Last Call Comments on 23 Jan 2003 RDF Working Drafts

primer | concepts | xml-syntax | schema | semantics | test-cases

RDF Primer

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
danc-03rdf/xml reification examplesacceptedraisedDan Connollyaccepted
pfps-15Say anything quoteacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-17namespace v vocabularyacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted

Resource Description Framework (RDF): Concepts and Abstract Syntax

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
danc-01graph equalityacceptedraisedDan Connollynone
danc-02goofy literalsacceptedraisedDan Connollyaccepted
efth-01change namespace URIsnot acceptedraisedNick Efthymiouaccepted
jsr188-01Global Datatypingnot acceptedraisedMark Butler for CC/PP JSRaccepted
macgregor-01Distinguishing asserted and non-asserted triplesacceptedraisedBob MacGregoraccepted
macgregor-02Propositional attitudesacceptedraisedBob MacGregoraccepted
pfps-13Datatype FacetsclarificationraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-14Social MeaningacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
raisedPeter Crowtheraccepted
raisedBijan Parsiaaccepted
raisedJim Hendler for Webontnone
pfps-16RDF's Expressive PoweracceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-18namespace v vocabularyacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-22reserved names in abstract syntaxacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-23sanctioned by?acceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
reagle-01XMLLiteral equalityacceptedraisedEric Prud'hommeauxnone
raisedJoseph Reagleaccepted
raisedJim Hendler for Webontnone
reagle-02exc-c14n throughoutacceptedraisedEric Prud'hommeauxnone
raisedJoseph Reagleaccepted
tex-01case of lang tagsclarificationraisedTex Texinaccepted
tex-02sub langauge literal comparepostponedraisedTex Texinnone
williams-01What is a node in an RDF graph?acceptedraisedStuart Williamsaccepted
williams-02s/URIref/IRI/not acceptedraisedStuart Williamsaccepted
raisedTex Texinnone
xmlsch-01Typed Literal Structurenot acceptedraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-02whitespace facetacceptedraisedXML Schema WGnone
xmlsch-03lexical mappingclarificationraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-04values without lexical formsclarificationraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-05character sequencesnot acceptedraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-06natural language dataacceptedraisedXML Schema WGaccepted

RDF/XML Syntax Specification (Revised)

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
chas-01aboutEachPrefixnot acceptedraisedCharles McCathieNevilenone
hendler-01literals in parsetype collectionpostponedraisedJim Hendleraccepted
raisedJim Hendler for Webontaccepted
krech-01emptyPropertyElt ambiguityacceptedraisedDaniel Krechaccepted
hodder-01RDF in HTMLacceptedraisedDave Hodderaccepted
pfps-19namespace v vocabularyacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
timbl-01bagid neededacceptedraisedTim Berners-Leeaccepted
timbl-03collection clutteracceptedraisedTim Berners-Leenone
xmlsch-08xsi:typeacceptedraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-09qnamesacceptedraisedXML Schema WGaccepted
xmlsch-10cannonical syntaxpostponedraisedXML Schema WGnot accepted
xmlsch-11layering on xmlclarificationraisedXML Schema WGnot accepted
xmlsch-12capricious syntaxpostponedraisedMark Butleraccepted
raisedXML Schema WGnone

RDF Vocabulary Description Language 1.0: RDF Schema

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
danc-04triviallyTrue predicatenot acceptedraisedDan Connollynone
raisedIan Horrocksaccepted
eikon-01define rdfs:SchemaacceptedraisedDaniel "eikeon" Krechaccepted
pfps-11rdfs:comment implies entailmentsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-12Lists are not well formedacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
raisedKarsten Tolleaccepted
pfps-20namespace v vocabularyacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-24What is RDF Schema?acceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneidernone
pfps-25Schema semanticsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
qu-04RDF/XML RepresentationacceptedraisedQu Yuzhongaccepted
vass-01flat layeringnot acceptedraisedVassilis Christophidesnone
vass-02property instancesacceptedraisedVassilis Christophidesnone
webont-01rename schemanot acceptedraisedJim Hendler for Webontaccepted

RDF Semantics

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
horrocks-01rdfs:comment semanticsnot acceptedraisedIan Horrocksaccepted
horst-01RDFS entailment lemmaacceptedraisedHerman ter Horstaccepted
pan-01Extending to FOLpostponedraisedJeff Z Panaccepted
pfps-01XML Schema datatypesacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-02Lbase translation of XML LiteralsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-03translation to LbaseacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-04RDF closure rulesacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneidernot accepted
pfps-05RDFS closure rulesacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneidernot accepted
pfps-06typed XML literals and LVacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-07typed literals with lang tagsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-08typed literalsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-09datatypesacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-10untyped literalsacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
pfps-21namespace v vocabularyacceptedraisedPeter F. Patel-Schneideraccepted
timbl-02reification semanticsnot acceptedraisedTim Berners-Leenone
qu-01Domain of rdfs:membernot acceptedraisedQu Yuzhongaccepted
qu-02rdfs:member functional?not acceptedraisedQu Yuzhongnone
qu-03Ontology subset of RDFSpostponedraisedQu Yuzhongaccepted
reagle-03must use xsd:?not acceptedraisedJoseph Reagleaccepted
xmlsch-07datatype definitionResolutionraisedXML Schema WGaccepted

RDF Test Cases

idtitlewg responseraisedbyraiser's response
jang-01datatype subclass entailmentacceptedraisedJan Grantnone
jjc-01rdfms-nested-bagIDs/test007.rdfacceptedraisedJeremy Carrollaccepted