booth about ns documents.

2.3.2 Sandro Hawke

1. Comments from Sandro Hawke

2.3.3 Dominique Hazael-Massieux

1. Comments from Dominique Hazael-Massieux
2. Comments about metadata
3. Comments about conformance

2.3.4 Danny Weitzner

1. Comments from Danny Weitzner

2.3.5 David Booth

1. Question about ns docs providing definitive info

2.3.6 Sergio Rodrigues

1. Question about XDI and XRI w.r.t. Webarch

2.3.7 Jacek Kopecky

1. AWWW LC comments

2.3.8 Martin Dürst

1. principles, etc.

The TAG does not expect to discuss the topics below this line.

4. Follow-up on Internationalization Issues

• charmodReview-17
  1. actions
  2. TAG finding related to adoption of Charmod? See mail from TBL
• URIEquivalence-15
• IRIEverywhere-27

5. Status report on these findings

See also TAG findings

• abstractComponentRefs-37:
  • 30 Oct 2003 draft finding "Abstract Component References"
• contentPresentation-26:
  • 30 June 2003 draft finding "Separation of semantic and presentational markup, to the extent possible, is architecturally sound"
• metadataInURI-31
• siteData-36
  • "There is no such thing as a Web site"

6. Other action items

• Action RF 2003/10/08: Explain "identifies" in RFC 2396.
• Action DC 2003/11/15: Follow up on KeepPOSTRecords with Janet Daly on how to raise awareness of this point (which is in CUAP).
• Action CL 2003/10/27: Draft XML mime type thingy with Murata-san