5923 2008-07-31 20:25:28 +0000 Requirements on schema documents 2008-08-14 22:13:14 +0000 1 1 1 Unclassified SML Core LC PC Windows XP RESOLVED FIXED resolved P2 normal --- 1 sandygao virginia.smith kumarp pratul.dublish virginia.smith public-sml oldest_to_newest 21419 0 sandygao 2008-07-31 20:25:28 +0000 In the conformance section 8, "2 Each XML Schema document in the model's definition documents MUST satisfy the conditions expressed in Errors in Schema Construction and Structure (§5.1). [XML Schema Structures]" Section 5.1 in schema structures is about errors when schemas are constructed, but there may be schema documents in an SML model that do not participate in schema construction. For example, what if a schema document is only transmitted in the IF and is meant to be merged with other docs to assemble a schema? When a schema document is used to construct a schema, then the result schema must satisfy all rules in the schema spec; if a schema document is not used to construct any schema, then it still needs to be a good schema document. We need to distinguish these 2 cases in the conformance rules. For example: "2a For each XML Schema document in the model's definition documents, the [validity] property of the root element MUST be "valid" when schema validity is assessed with respect to a schema constructed from the "schema for schemas" and the "normative SML schema" schema documents. 2b All schemas assembled from the XML Schema documents in the model's definition documents MUST satisfy the conditions expressed in Errors in Schema Construction and Structure (§5.1). [XML Schema Structures] Note: This specification does not define how many schemas are assembled and which schema documents contribute to assembling the schemas." 21473 1 pratul.dublish 2008-08-07 19:41:20 +0000 Resolution in 8/7 call - fix as per Sandy's proposal in Comment #1 - 2a and 2b 21519 2 virginia.smith 2008-08-12 23:57:41 +0000 Fixed per comment #1. See diff at: http://www.w3.org/2007/10/htmldiff?doc1=http%3A%2F%2Fdev.w3.org%2Fcvsweb%2F~checkout~%2F2007%2Fxml%2Fsml%2Fbuild%2Fsml.html%3Frev%3D1.242%26content-type%3Dtext%2Fhtml%3B%2520charset%3Diso-8859-1&doc2=http%3A%2F%2Fdev.w3.org%2Fcvsweb%2F~checkout~%2F2007%2Fxml%2Fsml%2Fbuild%2Fsml.html%3Frev%3D1.243%26content-type%3Dtext%2Fhtml%3B%2520charset%3Diso-8859-1#Conformance 21530 3 sandygao 2008-08-13 20:25:26 +0000 > a schema constructed from the "schema for schemas" and > the "normative SML schema" schema documents. The above can benefit from links to http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema.xsd and appendix A. "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema.xsd" may warrant a new entry in section 10.1 Normative References. 21542 4 kumarp 2008-08-14 04:24:49 +0000 +1. Also agree with Sandy's suggestion in comment# 3. 21560 5 kumarp 2008-08-14 18:42:01 +0000 resolution on 8/14: Add the references suggested in comment# 3. Does not need review after changes are made. 21568 6 virginia.smith 2008-08-14 22:13:14 +0000 Bullet 2 in section 8 changed to the following (text enclosed in '*' are links to a normative reference or a section in the spec. --------- For each XML Schema document in the model's definition documents, the [validity] property of the root element MUST be "valid" when schema validity is assessed with respect to a schema constructed from the *XML Schema for Schemas* and *A. Normative SML Schema* schema documents. -------- New normative reference: ------- [XML Schema for Schemas] XML Schema for XML Schemas. World Wide Web Consortium, 2 May 2001, revised 28 October 2004. -------