15:59:50 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #voiceinteraction
15:59:50 <RRSAgent> logging to https://www.w3.org/2022/02/09-voiceinteraction-irc
16:00:04 <ddahl> meeting: Voice Interaction Community Group
16:00:20 <ddahl> chair: Debbie
16:00:46 <ddahl> scribe:ddahl
16:05:35 <ddahl> topic: changes to interface document
16:06:50 <ddahl> https://w3c.github.io/voiceinteraction/voice%20interaction%20drafts/paInterfaces/paInterfaces.htm
16:07:24 <ddahl> dirk: changed diagram to focus on major interfaces
16:12:11 <ddahl> jim: not sure what half circle notation means
16:12:31 <ddahl> dirk: will add legend explaining notation
16:13:12 <ddahl> ...also added sequence diagram
16:15:16 <ddahl> dirk: only shows calls to external processing
16:16:32 <ddahl> jim: walks through sequence diagram
16:21:10 <ddahl> dirk: will add "External processes" to "APIs/Data"
16:21:45 <ddahl> ...will add three labels to "APIs/Data"
16:22:03 <ddahl> .. will update both documents
16:27:30 <ddahl> present: debbie, jim, dirk, anastasios,votis, ulrike,jon
16:36:29 <ddahl> debbie: reviews overall work of group
16:36:37 <ddahl> dirk: reviews architecture
16:41:33 <ddahl> debbie: would be good to get comments on the public mailing list
16:41:49 <ddahl> dirk: if there are questions we need to improve how we describe things
16:43:05 <ddahl> public mailing list is public-voiceinteraction@w3.org
16:43:32 <ddahl> jim: what if there is no IPA, what does it mean to send the interpretation back?
16:44:02 <ddahl> dirk: sendInterpretation needs to be corrected
16:44:21 <ddahl> jim: what is response to "callServices"?
16:44:44 <ddahl> dirk: there should be a response, for example to indicate errors
16:45:02 <ddahl> jim: every message should have a response
16:45:17 <ddahl> ulrike: what is the small square?
16:45:31 <ddahl> dirk: just shows that there is some activity going on there
16:45:48 <ddahl> rrsagent, make logs public
16:45:58 <ddahl> rrsagent, format minutes
16:45:58 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/02/09-voiceinteraction-minutes.html ddahl
16:47:05 <ddahl> dirk: this is just one turn, there might be multiple turns
16:47:51 <ddahl> jim: if neither IPA or service calls are present, what is the content of the response? must one of these be present?
16:48:18 <ddahl> dirk: no
16:49:10 <ddahl> debbie: the external services are not necessarily called
16:50:45 <ddahl> dirk: should add a local call
16:52:08 <ddahl> debbie: maybe add text that some client input can be completely handled on the local side
16:52:41 <ddahl> jim: we need a box under the "opt service call" that there might be some dialog processing
16:53:34 <ddahl> ulrike: can all three items occur?
16:54:18 <ddahl> ...external IPA, external service call, and local following one clientInput
16:55:31 <ddahl> jim: squares are optional but they're independently optional
16:56:21 <ddahl> dirk: optional things are independent of each other in the general case?
16:56:31 <ddahl> ...should we explain that?
16:56:42 <ddahl> ulrike: I think it's clear
16:58:13 <ddahl> dirk: added service call interface, semantic interface
17:00:17 <ddahl> debbie: semantics should be aligned with JSON
17:00:55 <ddahl> ...should be able to add multi-intents and nbest intents
17:02:06 <ddahl> ...also nested entities
17:02:43 <ddahl> jim: tables are more useful than text
17:03:36 <ddahl> rrsagent, format minutes
17:03:36 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2022/02/09-voiceinteraction-minutes.html ddahl