Disposition of comments

Title
Media Queries
Date
2010-07-27
Document URL
http://www.w3.org/TR/2010/CR-css3-mediaqueries-20100727/

There were no objections.

# Author Summary and discussion Actions for WG Result
1: Tab Atkins

Allow 'tv', 'handheld' and 'projection' to match at the same time as 'screen'

  1. comment
  2. reply
Rejected and verified
2. Yves Lafon

<ratio> which is used by MQ is neither in CSS2.1 nor in css3-values

  1. comment
  2. reply
Out of scope and verified
3. Yves Lafon

Disallow spaces in ratios

  1. comment
  2. reply
Rejected and verified
4. Jarek Foksa

Isn't "@media { ... }" disallowed by the grammar?

  1. comment
  2. reply
Retracted
5. Boris Zbarsky

Don't contradict normative text in note

  1. comment
  2. reply
Accepted
6. Boris Zbarsky

Be explicit about the behavior of the rem unit

  1. comment
  2. reply
Rejected and verified
7. Simon Sapin

Conflict with css3-page

  1. comment
  2. reply
Retracted
8. Lea Verou

Using CSS units rather than Physical ones is problematic

  1. comment
Out of scope and Discussion moved to css3-values; assumed verified

Legend:

StatusMeaning
Retracted Commenter has withdrawn the comment.
Accepted The WG accepted and applied the comment.
Out of scope and verified Commenter accepts that the comment is out of scope.
Invalid and verified Commenter accepts that the comment is invalid.
Rejected and verified Commenter accepts that the WG did not apply the comment.
Out of scope but unverified Comment out of scope, but commenter did not yet react.
Invalid but unverified Comment invalid, but commenter did not yet react.
Rejected but unverified Comment rejected, but commenter did not yet react.
Out of scope with objection Comment out of scope, but commenter disagrees.
Invalid with objection Comment invalid, but commenter disagrees.
Rejected with objection Comment rejected, but commenter objects.

This file was generated from issues-2012-04.txt on 13 April 2012.