IRC log of aria on 2021-04-29
Timestamps are in UTC.
- 16:59:15 [RRSAgent]
- RRSAgent has joined #aria
- 16:59:15 [RRSAgent]
- logging to https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-irc
- 16:59:18 [Zakim]
- RRSAgent, make logs Public
- 16:59:19 [Zakim]
- please title this meeting ("meeting: ..."), jamesn
- 16:59:26 [jamesn]
- meeting: ARIA WG
- 16:59:31 [jamesn]
- chair: JamesNurthen
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- agenda+ [New Issue Triage](https://bit.ly/2QDnJKM)
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- agenda+ [New PR Triage](https://bit.ly/32WPhxg)
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- agenda+ Upcoming Deep Dives
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- - this week (Apr 29) Accessible name prohibited issues
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- - next week (May 6) - aria-roledescription (stes-acc)
- 17:00:01 [jamesn]
- - 2 weeks (May 13) - Data Visualization part 2
- 17:00:02 [jamesn]
- agenda+ [Roles with required accessible names](https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues/1466)
- 17:00:02 [jamesn]
- agenda+ [Suggested simplification](https://github.com/w3c/accname/issues/96)
- 17:00:02 [jamesn]
- agenda+ [1.3 triage](https://bit.ly/3udUkWh) - 21 issues to go!
- 17:00:07 [carmacleod_]
- present+
- 17:00:28 [joanie]
- present+ Joanmarie_Diggs
- 17:00:34 [jamesn]
- present+
- 17:01:43 [harris]
- harris has joined #aria
- 17:03:00 [sarah_higley]
- sarah_higley has joined #aria
- 17:03:36 [msumner]
- present+
- 17:03:45 [sarah_higley]
- present+
- 17:03:53 [MarkMcCarthy]
- MarkMcCarthy has joined #aria
- 17:03:55 [Jory]
- Jory has joined #aria
- 17:03:56 [MarkMcCarthy]
- present+
- 17:05:18 [harris]
- present+
- 17:05:22 [msumner]
- scribe: msumner
- 17:05:38 [msumner]
- Zakim, next item
- 17:05:38 [Zakim]
- agendum 1 -- [New Issue Triage](https://bit.ly/2QDnJKM) -- taken up [from jamesn]
- 17:06:54 [sarah_higley]
- issue: https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues/1476
- 17:07:31 [msumner]
- jamesn: three new issues, two of which we discussed in the last hour, we need to get this resolved quickly
- 17:08:47 [msumner]
- jamesn: resolution is that the issue (1476) is assigned to scott and myself
- 17:09:18 [msumner]
- jamesn: issue 1474 also assigned to jamesn
- 17:09:23 [msumner]
- zakim, next item
- 17:09:23 [Zakim]
- agendum 2 -- [New PR Triage](https://bit.ly/32WPhxg) -- taken up [from jamesn]
- 17:09:47 [siri]
- siri has joined #aria
- 17:10:41 [msumner]
- jamesn: 1475 we need two more reviewers, who would like to review.
- 17:10:59 [msumner]
- jcraig: you can assign me as a reviewer
- 17:11:31 [msumner]
- jamesn: oh cool we already have three reviewers, also it's good to have one reviewer that wasn't in the deep dive convo
- 17:12:04 [msumner]
- jamesn: the other one is editorial so I'll resolve, we don't need to discuss
- 17:12:11 [msumner]
- zakim, next item
- 17:12:11 [Zakim]
- agendum 3 -- Upcoming Deep Dives -- taken up [from jamesn]
- 17:12:41 [msumner]
- jamesn: next week we'll discuss aria role description next week, data viz part 2 the week after
- 17:13:10 [msumner]
- jamesn: may 20th we'll discuss accessible name prohibited, focusing on what to do with focusable divs and what their role mapping should be
- 17:13:41 [msumner]
- siri: all these sound super interesting but they all conflict, can we record?
- 17:14:34 [msumner]
- jamesn: we do release minutes from these; recordings aren't typically available publicly unless everyone present agrees to it
- 17:14:56 [msumner]
- cyns: are there calendar entries yet?
- 17:15:04 [msumner]
- jamesn: no not yet we just decided on these
- 17:15:22 [msumner]
- (discussion about subscribing capabilities for calendar use)
- 17:16:15 [cyns]
- cyns has joined #aria
- 17:17:12 [cyns]
- Calendar subscription: https://www.w3.org/groups/wg/aria/calendar/export
- 17:17:20 [msumner]
- jcraig: deep dives are harder for me lately, so please ping me if you need me there so I can block my calendar
- 17:17:59 [msumner]
- zakim, next item
- 17:17:59 [Zakim]
- agendum 4 -- [Roles with required accessible names](https://github.com/w3c/aria/issues/1466) -- taken up [from jamesn]
- 17:18:41 [msumner]
- scott: "this" is a good way to describe this issue
- 17:20:22 [msumner]
- scott: accessible name required row- sometimes it's true, false or not there at all. it should be consistent.
- 17:20:40 [msumner]
- jamesn: what do people think?
- 17:21:22 [msumner]
- msumner: I think it should be Accessible Name: Required, Not Required, or Prohibited.
- 17:21:31 [msumner]
- bryang: that sounds correct
- 17:21:40 [msumner]
- jamesn: okay cool but also this is more scripting work
- 17:22:28 [jcraig]
- Approved PR #1475 https://github.com/w3c/aria/pull/1475 makes total sense
- 17:22:32 [msumner]
- scott: so do I need to change it from "Accessible Name Required" ?
- 17:22:57 [msumner]
- jamesn: I am not sure we should do this because there are things that reference this and all those references would have to be updated
- 17:23:59 [msumner]
- carmacleod_: it does get a bit more complicated
- 17:24:24 [msumner]
- scott: so let's then just do Accessible Name Required: true, and not put rows in for false or prohibited
- 17:24:43 [msumner]
- (no objections, general agreement)
- 17:26:29 [msumner]
- scott: next up we have "landmark SHOULD" - I think we want to call out some author guidance around landmark roles when there are multiple of the same landmark
- 17:28:01 [msumner]
- jamesn: do we have an issue that says we should have links to practices?
- 17:28:16 [msumner]
- carolyn: no but it's a good idea! there are a lot of links that could be added
- 17:29:34 [msumner]
- scott will separate out the "landmark Should" section to a separate issue so it can be worked on separately
- 17:30:34 [msumner]
- scott: right now if role="group" is named, it wouldn't be exposed, so it's missing name required.
- 17:30:50 [msumner]
- *is not named
- 17:30:58 [jamesn]
- q+
- 17:31:27 [msumner]
- jamesn: can't you have an unnamed fieldset? so why wouldn't we allow an unnamed group?
- 17:31:51 [msumner]
- scott: yes but that makes fieldset kinda useless right?
- 17:32:11 [msumner]
- bryan: group is used for other things where you wouldn't want group to be named, like if it contained a tree
- 17:32:29 [msumner]
- jamesn: sounds like we need an authoring note that sometimes it needs a name, and give usage examples
- 17:34:13 [msumner]
- discussed APG guidance
- 17:34:17 [msumner]
- scott: ok so for this one it's a no
- 17:34:33 [msumner]
- scott: next up is tab and I don't think that makes sense w/o a name
- 17:34:37 [msumner]
- carolyn: good point
- 17:35:03 [msumner]
- jamesn: it says "name required only if content is insufficient"
- 17:35:21 [msumner]
- jamesn: anyone disagree that tab should have accessible name required? (no objections)
- 17:36:12 [msumner]
- scott: next up is separator: it says "if focusable" and I think we should give it more guidance
- 17:36:42 [msumner]
- jamesn: I think we do stuff differently for things "if focusable" so I think it makes sense for accessible name to be required
- 17:37:13 [msumner]
- siri: I always saw separator being used in APG in examples, but where is it focusable?
- 17:37:33 [msumner]
- scott: a focusable separator might be one like between two window panes where you could adjust the width of the panes
- 17:38:18 [msumner]
- bryan: do they even do this on the web? I haven't seen it.
- 17:38:36 [msumner]
- sarah: is there some documentation anywhere about this?
- 17:38:57 [msumner]
- jamesn: there were plans for a proposal for authoring practices about this, it just hasn't been a high priority
- 17:39:39 [msumner]
- jamesn: typically it's the non-canvas, window-splitters where we tend to use this sort of pattern
- 17:40:40 [msumner]
- jcraig: we do role description of splitter and you can interact with it like a slider
- 17:41:45 [msumner]
- bryan: I've never seen one that was usable and intuitive on the web
- 17:42:14 [msumner]
- jcraig: yes it's been hard to figure out but we have increment and decrement now so it's possible
- 17:42:20 [msumner]
- scott: ok so it shouldn't have a name
- 17:42:38 [msumner]
- (jokes re: tooltip)
- 17:43:05 [jcraig]
- s/hard to figure out/difficult to implement/
- 17:45:03 [jcraig]
- s/we do role description of splitter and you can interact with it like a slider/Mac uses a role description of "splitter" and a [vertical | horizontal] property. A VoiceOver user can interact with it, then control it like a slider: increment or decrement./
- 17:45:08 [msumner]
- jamesn: tooltip supports name from content
- 17:45:11 [jcraig]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 17:45:11 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html jcraig
- 17:45:49 [msumner]
- sarah: clarifies that there's no issue if a tooltip doesn't have content (and it just exists as empty)
- 17:47:24 [msumner]
- bryan: (if you put aria-label on a heading, it obscures the content of the heading- there are situations similar with tooltip where it can obscure content)
- 17:47:29 [jcraig]
- s/a role description of "splitter"/no label by default, but a role description of "splitter"/
- 17:48:00 [carmacleod_]
- +1 for removing name required from tooltip
- 17:48:07 [jcraig]
- s/shouldn't have a name/shouldn't have name required/
- 17:49:01 [msumner]
- jamesn: decision: not require a name for roles of tooltip, label and legend.
- 17:49:07 [msumner]
- no objection
- 17:50:38 [msumner]
- scott: some other questions- "tree and treegrid require a name, but other similar roles (of varying similarities mind you) menu, menubar, toolbar, tablist, and navigation do not. should tree/treegrid continue to require a name, or should some of these other roles require a name too?"
- 17:51:04 [msumner]
- scott: also "do alertdialog, dialog, table, grid, tabpanel need a quantifier to their required name status?"
- 17:51:52 [msumner]
- jamesn: what do we think we should do about this?
- 17:52:16 [msumner]
- carolyn: again, we should be pointing to APG. it would be nice to point to that naming guidance table
- 17:57:02 [msumner]
- jamesn & scott: discussion about how the article element gets its name
- 17:57:21 [jamesn]
- agenda?
- 17:57:22 [msumner]
- jamesn: I think we need a longer conversation on the "labeling things"
- 17:57:47 [msumner]
- scott: I got what I need from this, I'll get it done
- 17:57:50 [msumner]
- zakim, next item
- 17:57:50 [Zakim]
- I see a speaker queue remaining and respectfully decline to close this agendum, msumner
- 17:57:59 [MarkMcCarthy]
- q?
- 17:58:02 [MarkMcCarthy]
- ack jamesn
- 17:58:12 [msumner]
- zakim, next item
- 17:58:12 [Zakim]
- agendum 5 -- [Suggested simplification](https://github.com/w3c/accname/issues/96) -- taken up [from jamesn]
- 17:59:45 [MarkMcCarthy]
- msumner: i wanted to rearrange and update things, and hopefully move forward with rewording things in another PR, all taking into account James Teh's comments
- 18:00:14 [MarkMcCarthy]
- msumner: no wording changed, only rearranged things so far
- 18:00:31 [msumner]
- bryan: I'm having a hard time reading the code changes can you email me
- 18:00:35 [msumner]
- msumner: sure will do
- 18:00:44 [msumner]
- jamesn: there is a reference there that needs to be changed
- 18:01:06 [msumner]
- jamesn: I'll give it a review as well, I agree that we should keep it to a small change and other things should be subsequent issues
- 18:01:18 [msumner]
- jamesn: ok we're at the hour!
- 18:01:40 [msumner]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 18:01:40 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html msumner
- 18:02:59 [msumner]
- regrets+ peter
- 18:03:16 [msumner]
- regrets+ juanita kurt
- 18:03:36 [msumner]
- regrets- juanita
- 18:03:43 [msumner]
- regrets+ jaunita
- 18:03:54 [msumner]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 18:03:54 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html msumner
- 18:56:36 [jamesn]
- regrets- juanita kurt
- 18:56:50 [jamesn]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 18:56:50 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html jamesn
- 18:57:20 [jamesn]
- regrets+ curt
- 18:57:24 [jamesn]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 18:57:24 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html jamesn
- 18:58:04 [msumner]
- present+ bryang
- 18:58:18 [msumner]
- present+ jcraig
- 18:58:38 [msumner]
- present+ siri
- 18:58:52 [msumner]
- present+ cyns
- 18:59:00 [msumner]
- present+ Scott_O
- 18:59:12 [msumner]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 18:59:12 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/04/29-aria-minutes.html msumner
- 19:08:58 [cyns]
- I'm reviewing the ARIA in HTML doc. Anyone up for a sanity check when I'm done? It should be later today or tomorrow. I haven't been active in the group for some time, so I want to make sure my comments reflect consensus.