1064 2005-01-27 15:14:34 +0000 WSDL dilemma about outbound operations not fully resolved 2005-07-18 17:42:06 +0000 1 1 1 Unclassified WS Choreography Last Call Comment: Confirmed Closed unspecified PC Linux CLOSED FIXED http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor-comments/2005Jan/0025.html P2 normal -- 1 gritzinger martin.chapman martin.chapman oldest_to_newest 2919 0 gritzinger 2005-01-27 15:14:34 +0000 I think your group has not fully resolved the WSDL dilemma about outbound operations. I had raised that before, it might be that I don't understand, but you are limiting all WSDLs to have inbound operations only (note that this is a recommendation of WS-I). So, I did not see how in the interaction element you could actually specify that this outbound operation maps to this inbound operation. We are supporting this in ebBP (we call it operation mapping). We can map any combination of operations to an ebBP business transaction and we can also map WS operatoins together, from one party to another. JJ- 4204 1 martin.chapman 2005-02-14 21:30:05 +0000 From 8-feb-05 concall: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/member-ws-chor/2005Feb/att-0003/Minutes- 02082005-0.txt left open subject to response from JJ 4042 2 charlton_b 2005-02-15 18:01:46 +0000 After discussing with JJ, we've clarified that the issue he's raised is how does one specify the mapping between outbound and inbound operations (or inbound and outbound operations) in a CDL. I've indicated that any and all such mapping details are not the domain of CDL, but delegated to lower-layer specifications/stacks (WSDL, WS-Addressing, BPEL, etc.) which carry such responsibilities. We are in agreement that CDL is not the level at which one specifies mapping. JJ in the meantime will review the other involved specifications to better clarify when and where such mapping takes place. 4068 3 charlton_b 2005-02-16 23:45:06 +0000 After discussion with JJ we are in agreement on the following w.r.t. issue #1064: - We agree that issue #1064 concerns where mapping between operations is defined and how is this mapping performed in CDL. - We agree that mapping between operations is outside the scope of CDL and delegated to underlying specificiations (XSLT, XPath, WSDL, WS-Addressing, BPEL, etc.). - We agree that further review of these other, underlying specifications may be necessary to further clarify how and where mapping is performed. - We agree that either of both of us would raise any issues w.r.t. mapping with these specifications with their respective WG/TCs. As such I am marking this issue as "FIXED". 4803 4 martin.chapman 2005-07-18 17:42:06 +0000 JJ has been informed of the resolution and has confirmed it is acceptable: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-chor-comments/2005Jul/0010.html