Talk:SC1-2-2-video-element

• This page doesn't use the same logic flow as the test on for example this page:

https://www.w3.org/community/auto-wcag/wiki/SC4-1-1-tag-nesting

• A few of the steps do contain outcome tables but don't explicitly state when to return those outcomes (although most of the time it is clear from the text). For example "File content contains time codes and text" (step 4) could be

"IF File content does't contains time codes and text: RETURN SC122-videoelement-fail#"

• Testmode is missing on each step and selector.
• The page states "success criterion doesn't take into account language changes. So it is valid to have spoken text in language 1, subtitles in language 2 and page content in language 3." But I would argue that in that case the captions are not an equivalent to the audio track.

--Wfiers

• Suggestion: Add reference to Technique H95
• Selector: There is not track-attribute in HTML5. It should say: "track element with kind attribute".
• Step 2: Not clear what happens if the attribute is found.
• Step 8: What is the intention of this step? Why is there no need for further testing for 'talking head' videos? Suggestion: Remove this step.
• Step 10: What is a "background fragment"? Step 11: What is a "speaker fragment"? Please clarify.
• Suggest to split this test into two parts. (1) automated part checking for the presence and correct format of the file. (2) Manual check that the captions describe the video.
• The test mode of the steps should be either automatic or manual. SemiAuto should not be used (in step 6 and 8). In this case the step should be spilt into two steps.

--Anietzio