11:45:15 RRSAgent has joined #wcag3-equity 11:45:15 logging to https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-irc 11:45:17 RRSAgent, make logs Public 11:45:18 please title this meeting ("meeting: ..."), jeanne 11:45:34 Meeting: WCAG3 Equity Subgroup 11:45:34 present: 11:45:34 chair: Janina, jeanne 11:45:34 present+ 11:45:34 zakim, clear agenda 11:45:34 rrsagent, make minutes 11:45:34 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html jeanne 11:45:34 q? 11:45:34 === Conformance === 11:45:34 agenda cleared 11:45:39 zakim, start meeting 11:45:39 RRSAgent, make logs Public 11:45:39 Meeting: Silver Conformance Subgroup 11:45:39 present: 11:45:39 chair: sajkaj 11:45:40 please title this meeting ("meeting: ..."), jeanne 11:45:40 present+ 11:45:40 zakim, clear agenda 11:45:40 rrsagent, make minutes 11:45:40 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html jeanne 11:45:40 agenda cleared 11:48:04 agenda+ Review feedback from AGWG meeting 11:48:22 agenda+ Review PR for the Requirements document 11:52:08 laura has joined #wcag3-equity 11:58:35 jenniferS has joined #wcag3-equity 11:58:39 present+ 12:01:20 janina has joined #wcag3-equity 12:01:26 agenda? 12:02:44 MichaelC has joined #wcag3-equity 12:02:55 zakim, take up item 1 12:02:55 agendum 1 -- Review feedback from AGWG meeting -- taken up [from jeanne] 12:02:58 present+ 12:03:08 present+ 12:03:15 scribe: Laura 12:04:18 jannina: glad we went first at ag meeting. 12:04:37 ... jeanne did a great job. Very happy. 12:04:52 q? 12:05:52 ... wilco was off topic on measurablity. 12:06:55 jen: he is on tesitng sub group an that may have had an impact. 12:07:09 ... people are imperfect. 12:07:58 ... may be suck in testing. 12:08:35 mc: not feedback from that meeting. 12:09:07 q+ 12:09:16 q+ 12:09:25 jeanna: How will this play at TPAC? Ideas on hoe to move forward. 12:09:26 ack jen 12:09:43 jen: be stratigec in how er convey it. 12:10:13 ... thnings may become possible even if they are not possible today. 12:10:31 q+ 12:11:07 ... we should always be aiming for equity in your outcomes. 12:11:16 ... some of this is hard. 12:11:23 q+ to say to inlcude "avoid prioritization by functional need" - recommend prioritize by context 12:11:34 ... technology takes time. 12:11:37 ack mi 12:12:07 mc: pull request is a big part of how this will land in AG. 12:12:28 ... maybe show the PR and the explain. 12:12:39 ... we need to be actionable. 12:13:07 ... both in guidlines and process. 12:13:11 ack me 12:13:26 ack ja 12:14:33 janina: some things may be unlikely. May need to take them to the lab. 12:14:55 ... Need to be practical and actionable. 12:15:08 q+ to say making unknowns known is an action - but not the first one 12:15:11 q+ 12:15:12 ack ja 12:15:17 ... document things. 12:15:21 ack je 12:15:25 ack je 12:15:25 jeanne, you wanted to say to inlcude "avoid prioritization by functional need" - recommend prioritize by context 12:15:53 jeanne: would like to avoid priority by funtional need. 12:16:12 Can you provide an example of what that would look like, Jeanne? 12:16:17 ack me 12:16:17 MichaelC, you wanted to say making unknowns known is an action - but not the first one 12:16:20 ack mi 12:16:35 q? 12:16:42 where did I go? 12:16:45 1+ 12:16:49 MC: level of detailthat is too much for this PR 12:16:54 q+ 12:17:02 ... focus on actionable stepss 12:17:52 ... if equity needs to be a cyiclical process if we are to be taken seriously. 12:18:04 ack je 12:18:14 ... start with what we got. 12:18:39 jen: example of don't do this. 12:18:52 jeanne: A, AA, AAA 12:19:15 q? 12:20:01 mc: A, AA, AAA not intentionally inequiable but it worked out that way. 12:20:03 zakim, take up next 12:20:03 agendum 2 -- Review PR for the Requirements document -- taken up [from jeanne] 12:20:15 https://raw.githack.com/w3c/silver/equity-proposal/requirements/index.html#equity 12:20:20 zakim, next item 12:20:20 agendum 2 was just opened, laura 12:21:02 mc: starts with editors notes 12:21:27 ... (Reads PR) 12:22:14 "relevant user groups" — may need some explanation, could attract ire 12:22:36 q? 12:25:28 q? 12:25:36 q+ 12:25:42 ack je 12:26:00 jen: "relevant user groups" — may need some explanation, could attract ire 12:26:32 MC: suggestion for a different word? 12:26:39 q+ to say that I like it, Issue Severity proposal is heading toward priority by Functional Need. That's why I think we need it for TPAC. 12:27:18 jen: accessibility specific? 12:27:27 MC: yes. 12:27:55 (group wordsmithing) 12:28:26 jen: that's good. 12:28:41 That's good enough! The word "relevant" was the one I worried about. 12:28:46 ack jea 12:28:46 jeanne, you wanted to say that I like it, Issue Severity proposal is heading toward priority by Functional Need. That's why I think we need it for TPAC. 12:29:10 jeanne: like what you have done. 12:29:32 q+ 12:29:37 ack mi 12:29:54 ... concerned that issue severity is heading in in conflict with equity. 12:30:24 mc: may want to come up with some measurements in the next 6 months. 12:30:34 +1 for a six month project, not 1 week 12:31:07 ... where structual equities may exist, etcc. 12:31:14 q? 12:31:19 ... will be n acive work item job. 12:31:42 No objection here with the one edit. Thank you for the work on this! 12:32:08 MC: what is the next step? 12:32:32 janina: not sure. 12:34:00 +1 from Jeanne (only on phone) 12:34:02 Laura: +1 12:34:02 +1 12:34:05 +1 12:34:26 RESOLUTION: accept PR 654 https://github.com/w3c/silver/pull/654 as a proposal to the WG 12:35:05 mc: will sent to the chairs. 12:36:02 ... equity is on the agenda at 1PM at TPAC. 12:36:20 Thank you Michael! 12:37:56 rrsagent, make minutes 12:37:56 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html laura 12:38:32 present+ Laura_Carlson 12:40:23 Cyborg has joined #wcag3-equity 12:40:28 s/measurablity/measurability/ 12:41:03 s/tesitng /testing / 12:41:27 s/an that /and that / 12:41:28 can't find zoom call today... 12:42:10 the meeting just ended 12:42:33 oh...any way to catch up on what i missed? 12:43:16 I will be sending out the minutes. 12:43:50 s/guidlines /guidelines / 12:44:25 s/stratigec in how er /strategic in how we / 12:44:40 it seems to still be going? 12:45:02 I am fixing typos in irc 12:45:21 s/thnings /thnings/ 12:45:57 s/funtional /functional / 12:46:27 s/level of detailthat /that level of detail 12:46:57 s/stepss/steps/ 12:47:17 s/cyiclical /cyclical / 12:47:57 s/example/ It there an example/ 12:48:28 s/inequiable /inequitable / 12:49:19 s/structual /structural / 12:49:46 s/, etcc./, etc./ 12:50:18 s/will be n acive /will be an active / 12:51:21 rrsagent, make minutes 12:51:21 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html laura 12:55:53 s/thningsmay become /thnings may become / 12:56:26 s/thnings/things/ 12:56:50 s/guidlines /guidelines / 12:57:32 s/level of detailthat /that level of detail / 12:59:26 s/at 1PM /Monday at 1PM / 13:00:32 rrsagent, make minutes 13:00:32 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html laura 13:01:58 s/not feedback/no specific feedback/ 13:03:03 s/hoe to/how to/ 13:03:25 rrsagent, make minutes 13:03:25 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html laura 13:05:16 zakim, end meeting 13:05:16 As of this point the attendees have been jeanne, jenniferS, MichaelC, janina, Laura_Carlson 13:05:18 RRSAgent, please draft minutes 13:05:18 I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/08/29-wcag3-equity-minutes.html Zakim 13:05:21 I am happy to have been of service, laura; please remember to excuse RRSAgent. Goodbye 13:05:25 Zakim has left #wcag3-equity 13:54:49 janina has left #wcag3-equity