12:02:06 RRSAgent has joined #wot 12:02:11 logging to https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-irc 12:02:12 meeting: WoT-WG/IG 12:02:17 chair: McCool 12:02:50 present+ Kaz_Ashimura, Michael_McCool, David_Ezell, Josh_Thomas, Kunihiko_Toumura, Michael_Koster, Jan_Romann 12:02:55 JKRhb has joined #wot 12:05:08 present+ Ege_Korkan 12:05:22 scribenick: JKRhb 12:05:36 topic: Agenda Review 12:05:53 agenda: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/Main_WoT_WebConf#23_October_2024 12:05:58 regrets+ Sebastian 12:05:59 mm: I don't believe we have any guests 12:06:02 luca_barbato has joined #wot 12:06:08 ... Larry called in earlier, but he left 12:06:15 ... had a call with Sharif, working on that 12:06:23 ... nothing major and no guests today 12:06:27 s/Agenda Review/Guests and IEs/ 12:06:27 topic: Minutes Review 12:06:36 mm: Reviewed them in the chairs call 12:06:46 i|Rev|-> https://www.w3.org/2024/10/16-wot-minutes.html Oct-16| 12:06:47 ... fixed a few typos, otherwise basically ready 12:06:51 ... any more comments? 12:06:53 rrsagent, make log public 12:06:58 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:06:59 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:07:10 present+ Luca_Barbato 12:07:11 ... Just to recap, we reviewed the TPAC minutes, talked about the ETSI liason 12:07:19 q+ 12:07:36 ... as you here, Ege, we need to keep in mind the potential conflict with ETSI 12:07:50 ek: CG call is one hour before the next ETSI meeting 12:08:10 ack k 12:08:10 kaz: Please remember that the W3C staff also wants to join the CG calls some time 12:08:25 s/W3C staff/WoT Chairs and W3C staff/ 12:08:26 mm: Hearing no objections to publishing the minutes, minutes are approved 12:08:31 s/wants/want/ 12:08:33 topic: Quick Items 12:08:43 subtopic: Eclipse Thingweb presentation 12:08:54 ek: Will present tomorrow at the Eclipse OCX 12:09:02 s/some time/some time but the CG call might be overlapped with the WoT Chairs call./ 12:09:03 mm: Are there slides you can share with us? 12:09:07 ek: Not done yet 12:09:22 mm: No problem, please just upload them once you are ready 12:09:26 present- Sebastian 12:09:29 ek: Will do 12:09:30 mahda has joined #wot 12:09:38 ... interesting aspect: it is also a fair 12:09:44 present+ Mahda_Noura 12:09:47 present+ Sebastian_Kaebisch, Mahda_Noura, Tomoaki_Mizushima 12:09:53 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:09:54 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:10:06 ... and there is one company that is dealing with Smart Cities and they said that they have a southbound WoT 1.0 connector 12:10:07 sebastian has joined #wot 12:10:11 q+ 12:10:15 ... but I could not find any information on their website 12:10:31 mm: Generally difficult to find information about who is using WoT 12:10:40 ek: Should be the task of the CG 12:10:51 ... but we cannot do it on behalve of the companies 12:10:54 Mizushima has joined #wot 12:11:06 mm: Would be nice if the companies could edit that information themselves 12:11:06 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:11:08 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:11:14 ... topic for future discussions 12:11:17 topic: WoT CG 12:11:28 mm: ETSI call is at 10 PM eastern 12:11:33 i/WoT CG/topic: Meetups/ 12:11:38 .... chairs call is at 9 AM 12:11:43 s/PM/AM/ 12:11:43 s/topic: WoT/subtopic: WoT/ 12:11:49 q+ 12:11:51 ... so there is a conflict 12:11:59 ... Kaz, what are the options for moving the call here? 12:12:08 kaz: If we could move the CG call, we could do so 12:12:22 ... need to look into the details of the calendar a bit more 12:12:40 sk: The conflict happens due to the timeshift this Sunday 12:12:47 q+ 12:13:03 mm: This time we forgot about the timeshift 12:13:20 ... generally, we schedule meetings based on the eastern timezone 12:13:35 dape has joined #wot 12:13:41 ... so there should not be a conflict 12:13:55 ... Ege, what timezone did you use to schedule the meetings? 12:14:01 ek: Central European Tiime 12:14:26 mm: That is the reason, even though it is annoying, would be great if you could keep that in mind for the future 12:14:34 q- 12:14:36 q+ 12:14:38 ack s 12:14:39 ... for now, we can move the chairs call to avoid the conflict 12:14:50 ... since people have already planned for the meeting 12:15:16 ... important thing is the ETSI call, let me make a note in the Wiki that it is going to take place at 10 AM 12:15:30 kaz: I though originally that CG calls would be held on Thursday 12:15:35 q? 12:15:42 ... but not they are sometimes held on Mondays or Tuesdays 12:16:03 ack k 12:16:05 ... in the future, one hour earlier than the ETSI call should be avoided 12:16:20 mm: Would be better to have a fixed slot in general 12:16:34 ... could reschedule the chairs call 12:16:58 ek: We had to find a different slot since the speakers were not available on Thursdays 12:17:13 kaz: My point is we should coordinate better in the future 12:17:38 mm: Should also make things consistent, like timezones 12:17:54 kaz: There will not be a rescheduling of the chairs call, right? 12:18:02 mm: We can resolve it via email 12:18:33 ... or now. My suggestion would be moving the chairs call one hour earlier 12:18:42 kaz: Based on eastern time 12:18:46 mm: Yes 12:18:55 The others agree to moving the call 12:19:36 mm: You should have received an invite to the CG event 12:20:04 ... will also adjust the calendar entry for the chairs call right now 12:20:40 ... or later, since it is hard to find. 12:21:14 mm: Next meeting of the CG will be on November 5, that is a regular call 12:21:26 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:21:28 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:21:45 ... that is going to be at 11 AM eastern 12:22:21 ... you also have the office hours in CEST, so maybe you want to change that, too 12:22:28 ek: Will do so after the timeshift 12:22:34 q? 12:22:38 topic: WoT JP CG 12:22:39 q+ 12:22:44 tm: No updates 12:22:51 topic: Smart City CG 12:23:09 s/CG/IG/ 12:23:17 kaz: Will switch to regular meetings at the end of this month, will try to get more participants then 12:23:51 s/at the end of this month/in November/ 12:23:52 q+ 12:23:57 q- 12:24:01 mm: There is also an edge computing CG which is partly related to smart cities, you will receive an invite later 12:24:02 s/then/by then/ 12:24:11 topic: Liasons 12:24:18 subtopic: OPC Foundation 12:24:22 s/will try to/sending reminders to potential participants to/ 12:24:27 sk: Yesterday there was the regular call 12:24:36 ... unfortunately, I could not make it 12:24:55 q+ 12:24:59 ... but there was a good discussion on a first draft ontology for the binding, as I heard 12:25:20 mm: Reminds me of the JSON-LD discussion we had at TPAC 12:25:24 ... regarding versioning 12:25:30 ack mjk 12:25:46 ... need to pin that done as it is highly relevant for bindings like OPCUA and ETSI 12:25:57 subtopic: ETSI ISG CIM 12:26:13 McCool has joined #wot 12:26:14 mm: There is going to be another meeting on the 10th 12:26:26 q+ 12:26:30 q? 12:26:35 ack e 12:26:50 ack k 12:26:59 kaz: I asked the ETSI people to update their contact details, based on the previous discussions 12:27:15 mm: Need to update deliverables and get organized 12:27:25 ... probably want to have some kind of binding to their APIs 12:27:37 ... will be interesting in the context of smart cities in particular 12:27:46 ... would be great if people could review their materials 12:27:52 s/I asked the ETSI people to update their contact details/will ask the W3C Liaison Team to updated the Liaison contact for ETSI with Franck and Patrick/ 12:28:05 ... would be good to index the material to prepare for the meetings 12:28:16 topic: Holidays and Cancellations 12:28:28 mm: Need to apologize for cancelling the Use Cases call last minute 12:28:36 ... will have a regular call next week 12:28:43 i|Holidays|-> https://github.com/w3c/wot/blob/main/proposals/liaisons/ngsi-ld.md NGSI-LD Liaison targets| 12:28:45 ... need to update our holiday schedule 12:28:58 ... we only have two months left in the year 12:29:11 ... also holidays, that will conflict directly with the chairs call 12:29:29 ... there is also a conflict with Thanksgiving, which is a staff holiday in the US 12:29:43 ... which needs to dealt with by the TD call 12:29:57 mjk: Might only be me, but we will sort it out 12:30:06 subtopic: Scripting API Call 12:30:10 mm: The slot is moving 12:30:19 q+ 12:30:22 ... to 11 AM CET 12:30:35 ... in Eastern Time that is 5 AM 12:30:48 kaz: We talked about that in last weeks call 12:31:02 ... need some clarification from Cristiano and Daniel 12:31:13 ... since it is quite early for non-Europeans 12:31:29 ... since Cristiano is not available, need to resolve that later or via email 12:31:54 mm: Generally, there is only a very narrow window that is suitable, need to keep that in mind, even though it leads to more conflicts 12:32:01 topic: F2F Planning 12:32:09 sk: Let's talk about that in the Plugfest call 12:32:20 mm: Should have mentioned that slot in the beginning 12:32:28 i|Let|-> https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/Wiki_for_WoT_Week_2024_planning WoT Week wiki| 12:32:33 ... will focus on the Plugfest as it is only a few weeks away now 12:32:45 ... need to reschedule the Profile call 12:33:02 ... do you consider a different timeslot for Profiles, Luca? 12:33:10 lb: Either we try to find another time 12:33:33 ... or assuming that the people currently involved update the GitHub issue we can avoid the meeting for the next couple of weeks 12:33:40 ... but that depends on the people to get involved 12:33:57 mm: I guess the option here would be to cancel the call until the Plugfest 12:34:06 ... and then you have a few weeks until Christmas 12:34:18 ... also need to keep in mind other conflicts 12:34:44 lb: I would not schedule more meetings, but we should have weekly updates 12:35:03 mm: Maybe in the TD call on Thursday? 5 to 10 minutes? 12:35:11 Everyone agrees with that proposal 12:35:28 mm: Will have the Plugfest call in the same Zoom call after this meeting 12:35:31 topic: Policies 12:35:46 mm: Michael, do you have anything to discuss here? 12:36:01 mjk: Not sure, let's put this on the agenda for next call and resolve it then 12:36:17 mm: I think we should resolve the versioning proposal soon 12:36:24 ... the others are more procedural 12:36:38 ... I guess we could also table these for the F2F 12:36:45 ... but we need actual PRs for these 12:36:52 topic: TF Leads 12:36:59 mm: Still don't have leads 12:37:20 ... agreed to defer discover, should probably focus on architecture first 12:37:47 ... regarding the use case call: We should probably focus on curating existing requirements 12:37:53 ... instead of creating new ones 12:38:06 ... I plan on joining the TD call on Thursdays 12:38:16 s/don't have leads/don't have leads for several TFs/ 12:38:30 ... from that, we should try to come up with a template for requirements 12:38:39 ... should do a quick test run with the template 12:39:14 ... and once we have figured out the test run, we should process a lot of issues at the same time, in a bulk fashion 12:39:25 ... hope to be done with the most part by Christmas 12:39:51 ... hope to finish up TD by the end of the year and focus on other aspects such as Discovery and Security in the new year 12:40:05 ... any comments on that? 12:40:10 No comments 12:40:25 mm: I'll try to create some short presentation material 12:40:39 ... is it okay if I can use 5-10 minutes for that on Thursday? 12:40:54 ek: Actually, we reserved time for use cases on Thursday 12:41:14 ... also need to discuss the process of what triggers the use case process 12:41:17 s/Thursday/Thursday during the TD call/ 12:41:26 mm: Great, then we are aligned here 12:41:51 topic: Other Liasons 12:42:00 s/Thursday?/Thursday during the TD call/ 12:42:09 mm: We had a meeting with spatial @@@ during TPAC 12:42:09 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:42:11 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:42:31 ... I know the S2W is paused at the moment 12:42:34 q+ 12:42:55 s/paused/being rescheduled/ 12:43:07 ... discovery is also deferred at the moment 12:43:16 kaz: Discussion is fine 12:43:37 ... should continue the dicussion with the S2W guys although the rechartering is still ongoing 12:43:47 mm: Question is whether we should schedule a meeting 12:44:01 ... discussion has been ongoing for years 12:44:26 kaz: Smart city IG could also invited them and bring the results back to the WoT working group 12:44:48 ... the question is also a bit which group should discuss what at which time 12:45:06 s/invited/invite/ 12:45:21 ... could continue the discussion in the chairs call later 12:45:22 s/S2W/SDW WG/g 12:45:32 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:45:34 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:45:40 mm: Moving the dicussion to the Smart City IG sounds good 12:45:50 ... do you want to define that as an Action Item, kaz? 12:46:01 kaz: Yeah, will continue to talk to them 12:46:08 q+ 12:46:09 subtopic: ECHONET 12:46:16 mm: Is there anything new? 12:46:31 kaz: Got a message from an ECHONET representative 12:46:46 ... they will join the WoT Week in November, remotely 12:46:57 mm: Would be good to include them in the F2F as well 12:47:07 ... but it will be difficult due to the timezone 12:47:20 kaz: Will stay in contact with them 12:47:24 subtopic: IETF 12:47:34 mm: We have not talked to them in a long time 12:47:43 subtopic: Microsoft DTDL 12:47:57 mm: This is now merged in the OPCUA activity, right? 12:47:59 dape has joined #wot 12:48:01 i|We had a meeting|-> https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/Main_WoT_WebConf/Liaisons WoT Liaisons in general| 12:48:14 s/spatial @@@/SDW WG (Spatial Data on the Web WG)/ 12:48:19 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:48:20 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:48:26 sk: Would be perfect to discuss this with Microsoft during WoT Week 12:48:32 s/reschedules/rechartered/ 12:48:38 mm: Would be great to start organizing the agenda 12:48:56 ... for now we only need a few bullet items for Microsoft and SDW 12:49:24 ... by the way, IEEE P2874 is also related to the Smart City topic 12:49:24 s/at the moment/at the moment, so maybe some discussion to be done by the WoT CG side/ 12:49:30 topic: TF Reports 12:49:35 mm: Any updates here? 12:49:36 s/Discussion is fine/Discussion by the WoT CG side is fine/ 12:49:40 q+ 12:49:44 q- 12:49:49 subtopic: TD and Binding Templates 12:50:09 s/should continue the discussion/but should continue the discussion/ 12:50:13 dp: Don't know whether you talked about the timeslot for Scripting 12:50:16 present+ Daniel_Peintner 12:50:21 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:50:22 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:50:39 mm: Talked about it, noticed that it is quite early for North America 12:50:47 i|We had a meeting with|subtopic: SDW| 12:50:48 ... also you planned it in CET 12:50:49 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:50:50 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:51:00 ... should take this into account for the future 12:51:00 q+ 12:51:16 ... your doodle also only included people already participating in the call 12:51:35 ... in general, you should try to fit the call in the narrow timeframe that works across most timezones 12:51:45 dp: Will discuss this in the next meeting 12:51:54 s/being rescheduled/being rechartered/ 12:51:56 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:51:57 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:52:03 ack dape 12:52:03 ... the old timeslot was not working anymore 12:52:09 ... but we will consider your concerns 12:52:30 ack m 12:52:46 s|should continue the dicussion|but we (WoT WG/IG) should also continue the discussion| 12:52:46 ek: Regarding the TD updates: The main thing currently is this initial connection topic 12:52:54 q? 12:52:57 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:52:58 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:53:06 ... grouping reusable aspects at the top-level 12:53:13 ... that is the main technical issue at the moment 12:53:21 ... the main non-technical one is about use cases 12:53:33 s/TD and Binding Templates/Scripting API/ 12:53:38 ... spent one slot last week, will continue this week 12:53:48 i/Regarding the TD/TD and Binding Templates/ 12:53:49 ... at the moment, we are doing too much administrative stuff 12:53:50 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:53:51 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:54:01 ack mjk 12:54:04 mm: Yeah, I'll try to resolve the issue until the end of this year 12:54:18 s/TD and Binding Templates/subtopic: TD and Binding Templates/ 12:54:19 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:54:20 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:54:26 ek: You can find a summary in the TD agenda 12:54:34 ... of the technical topics we are discussion 12:54:40 subtopic: Marketing 12:54:46 ek: Not that much 12:54:53 q? 12:54:59 ... did some Mastodon posts about WoT week 12:55:04 ... got some traction 12:55:16 ... and discussion, but other than that not that much at the moment 12:55:21 topic: AOB 12:55:35 No other business 12:55:39 dezell has joined #wot 12:55:47 mm: This is the end of the main call, the discussion will continue in the Plugfest call 12:55:57 me: rejoined 12:56:18 sk: We opened the Plugfest call for guests, so let's not keep them waiting too much 12:56:22 [adjourned] 12:56:24 s/me: rejoined// 12:56:32 rrsagent, draft minutes 12:56:34 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/10/23-wot-minutes.html kaz 12:56:58 mjk has left #wot 13:03:33 RobA-OGC has joined #wot 13:04:28 Hi - not normally in a friendly timezone - hope you dont mind me dropping by. 13:05:39 present 13:05:44 present+ 13:59:43 TallTed has joined #wot 14:17:48 mahda has joined #wot 14:44:31 dape has joined #wot 15:32:59 Zakim has left #wot 15:47:29 gkellogg has joined #wot 15:50:37 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 16:40:53 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 16:44:57 gkellogg has joined #wot 17:04:42 gkellogg has joined #wot 17:07:15 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 17:28:27 gkellogg has joined #wot 17:39:26 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 17:56:12 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 18:32:40 gkellogg has joined #wot 18:52:02 gkellogg has joined #wot 19:05:01 gkellogg has joined #wot 22:04:25 EgeKorkan has joined #wot 22:12:51 gkellogg has joined #wot 22:34:39 gkellogg has joined #wot 23:01:40 gkellogg has joined #wot 23:14:10 EgeKorkan has joined #wot