Rights Automation Community Group Teleconference

20 January 2021

Attendees

Present
adam, alex, ali, atiq, belen, ben, caspar, david_sawkins, fred.schulz, Ilya, jo, josh, laura, mark_b, marko, micahel_agaon, nigel, olga, phil, roy_kaplan
Regrets
chris_c, renato
Chair
Jo
Scribe
nigelp

Meeting minutes

https://github.com/w3c/market-data-odrl-profile/blob/gh-pages/agendas/md-odrl-profile-agenda-2021-01-20.md

Admin

<jo__> Minutes of last meeting:https://www.w3.org/2021/01/06-md-odrl-profile-minutes.html

Resolution: Accept minutes of last meeting

Discussion of Status

Ben: Publishing Standard - ambition end Jan (unrealistic); revised end Q1
… test cases and purposes outstanding.
… work has been fine grained and detailed. Before end Q1 need to show how low level stuff maps back to real world contracts.

Caspar: Second POC delivered by end Feb(hopefully), showing passing of ODRL between components

Action: Ben to make a note of outstanding tasks and we review and keep track at each meeting

JP Morgan Demo

Ilya: outlining scope; using ODRL in policy enforcement for permissions drawn from DACS (for now)

<jo__> (Michael Agaon Presents)

Michael: discusses mapping from DACS permissions into ODRL

Michael: discusses Open Policy Agent and capabilities
… logical diagram of PoC
… demo of system running

<ben> This looks great - but sadly, I've got to drop.

Atiq: where is ODRL adding value over DACS; do you get supplementary informaton from it?

Ilya: not at present but we plan to extend (working with Refinitiv). In the short term we will enrich data using a separate policy store but hope for something more integrated in time.

Roy: Refinitiv are looking at ODRL and what it might mean for the entitlements product strategy

Action: Ilya to see if he can get us a version of the presentation

Discussion of test cases

Mark: asks group to review test cases on github. Which are achievable and most relevant to group participants?

Action: everyone to contribute their top 5 test cases for us to translate into ODRL - via email on public list

Action: Mark to kick this off and seed the disucssion

Second Round of Feedback on Document

Mark: second round review of the ODRL specification draft needs to focus on "Activities"

Action: Everyone to please review document again and provide feedback on public email list

AOB

<jo__> Many thanks to JPMorgan for a most interesting discussion

<jo__> Many thanks also to Nigel for his debut scribing appearance

<jo__> -- meeting closed --

<jo__> s/ACTION: Ben(?) to maintain tracker of outstanding deliverables//

<jo__> s|s/ACTION: Ben(?) to maintain tracker of outstanding deliverables//||

Summary of action items

  1. Ben to make a note of outstanding tasks and we review and keep track at each meeting
  2. Ilya to see if he can get us a version of the presentation
  3. everyone to contribute their top 5 test cases for us to translate into ODRL - via email on public list
  4. Mark to kick this off and seed the disucssion
  5. Everyone to please review document again and provide feedback on public email list

Summary of resolutions

  1. Accept minutes of last meeting
Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 127 (Wed Dec 30 17:39:58 2020 UTC).

Diagnostics

Succeeded: s/Stanard/Standard/

Succeeded: s/Passcode ?//

Succeeded: s/RACG//

Succeeded: s/When I click on the calendar invite - it downloads one with the WebEx details ?//

Succeeded: s/Meeting ID 924 4275 4518//

Failed: s/ACTION: Ben(?) to maintain tracker of outstanding deliverables//

Succeeded: s/Hello - can't find the Zoom details ?//

Succeeded: s/https://github.com/w3c/market-data-odrl-profile/blob/gh-pages/agendas/md-odrl-profile-agenda-2021-01-20.md/Agenda: https://github.com/w3c/market-data-odrl-profile/blob/gh-pages/agendas/md-odrl-profile-agenda-2021-01-20.md

Succeeded: s/Action: Ben(?) to maintain tracker of outstanding deliverables//

Failed: s|s/ACTION: Ben(?) to maintain tracker of outstanding deliverables//||

Succeeded: s/rrsagent make minutes//

Maybe present: Mark, Michael, Roy