15:02:14 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #voiceinteraction
15:02:18 <RRSAgent> logging to https://www.w3.org/2024/01/10-voiceinteraction-irc
15:02:31 <ddahl> meeting: Voice Interaction
15:02:40 <ddahl> chair: debbie
15:02:56 <ddahl> scribe: ddahl
15:04:47 <ddahl> agenda: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-voiceinteraction/2024Jan/
15:33:08 <ddahl> present: dirk, debbie, gerard
15:33:26 <ddahl> topic: dirk's implementation
15:34:19 <ddahl> dirk: no client yet
15:34:31 <ddahl> ...ipa registry
15:34:53 <ddahl> ...ipa provider is chatGPT
15:35:29 <ddahl> ...using client input, sends text to dialog layer
15:35:53 <ddahl> ...the concepts are working
15:36:20 <ddahl> ...creates provider selection service
15:36:37 <ddahl> implementation is C++
15:37:28 <ddahl> dirk:only uses "multimodal input" parameter
15:37:43 <ddahl> ...this is a container of various multimodal inputs
15:38:50 <ddahl> ...returns client response
15:39:33 <ddahl> ...session id, request id, multimodal output
15:42:37 <ddahl> ...the ipa service must know about the provider selection service
15:44:12 <ddahl> ...provider selection service knows about the provider registry
15:44:32 <ddahl> ...provide registry is hard-coded, knows about providers
15:46:33 <ddahl> ...chatGPT is one provider
15:50:17 <ddahl> ...uses provider selection strategy, which hasn't been implemented yet, just uses the first one
15:53:27 <ddahl> ...eventually will need to use keyboard and display in client
15:56:40 <ddahl> ...need to add more logic about how to select IPA
15:59:31 <ddahl> debbie: seems like picking the IPA is the job of the provider selection service
15:59:39 <ddahl> ...not the registry
16:00:52 <ddahl> ...location of chatGPT is part of the adapter, not the registry
16:02:17 <ddahl> debbie: could use a similar pattern for Amazon Lex, for example
16:02:53 <ddahl> dirk: provider selection strategy should know about supported modalities
16:03:38 <ddahl> ...could try to match input with output
16:03:58 <ddahl> ... adapter should mention what it supports
16:04:12 <ddahl> ...in terms of modalities
16:04:25 <ddahl> ...we never discussed error situations
16:05:08 <ddahl> ...for example, ChatGPT gave an error for incorrect credentials
16:06:12 <ddahl> dirk: should return exceptions if the input is bad
16:06:43 <ddahl> ...rather than error codes
16:07:37 <ddahl> ... we need to decide this strategy soon
16:08:40 <ddahl> ...this is in the repository, where to put the documentation
16:09:41 <ddahl> debbie: should be in the "source code folder
16:12:56 <ddahl> dirk: what we've defined so far seems to be working
16:13:35 <ddahl> debbie: next priority is provider selection service and registry need to be fleshed out
16:14:02 <ddahl> ...maybe the client isn't that critical
16:14:15 <ddahl> dirk: would need that if we don't want to recompile every time
16:14:55 <ddahl> dirk: need to check license of source code
16:15:22 <ddahl> debbie: check to see if w3c has a preference
16:15:59 <ddahl> ...could use Apache 2.0 if the W3C doesn't have a preference
16:16:15 <ddahl> dirk: then elaborate on provider selection strategy
16:16:27 <ddahl> ...decide on return values vs. exceptions
16:16:56 <ddahl> debbie: providers should advertise what modalities they support
16:17:13 <ddahl> dirk: this would be part of the provider selection strategy
16:18:16 <ddahl> ...highest priority is to document in the README
16:18:31 <ddahl> ...invite others to support
16:19:09 <ddahl> dirk: still planning to look at dialog events
16:19:56 <ddahl> debbie: should also look at conversation envelope spec, which will be published in the next few days
16:20:36 <ddahl> dirk: didn't run into any major problems with implementation
16:21:41 <ddahl> dirk: should create issues for next steps
16:22:57 <ddahl> ...any questions from gerard? security?
16:23:37 <ddahl> gerard: implementation of small LLM's on smartphone
16:24:32 <ddahl> ...European project called "Evita", coaching older people
16:24:56 <ddahl> ...want to avoid cloud access
16:25:34 <ddahl> dirk: would it make sense to add this as a wrapper around your project?
16:25:38 <ddahl> gerard: not sure
16:26:19 <ddahl> rrsagent, format minutes
16:26:20 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2024/01/10-voiceinteraction-minutes.html ddahl
16:26:31 <ddahl> rrsagent, make logs public
18:14:12 <ddahl> ddahl has left #voiceinteraction