16:58:45 RRSAgent has joined #aria 16:58:49 logging to https://www.w3.org/2026/08/27-aria-irc 16:58:49 RRSAgent, make logs Public 16:58:50 Meeting: ARIA WG 16:59:02 Agendabot, find agenda 16:59:02 jamesn, OK. This may take a minute... 16:59:02 agenda: https://www.w3.org/events/meetings/690d057f-db6d-4169-b13f-68d7f1336b59/20260827T130000/ 16:59:02 clear agenda 16:59:02 agenda+ -> New PR Triage https://github.com/search?q=is%3Aopen+is%3Apr+created:%3E=2026-08-20+repo:w3c/aria&type=Issues 16:59:03 agenda+ -> New Issue Triage https://tinyurl.com/4bt2ecnb 16:59:06 agenda+ -> WPT Open PRs https://tinyurl.com/wpt-a11y 16:59:08 agenda+ -> TPAC Plannning https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3AF2FCandidate 16:59:11 agenda+ -> Security Horizontal Review https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues/2861 16:59:14 agenda+ -> Allow aria-valuetext for use with combobox role https://github.com/w3c/aria/pull/2417 16:59:17 agenda+ -> Expectations for aria-hidden and focused elements https://github.com/w3c/aria/pull/2181 16:59:21 pkra has joined #aria 17:00:30 zakim, drop item 1 17:00:30 agendum 1, -> New PR Triage https://github.com/search?q=is%3Aopen+is%3Apr+created:%3E=2026-08-20+repo:w3c/aria&type=Issues, dropped 17:00:49 present+ 17:01:29 present+ 17:01:53 giacomo-petri has joined #aria 17:02:08 present+ 17:02:28 ChrisCuellar has joined #aria 17:02:39 present+ 17:03:47 scribe+ 17:03:52 zakim, next item 17:03:52 agendum 2 -- -> New Issue Triage https://tinyurl.com/4bt2ecnb -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:03:52 I can't comment on that because it doesn't look like a github issue to me. 17:04:11 jamesn: no new PRs so on to new issue triage. 17:04:38 ... first one is editorial. dpub-aria. 17:05:34 ... next one aria 2875. different outline algorithm. 17:05:41 katez has joined #aria 17:05:43 present+ 17:06:00 ... we should probably agenda this 17:06:31 HaTheo has joined #ARIA 17:07:06 present+ 17:07:32 ... next aria 2872. 17:08:56 pkra: I filed this because I had piggybacked on the older issue which was discussed but not this one. 17:09:43 ... I find it unfortunate that we have specified meter for the HTML parity but there hasn't been uptake in AT. narrator even dropping support in my testing compared to tetralogical. 17:09:44 jcraig has joined #aria 17:10:16 mattking: that's what aria-at is all about. It allows us to identify and help with this kind of thing. 17:10:50 jamesn: this seems like it could fit in a larger conversation about missing features in AT from the specs. 17:11:20 agenda? 17:11:42 mattking: aria-at would be a natural path for tha. 17:11:58 jamesn: let's try that. 17:12:09 ... next up: align area with anchor from giacomo. 17:12:21 ... there's a WPT PR 17:12:28 Matt_King has joined #aria 17:12:35 giacomo: the WPT PR is for anchor but not area. 17:12:35 present+ 17:12:55 ... I opened it because links are more common but they are so close. 17:13:00 ... I think we should align implementations. 17:13:33 ... the WPT test demonstrates that there's no consistency, even in chrome, anchor and area differ. 17:13:50 jamesn: just for completeness: do we have a use case? 17:13:53 cyns: decades ago? 17:14:36 jamesn: personally seems like a problem that might not need a solution. If there's time in the group and implementations, then ok. 17:16:11 jcraig: it does seem minor. 17:16:29 giacomo: we found it in our tooling so it seemed worth it. 17:16:44 jcraig: a real use case is a good reason. 17:17:20 giacomo: I'll double check and follow up. 17:17:39 zakim, next item 17:17:39 agendum 3 -- -> WPT Open PRs https://tinyurl.com/wpt-a11y -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:17:39 I can't comment on that because it doesn't look like a github issue to me. 17:18:11 present+ 17:18:12 q+ 17:18:24 jcraig: only 2 new ones. First one is not important. Second we just discussed. 17:18:27 Ack Rahim 17:18:33 rahim: a few are waiting for review. 17:19:08 ... I'll ping separately 17:19:16 jcraig: sounds good. 17:19:31 zakim, next item 17:19:31 agendum 4 -- -> TPAC Plannning https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3AF2FCandidate -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:19:31 I can't comment on that because it doesn't look like a github issue to me. 17:19:57 jamesn: if you have a deep dive, please make an issue. 17:20:00 ... some are leftover. 17:20:31 ... we could repeat them. Three are newer. 17:21:21 ... the dev tools one could use more ideas. We might even run some coding sessions. 17:22:16 jcraig: sounds great. 17:22:52 ... is there interest in sharing agent specific skills or tooling? 17:23:40 ... since agentic coding is so new, people are at varying levels of competency. We've been encouraging people to use these tools. Maybe we can get more people involved. 17:23:56 ... share how people use these tools. 17:24:12 cyns has joined #aria 17:24:17 present+ 17:24:34 jamesn: I'll create a placeholder issue. 17:24:47 jcraig: maybe separate sessions to come back to. 17:25:00 jamesn: relies on people having access to the tools. 17:25:22 ... free version probably not enough. 17:25:55 ... and maybe people won't be able to get their access up&running. 17:26:03 cyns: breakouts might work? 17:26:29 jcraig: I thought that's for other uses. But same time perhaps. 17:26:59 ... projecting might be useful. 17:27:49 jamens: if you have other ideas, please add issues with the label. 17:28:03 ... update on openui probably makes a good repeat. 17:28:41 ... the other two might not be but take a look. 17:29:09 cyns: lola and I are working on a breakout. 17:29:16 https://github.com/w3c/tpac2026-breakouts/issues/3 17:29:20 jamesn: great. send us the time? 17:29:35 zakim, next item 17:29:35 agendum 5 -- -> Security Horizontal Review https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues/2861 -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:30:10 q+ 17:30:48 jamesn: jcraig could you review this? 17:31:32 jcraig: PR #2869 ? 17:31:35 jamesn: yes. 17:31:54 q? 17:32:43 Daniel: security contact had suggestions. I can update the PR or open a new one. 17:32:48 jamesn: let's add it. 17:33:13 jcraig: what's the issue? 17:33:41 jamesn: using notify to get people to behave differently to identify AT users. 17:34:01 jcraig: it's "just" cloaking/masking. I can draft a note. 17:34:36 ... I wouldn't call this a security issue. There are much bigger problems in the JS event model. 17:35:05 ... remember when we pushed back on other review, saying this should then also be added to DOM, HTML etc. 17:35:14 ... we filed this as a TAG issue that's just been sitting around. 17:35:38 jamesn: aren't we covering this then by the text for this? 17:35:55 jcraig: maybe not passive but active fingerprinting? 17:36:06 daniel: re jamesn I think so. 17:36:10 jamesn: can we push it back? 17:36:21 jcraig: maybe push back with PRs to HTML and DOM? 17:36:26 q? 17:36:41 daniel: that would block us though. 17:37:15 ... if firing up arianotify, would it map it to AAPIs without AT active? 17:37:48 jcraig: it would require root access to know this so then there are bigger problems. It's not about ARIA. 17:37:58 ... same for event model. 17:38:08 daniel: maybe invite Simone to a session. 17:38:12 jcraig: or breakout. 17:38:17 daniel: sure. 17:38:41 jamesn: let's set something up. 17:39:15 Ack Daniel 17:39:15 present+ 17:39:17 zakim, next item 17:39:17 agendum 6 -- -> Allow aria-valuetext for use with combobox role https://github.com/w3c/aria/pull/2417 -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:39:25 agenda? 17:39:49 jamesn: this PR has been reviewed by three people. 17:40:02 ... last time, mattking wanted to create a PR. 17:40:25 mattking: right. I think the changes here are too light. There's info missing how this would work. 17:40:35 ... I think I can get to those answers without taking up group time. 17:41:14 ... I suggest not to merge, depending how urgent this is. I can add my concerns to the PR if that helps? 17:41:16 jamesn: yes please. 17:41:20 zakim, next item 17:41:20 agendum 7 -- -> Expectations for aria-hidden and focused elements https://github.com/w3c/aria/pull/2181 -- taken up [from agendabot] 17:42:34 jamesn: looking at the minutes from the last discussion, there were comments from jamie that we needed to address. 17:42:57 q+ 17:43:12 Ack Rahim 17:43:37 rahim: Aaron mentioned that there is a chromium implementation. Has any other browser done this? I had created a draft for webkit. 17:45:49 pkra: jamie's last comment is from september. Was this discussed more at TPAC? 17:45:53 jamesn: not sure. 17:46:32 q+ 17:47:07 ... it's interesting to look through the linked issues. Seems like AI review tools are creating these. 17:47:19 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1944935 17:47:49 q+ 17:48:03 pkra: I found a bugzilla bug from last year. 17:48:07 jamesn: I'll add it. 17:49:27 giacomo: I think we should ask for real user feedback. People use it intentionally but forget tabindex -1. Exposing them might be confusing. Unless tabbing, these might be skipped by screenreaders which could make it even more confusing to expose them. 17:49:35 qq+ 17:49:42 Ack giacomo-petri 17:50:11 jamesn: I thought this was only for exposing content when focused. Not just focusable content with aria-hidden. 17:50:19 Ack me 17:50:19 jamesn, you wanted to react to Rahim 17:50:27 Ack Rahim 17:50:37 rahim: I think that's correct. 17:50:54 q+ 17:51:07 ... you have to do a tree walk. If it's inside a container, the entire branch should be un-hidden. 17:51:27 ... one of the WPTs that need review is about aria-hidden. We might be able to piggy back on that. 17:51:29 Ack Matt_King 17:51:37 I would be happy to write a WPT. 17:52:14 mattking: this is still an author error recovery mechanism though. I don't think author intent can always be clear when you're recovering. 17:52:22 ... so we're looking for a least bad option. 17:52:49 jamesn: right. From Valerie's comment, there's still work to do in Chrome, too. 17:53:18 WPT for testing aria-hidden using label that could be used to test this potentially: https://github.com/web-platform-tests/wpt/pull/45694 17:53:28 mattking: consistency is super important here. 17:54:20 jamesn: ok it seems the spec is ok but this PR is almost too long and old. Does anyone want to try to move it forward? 17:55:13 rahim: I can follow up with scott. 17:55:15 jamesn: thanks. 17:55:19 q? 17:55:26 zakim, end meeting 17:55:26 As of this point the attendees have been pkra, filippo-zorzi, giacomo-petri, Daniel, katez, HaTheo, Matt_King, Rahim, cyns, JohnJansen 17:55:28 RRSAgent, please draft minutes v2 17:55:29 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2026/08/27-aria-minutes.html Zakim 17:55:32 I am happy to have been of service, pkra; please remember to excuse RRSAgent. Goodbye 17:55:36 Zakim has left #aria 20:19:24 ChrisCuellar has joined #aria 21:47:56 ChrisCuellar has joined #aria 22:44:18 ChrisCuellar has joined #aria