14:26:08 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #voiceinteraction
14:26:12 <RRSAgent> logging to https://www.w3.org/2025/04/23-voiceinteraction-irc
14:26:39 <dadahl> meeting: Voice Interaction
14:26:49 <dadahl> scribe: dadahl
14:27:16 <dadahl> topic: GitHub issue 65, compare semantic representations
14:27:39 <dadahl> chair: debbie
14:31:04 <kaz> kaz has joined #voiceinteraction
14:38:24 <dadahl> JROSI features
14:42:02 <dadahl> nbest with start and stop times and "medium" and "mode", medium possibly not needed
14:42:57 <dadahl> version
14:43:48 <dadahl> multiple interpretations
14:46:05 <dadahl> every interpretation has tokens, id and confidence
14:47:39 <dadahl> debbie: do we need all semantic structure now because of LLMs
14:48:32 <dadahl> dirk: is emma really suited to cover LLM systems
14:49:32 <dadahl> debbie: we don't need all this semantic structure today
14:49:45 <dadahl> dirk: maybe only a subset would be needed
14:50:55 <dadahl> debbie: maybe not necessary for interactive systems
14:51:12 <dadahl> dirk: the full EMMA spec would be overkill
14:52:09 <dadahl> debbie: a lot of EMMA is optional
14:54:10 <dadahl> debbie: we're talking about requirements for voice interaction
14:54:48 <dadahl> dirk: we could use some EMMA metadata and multimodal information
14:55:30 <dadahl> debbie: EMMA 1.0 and JROSI don't cover streaming
14:56:19 <dadahl> debbie: should we include streaming?
14:56:42 <dadahl> dirk: we should support streaming to an endpoint
14:58:20 <dadahl> debbie: we could look for streaming in old EMMA 2.0 document and see if we could use that
14:58:46 <dadahl> dirk: maybe use a subset
14:59:10 <dadahl> debbie: work with Open Voice on EMMA
14:59:29 <dadahl> s/EMMA/streaming
15:01:01 <dadahl> dirk: let's look at Open Voice
15:01:02 <dadahl> https://github.com/open-voice-interoperability/docs/blob/main/specifications/DialogEvents/1.0.2/InteropDialogEventSpecs.md
15:01:54 <dadahl> timestamp, id, speakerUri
15:04:51 <dadahl> debbie: looking at section 1.4 of Dialog Events
15:04:57 <dadahl> topic: workshop
15:05:31 <kaz> -> https://github.com/w3c/smartagents-workshop/blob/main/README.md Draft CfP
15:06:23 <kaz> * should rather concentrate on voice interaction
15:06:23 <kaz> * how to deal with use cases like connected cars?
15:06:23 <kaz> * should mention what would be the impact to the Web platform
15:06:25 <dadahl> kaz: brought CFP to W3C Strategy meeting
15:07:18 <dadahl> kaz: avoid dealing with AI-based agents concentrate on voice
15:11:37 <dadahl> dirk: voice and smart agents overlap
15:14:54 <dadahl> kaz: impact on the web platform, but standards are not just web browser, for example web data
15:16:16 <dadahl> ...how to identify person and credentials
15:16:46 <dadahl> dirk: doesn't this overlap with security?
15:17:27 <dadahl> kaz: security is very important to smart agents
15:17:44 <dadahl> dirk: can we include smart agents
15:19:29 <dadahl> kaz: will update proposal
15:20:44 <dadahl> ...core target should be voice and multimodal interaction
15:22:47 <dadahl> kaz: will update proposal and take it back to W3C Strategy
15:24:03 <dadahl> ... will check on when to form PC
15:26:42 <dadahl> kaz: can start to work on converting MD to HTML
15:28:01 <dadahl> dirk: should wait to create a table of possible topics until the proposal is approved
15:28:37 <dadahl> kaz: next strategy meeting will be in two weeks
15:29:13 <dadahl> present: kaz, debbie, dirk, gerard
15:29:55 <dadahl> rrsagent, format minutes
15:29:57 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2025/04/23-voiceinteraction-minutes.html dadahl
15:30:15 <dadahl> rrsagent, make logs public
15:35:51 <dadahl> dadahl has left #voiceinteraction