29489 2016-02-20 04:58:08 +0000 hashless color quirk definition doesn't interact correctly with scientific notation 2016-02-23 10:21:58 +0000 1 1 1 Unclassified WHATWG Quirks Mode unspecified All All RESOLVED WONTFIX P2 normal Unsorted 1 dbaron zcorpan mike sideshowbarker+quirksspec oldest_to_newest 125171 0 dbaron 2016-02-20 04:58:08 +0000 Inspired by: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1249755 https://quirks.spec.whatwg.org/#the-hashless-hex-color-quirk says: If cv's type flag is not "integer", return an error. Since CSS has introduced scientific notation to numbers, "633e12" is a <number> tokens that is not an integer, and "63e1fa" is a <dimension> token that is not an integer. In Gecko I plan to fix this by ignoring the token stream and rescanning the buffer. I'm not sure how to fix the spec. 125208 1 zcorpan 2016-02-22 18:25:47 +0000 This was intentional. See https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1249755#c10 In httparchive chrome_jan_15_2016_* dataset of 470k pages, looking only at those in quirks mode (see https://github.com/HTTPArchive/httparchive/issues/40#issuecomment-187264991), I see 3362 resources using hashless colors, but only 60 using scientific notation colors. Those are listed below. Since Gecko/WebKit/Blink have had "broken" behavior for a long time, and it has worked out OK, I'm reluctant to change this. But if you still think we should, I think it would be a good idea to check the pages below and see if they have better rendering in Chrome, Gecko, or IE. quirk_pages_url requests_url scinot_color http://www.folhape.com.br/ http://www.folhape.com.br/css/terra-estilo.css color:3e3e3e http://www.biggolf.co.kr/ http://www.biggolf.co.kr/shop/data/skin/season2/style.css color:0e9f7f http://www.bookoa.com/ http://www.bookoa.com/style/css/style.css color:0005e0 http://www.polartour.ru/ http://www.polartour.ru/ color: 3567e7 http://www.csrdn.qc.ca/ http://www.csrdn.qc.ca/2csrdn.css color:172e68 http://www.popculturemadness.com/ http://popculturemadness.com/CSS.css color: 37e1f0 http://www.pickupphone.biz/ http://n.pickupphone.biz/web/css/style.css color:2e7acc http://www.adpanchok.co.kr/ http://www.adpanchok.co.kr/ez/index.php color:4e4e4e http://www.respaper.com/ http://www.respaper.com/ color:0e774a http://www.crazyprofile.com/ http://www.crazyprofile.com/ color:175e70 http://www.mtv123.com/ http://www.mtv123.com/CSS/pubic.css color:077e9a http://www.superbex.co.kr/ http://hostinfo.cafe24.com/index.php?hostname=uws64-109.cafe24.com color: 9e3264 http://www.smautomall.com/ http://www.smautomall.com/html/mainm.html?ref= color:2e3b43 http://www.wedoor.com/ http://www.wedoor.com/ color:5e5e5e http://www.wineaudio.com/ http://www.wineaudio.com/shop/data/skin/apple_tree/style.css color:7e7e7e http://www.hoinaru.ro/ http://www.hoinaru.ro/ color:3e3e3e http://www.avmagazine.com.hk/ http://www.avmagazine.com.hk/common/style.css color: 1e3282 http://www.hanafax.com/ http://www.hanafax.com/include/css/hfax_css.css color:4e7e28 http://www.itq.or.kr/ http://www.itq.or.kr/include/css/intro.css color: 7e7e7e http://www.gomsee.com/ http://www.gomsee.com/css/orbit.css color:9e7147 http://www.ledist.co.kr/ http://www.ledist.co.kr/style/common.css color:3e760c http://www.byus.net/ http://www.byus.net/ color:2e77ac http://www.faithstreet.com/ http://www.faithstreet.com/assets/application-8332573036cc06f35cc29acafb405bd6164b22823ee1fa3951d65ba3d7ee1fb9.css color:3e8eeeb http://www.mysql.ru/ http://www.mysql.ru/style.css color:3e608d http://www.zone-url.com/ http://zonurl.com/css/styles.css color:898e91 http://www.koban.co.kr/ http://www.koban.co.kr/default/inc/company.css color:0e3d72 http://www.omypc.co.kr/ http://www.omypc.co.kr/style/common.css color:3e760c http://www.omypc.co.kr/ http://www.omypc.co.kr/config/user.css color:3e760c http://www.ilhak.co.kr/ http://www.ilhak.co.kr/css/style.css color:5e5e5e http://www.affilcenter.com/ http://www.affilcenter.com/ color:5e83ff http://www.boonty.com/ http://us.boonty.com/css/styles.css color:6e6e6e http://www.mayblue.co.kr/ http://www.mayblue.co.kr/ color:5e5e5e http://www.luckyplanet.co.kr/ http://www.luckyplanet.co.kr/ color:6e6e6e http://www.cox.kr/ http://www.cox.kr/css/main.css color:0e4392 http://www.chicfox.co.kr/ http://www.chicfox.co.kr/ color:6e6e6e http://www.mathhelpforum.com/ http://mathhelpforum.com/clientscript/vbulletin_css/style00026l/main-rollup.css?d=1429110780 color:3e3e3e http://www.vipclips.net/ http://vipclips.net/_st/my.css color:8e8e8e http://www.artkultr.com/ http://www.artkultr.com/ color: 3e3e3e http://www.artkultr.com/ http://www.artkultr.com/ color: 3e3e3e http://www.telerehber.com/ http://www.telerehber.com/css.css color: 2e62b1 http://www.interpunk.com/ http://www.interpunk.com/ color: 2749e9 http://www.tax-brackets.org/ http://www.tax-brackets.org/ color: 715e00 http://www.webdelcule.com/ http://www.webdelcule.com/diario.htm color: 0000e8 http://www.lynxmotion.com/ http://www.lynxmotion.com/skins/Skin_1/style.css color: 1e1e1e http://www.islamicity.com/ http://www.islamicity.com/global/islamicity.css color: 1e3d70 http://www.sachal.net/ http://www.sachal.net/imgs/text.css color:5e91bf http://www.61ic.com/ http://www.61ic.com/Skin/DefaultSkin.css color: 1e50a2 http://www.newkadia.com/ http://www.newkadia.com/NKcss.php color:8e236b http://www.scanboat.com/ http://www.scanboat.com/css.css?1 color:1e3853 http://www.lizardpoint.com/ http://lizardpoint.com/ color:5e5c1c http://www.radiosargentina.com.ar/ http://www.radiosargentina.com.ar/arindice.css color: 0e065c http://www.al-eman.com/ http://www.al-eman.com/css/alemanStyles-min.css color:495e13 http://www.forumtransportu.pl/ http://www.forumtransportu.pl/ color:033e82 http://www.trainingpro.com/ http://www.trainingpro.com/includes/style_ie.css color : 2e6ade http://www.lapreferente.com/ http://www.lapreferente.com/estilos.css?f=20151125 color:190e7f http://www.greekshares.com/ http://www.greekshares.com/css/css.css color: 9e0314 http://www.catholicgiftshop.co.uk/ http://r.b5z.net/zirw/120/i/u/8100167/i/menu/s.css color:0073e5 http://www.porart.com/ http://www.porart.com/css/style.css color:2e2e2e http://www.directfromlourdes.com/ http://m.b5z.net/zirw/265/i/u/6128774/i/menu/s.css color:0073e5 http://www.parstradeshow.com/ http://www.parstradeshow.com/css/pts.css color: 004e9e 125219 2 zcorpan 2016-02-23 09:46:23 +0000 I looked through all of them. I found 13 where there was *some* visual difference, but none of them are actually broken. So it's 0.0027% of pages in this dataset where this bug affects pages at all. I suggest keeping the spec as is. Analysis follows: http://www.csrdn.qc.ca/template.asp?p=rh Table.Menu2 td.menu2 background-color is ignored, but it also has a background-image, so not really noticeable. http://www.adpanchok.co.kr/ez/index.php <a href='./mall.php?cat=001001000' style='color:4e4e4e;font-weight:bold;padding:0 0 0 10px;'>점착메모(포스트잇)</a> The color is black instead of dark gray. Not noticeable unless you toggle the style in inspector. http://www.respaper.com/ <a href="/batman247/about" style="color:0E774A;">batman247</a> 1 sec ago The text is black instead of green. Noticeable if you know it should be green, but it's not broken. http://hostinfo.cafe24.com/index.php?hostname=uws64-109.cafe24.com .unnamed4 Some text is black instead of pink. Noticeable if you know it should be pink, but it's not broken. http://www.wedoor.com/ <span style="color:5e5e5e;font-size:11px">|</span> A vertical bar in the footer is black instead of gray. Not noticeable. http://www.mysql.ru/ a:hover The link doesn't get a slightly darker color on hover. Noticeable if you know it should, but it's not broken. http://www.affilcenter.com/ <a ... style="font-size:11px;color:5E83FF;"> Mot de passe oublié </a> The link is the default blue instead of a lighter blue. Since the background is dark blue, it's hard to read. But you can guess what the link is based on context ("forgot password") http://www.luckyplanet.co.kr/ .mainbrandname Some text has a slightly different shade of gray. Not noticeable. http://www.cox.kr/ A:hover Links don't get a blue hover. Noticeable if you know they should, but it's not broken. http://vipclips.net/load/kategorija_klipa/videoklip/rihanna_work/80-1-0-17475 .entryTitle The heading is black instead of gray. Noticeable if you know it should be, but it's not broken. http://www.tax-brackets.org/ <td class='taxAmount' style='color: 715e00'><b>6.12%</b></td> The text is black instead of fitting in the gradient of colors in the column. Noticeable but not broken. http://lizardpoint.com/ A:link, A:visited Links are default colors instead of greenish. Noticeable if you know it should be greenish, but not broken. http://www.lapreferente.com/ .link190e7fInside:link The social media links are default link colors instead of a different shade of blue. Not really noticeable. 125220 3 zcorpan 2016-02-23 10:21:58 +0000 (Added a note in https://github.com/whatwg/quirks/commit/4d3fab3b2481d94b95bc8a66cb0959a7bfdc8946 )