15:50:43 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #voiceinteraction
15:50:48 <RRSAgent> logging to https://www.w3.org/2023/01/11-voiceinteraction-irc
15:51:02 <ddahl> meeting: Voice Interaction
15:51:06 <ddahl> chair: debbie
15:51:12 <ddahl> scribe: ddahl
15:52:22 <ddahl> agenda: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-voiceinteraction/2023Jan/0001.html
16:02:59 <ddahl> topic: interfaces document
16:04:13 <ddahl> dirk: goal is to provide examples to clarify document
16:04:48 <ddahl> ...use cases -- information retrieval and accessing remote services
16:16:07 <ddahl> ...looking at messages about weather forecast
16:16:39 <ddahl> ...audio output, but could also include text
16:17:28 <ddahl> ...will also include text
16:18:11 <ddahl> ...also flight reservation use case
16:19:35 <ddahl> debbie: change log would include examples
16:20:18 <ddahl> dirk: didn't publish the first version of this
16:20:50 <ddahl> dirk: create reference implementation
16:21:03 <ddahl> ...going to existing IPA's
16:21:35 <ddahl> ...should be possible to map to proprietary formats
16:22:00 <ddahl> debbie: web page as endpoint?
16:22:26 <ddahl> jim: should these examples include endpoints?
16:23:59 <ddahl> debbie: endpoints are defined in the architecture document
16:25:20 <ddahl> jim: should include a screen
16:25:42 <ddahl> debbie: it's a MAY requirement
16:26:52 <ddahl> present:debbie,dirk,jim,jon,bev
16:28:07 <ddahl> look at GitHub issues
16:28:21 <ddahl> dirk: worked on GitHub
16:31:11 <ddahl> dirk: after closing, should be able to release document
16:31:51 <ddahl> ...addedd labels in GitHub issues
16:32:02 <ddahl> ...let's revisit issues
16:33:00 <ddahl> topic: requirements
16:34:46 <ddahl> debbie: next requirement is "3.	The Dialog Manager MUST consider ongoing workflows that must not be interrupted"
16:35:16 <ddahl> dirk: is this MUST or SHOULD
16:35:25 <ddahl> bev: medical device
16:35:38 <ddahl> jim: processing of emergency message
16:35:48 <ddahl> jon: automotive user management
16:36:22 <ddahl> debbie: who decides what must not be interrupted?
16:37:17 <ddahl> jim: priority list of interruptions
16:37:32 <ddahl> ...with a boundary
16:37:40 <ddahl> debbie: does user decide?
16:38:10 <ddahl> dirk: interruptibility of user and interruptibility of workflow
16:38:51 <ddahl> jim: depends on application, so is this out of scope?
16:41:20 <ddahl> debbie: users must always be able to interrupt the system
16:41:51 <ddahl> jon: calls to 911 have priority, there may be societal concerns
16:42:23 <ddahl> bev: how to insure that technologies in systems cannot be weaponized
16:43:37 <ddahl> jim: partial shutdown
16:53:02 <ddahl> bev: what to log and not log?
16:54:34 <ddahl> jim: you might not want to log some things
16:57:38 <ddahl> debbie: should we remove "5.	The Dialog Manager MUST determine the Dialog that is best suited to serve the current user input"
16:57:46 <ddahl> ...is that just saying the DM should do its job
16:59:47 <ddahl> stop at "5.	The Dialog Manager MUST receive the next dialog move as output from the selected Dialog or the IPA Service'
17:03:21 <ddahl> rrsagent, format minutes
17:03:23 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2023/01/11-voiceinteraction-minutes.html ddahl
17:04:58 <ddahl> rrsagent, make logs public
18:00:00 <ddahl> ddahl has left #voiceinteraction