IRC log of tt on 2017-06-22
Timestamps are in UTC.
- 14:00:47 [RRSAgent]
- RRSAgent has joined #tt
- 14:00:47 [RRSAgent]
- logging to http://www.w3.org/2017/06/22-tt-irc
- 14:00:49 [trackbot]
- RRSAgent, make logs public
- 14:00:49 [Zakim]
- Zakim has joined #tt
- 14:00:51 [trackbot]
- Zakim, this will be TTML
- 14:00:51 [Zakim]
- ok, trackbot
- 14:00:52 [trackbot]
- Meeting: Timed Text Working Group Teleconference
- 14:00:52 [trackbot]
- Date: 22 June 2017
- 14:01:22 [nigel]
- Present: Nigel
- 14:01:23 [nigel]
- Chair: Nigel
- 14:01:26 [tmichel]
- tmichel has joined #tt
- 14:01:26 [nigel]
- Regrets: Glenn
- 14:01:32 [nigel]
- scribe: nigel
- 14:02:07 [nigel]
- Present+ Thierry
- 14:03:09 [nigel]
- Present+ Pierre
- 14:03:37 [nigel]
- Present+ Mike
- 14:03:41 [mike]
- mike has joined #tt
- 14:04:40 [nigel]
- Present+ Andreas
- 14:04:50 [nigel]
- Topic: This meeting
- 14:05:13 [nigel]
- Nigel: In today's momentous meeting we will be looking at IMSC 1.0.1 CR publication
- 14:05:22 [nigel]
- .. and TTML2 WR publication.
- 14:05:32 [dae]
- dae has joined #tt
- 14:06:04 [nigel]
- .. Before we get on to agenda topics, looking ahead to July's meetings, is everyone ok if
- 14:06:10 [nigel]
- .. I keep them at 2 hours and hopefully we use less?
- 14:06:19 [nigel]
- Andreas: In general I can only attend for 1 hour.
- 14:06:22 [atai]
- atai has joined #tt
- 14:06:32 [nigel]
- Nigel: I'll take the general silence as a Yes.
- 14:06:51 [nigel]
- Present+ Dae
- 14:07:39 [nigel]
- Nigel: Back to the agenda for today, there's a bit on TPAC. Any other points to make sure
- 14:07:41 [nigel]
- .. we cover?
- 14:07:57 [nigel]
- Dae: I have a couple of TTML2 issues we're waiting for r12a for. I don't know how long
- 14:08:03 [nigel]
- .. we give him before we just move forward.
- 14:08:15 [nigel]
- Nigel: Okay let's come to those in the TTML agenda item.
- 14:10:17 [nigel]
- Thierry: Regarding WebVTT we need some coordination and I'd really like David and Simon
- 14:10:20 [nigel]
- .. to attend a meeting.
- 14:10:43 [nigel]
- group: no other business
- 14:10:49 [nigel]
- Topic: TPAC 2017
- 14:11:03 [nigel]
- Nigel: Just wanted to alert everyone that if they need to book hotel rooms the Hyatt is
- 14:11:26 [nigel]
- .. already out of rooms for some nights so book quickly to take advantage of the lower rates.
- 14:12:15 [nigel]
- Nigel: I haven't managed to pull together the stuff for action-497 so it's still on my list of
- 14:12:17 [nigel]
- .. things to do.
- 14:12:37 [nigel]
- Topic: IMSC
- 14:13:22 [nigel]
- Nigel: What's the status on our issues?
- 14:13:48 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/246 SDP-US is listed as a normative reference, but it is not #246
- 14:14:05 [nigel]
- Pierre: This has a PR that has been open for a week and has been iterated, and approved
- 14:15:49 [nigel]
- .. by Andreas and Nigel. I think it should be good for Mike too.
- 14:15:57 [nigel]
- Mike: I'll approve that right now.
- 14:16:30 [nigel]
- Pierre: I guess we could merge that today?
- 14:16:43 [nigel]
- Nigel: Assuming Mike approves it, there are no objections so I think we can go ahead and
- 14:16:50 [nigel]
- .. merge that.
- 14:17:09 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/244 Add diff from IMSC 1.0.0 and update substantive-changes-summary.txt #244
- 14:17:15 [nigel]
- Pierre: This one is for me to do at the last minute.
- 14:17:33 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/241 Requirement to support certain Code Point #241
- 14:17:50 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/237 Why exclude hebrew and arabic proportional reference fonts? #237
- 14:17:57 [nigel]
- Pierre: Those are both addressed by #245
- 14:18:10 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/245 Clarified the requirement for processors to implement reference fonts #245
- 14:18:26 [nigel]
- Nigel: That has approvals and comments.
- 14:18:39 [nigel]
- Pierre: The approval that is missing is from r12a but since the change I made is exactly
- 14:18:50 [nigel]
- .. the same wording as his suggestion I assume that resolves the issue for him.
- 14:19:25 [nigel]
- .. That's been open for 13 days now.
- 14:19:39 [nigel]
- .. Again nobody else has voiced any concern or questions or comments.
- 14:20:31 [nigel]
- .. I think we should assume it satisfies Richard's comments and it is not normative.
- 14:20:41 [nigel]
- .. The risk of merging this is very low, and any other comments can be dealt with editorially.
- 14:20:52 [nigel]
- Nigel: Everyone happy to merge this?
- 14:20:55 [nigel]
- Andreas: Yes
- 14:21:00 [nigel]
- Pierre: I'll merge that too.
- 14:21:32 [nigel]
- Pierre: The next two are #227 and #228 which have been merged but the tickets are open
- 14:21:37 [nigel]
- .. until we get confirmation from ARIB.
- 14:21:48 [nigel]
- Nigel: Thierry we sent the message to ARIB didn't we?
- 14:21:51 [nigel]
- Thierry: Yes we did.
- 14:22:06 [nigel]
- .. We gave them until the end of June.
- 14:22:23 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/235 imsc1-all.xsd has a bad pointer for SMPTE-TT schemas #235
- 14:23:03 [nigel]
- Pierre: There was a message to the reflector 4 minutes ago. SMPTE has somehow found
- 14:23:23 [nigel]
- .. the XSD and sent us a link. So I'll pull that and make sure that the IMSC 1 links point to it.
- 14:25:17 [nigel]
- Nigel: Is this something we need to fix by erratum to IMSC1 as well as including in 1.0.1?
- 14:25:25 [nigel]
- Pierre: Yes
- 14:25:41 [nigel]
- Mike: I thought we were just going to do WG Consensus to update the schemas.
- 14:25:48 [nigel]
- Nigel: Oh yes it is not normative, thanks for the reminder.
- 14:27:39 [nigel]
- Mike: I think you can just add it to the existing schema.
- 14:27:52 [nigel]
- Nigel: I've added a comment on it with a link to the archived liaison at https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-tt/2017Jun/0084.html
- 14:28:02 [nigel]
- Pierre: I will update this and work with Thierry to get it published.
- 14:28:23 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/243 Recommended character sets considered harmful #243
- 14:28:34 [nigel]
- Pierre: I think this is just a misunderstanding and Addison never followed up.
- 14:30:10 [nigel]
- .. The last comment was by me 19 days ago and Addison didn't respond.
- 14:31:16 [nigel]
- Nigel: I've pinged him on the issue. I think if there's no update on this by Monday
- 14:31:30 [nigel]
- .. morning US time then we could reasonably close this with no further action.
- 14:32:24 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/imsc/issues/236 Should the character sets be minimum *font* requirements? #236
- 14:32:39 [nigel]
- Pierre: This started as a comment on the character sets being minimum font requirements.
- 14:33:03 [nigel]
- .. The thread went a little bit everywhere. In IMSC 1 the recommended character set is
- 14:33:20 [nigel]
- .. stated as an authoring requirement rather than a processing requirement. Then we
- 14:33:35 [nigel]
- .. explored why we have reference fonts, why we have recommended character sets, and
- 14:34:03 [nigel]
- .. I think I tried to answer all r12a's questions and haven't heard back from him. I haven't
- 14:34:50 [nigel]
- .. seen that anything is broken. I've tried to answer all the questions.
- 14:34:58 [nigel]
- Nigel: Is it also related to pull request #245?
- 14:35:02 [nigel]
- Pierre: Maybe, I don't know.
- 14:36:29 [nigel]
- Nigel: I think you've answered the original question in the issue.
- 14:39:26 [nigel]
- .. I've added a comment on the issue, pinging r12a and asking for a response by Monday
- 14:39:40 [nigel]
- .. in anticipation of closing the issue by next week's meeting.
- 14:40:33 [nigel]
- Nigel: Ok so where are we in terms of publishing this as a CR?
- 14:40:40 [nigel]
- Pierre: Next week is a good target.
- 14:41:15 [nigel]
- Nigel: Yes, if we can, or if not then the following week.
- 14:42:09 [nigel]
- Thierry: How do you plan this CR publication? We need to have a Director call, I need to
- 14:42:20 [nigel]
- .. write the transition request for this call, and we need also to have the DIsposition of
- 14:42:31 [nigel]
- .. Comments, which I have been tracking in a wiki page. So we have 2 comments that are
- 14:42:52 [nigel]
- .. still pending, on #236 and #243 because they are from external groups. We could have
- 14:43:02 [nigel]
- .. tried to avoid the Director's call but because we have an objection from Glenn about
- 14:44:19 [nigel]
- .. the version number we should discuss this while entering into CR.
- 14:46:29 [nigel]
- Nigel: I'm happy to simply take that to the Director and be transparent about the
- 14:46:42 [nigel]
- .. group's decision and its rationale and Glenn's objection.
- 14:47:01 [nigel]
- .. Can I check: if the Director hypothetically said we must call this v1.1 would anyone
- 14:47:09 [nigel]
- .. want me to bring that back for the group to consider?
- 14:47:18 [nigel]
- Pierre: Yes, I would object to publishing with v1.1.
- 14:47:30 [nigel]
- Thierry: This objection needs to be included in the transition request.
- 14:47:44 [nigel]
- Nigel: We need so we need some wording to go in the transition request.
- 14:48:27 [nigel]
- .. Does anyone else want to draft that wording about the objection, otherwise I'll do it?
- 14:48:33 [nigel]
- group: [nobody]
- 14:48:45 [nigel]
- Nigel: Okay then I will draft the objection text and circulate it for review.
- 14:48:52 [nigel]
- Thierry: When can we have a CR-ready draft?
- 14:49:03 [nigel]
- Pierre: Monday, assuming no changes are needed.
- 14:49:21 [nigel]
- Thierry: We need a CR ending date. Maybe target 1 month - say 6th August?
- 14:49:28 [nigel]
- Pierre: Alright.
- 14:49:32 [nigel]
- Nigel: 6th August should work.
- 14:49:36 [nigel]
- Pierre: Noted.
- 14:50:33 [nigel]
- Nigel: I note that for the objection text there are people on this call who would be interested
- 14:50:46 [nigel]
- .. in reviewing it but also we should get Glenn's approval on that wording too.
- 14:51:11 [nigel]
- Nigel: I will also double check with Glenn that his objection still stands.
- 14:52:43 [nigel]
- Thierry: Then we have a Director's call to arrange - next week will be difficult with the W3C team
- 14:52:54 [nigel]
- .. because it is geek week but we can try.
- 14:53:28 [nigel]
- Nigel: Given we haven't made the resolution to publish yet, it is more likely going to be
- 14:53:32 [nigel]
- .. the following week isn't it?
- 14:53:37 [nigel]
- Thierry: Okay, I think that's better.
- 14:54:12 [nigel]
- .. I will check his availability so we can pencil in a meeting early to mid the week after next.
- 14:54:32 [nigel]
- .. I will propose some different slots and see what works for everybody.
- 14:54:43 [nigel]
- Nigel: Typically we would have me as Chair, Thierry and Pierre on the call.
- 14:55:22 [nigel]
- Thierry: I guess this current time is good for everyone, as a rule?
- 14:55:27 [nigel]
- Pierre: Yes in general
- 14:55:35 [nigel]
- Nigel: And for me too, depending the particular day.
- 14:57:34 [nigel]
- Topic: TTML
- 14:57:42 [nigel]
- Nigel: Dae you said there were some issues to review?
- 14:57:57 [nigel]
- Dae: Yes, the 2 on IMSC we already covered and the 7 open i18n-comment ones for which
- 14:58:31 [nigel]
- .. we are awaiting feedback from Richard and/or Addison.
- 14:59:41 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/ttml2/issues/271 Metadata examples do not include xml:lang (editorial) #271
- 15:00:03 [nigel]
- Nigel: The last comment here was 28 days ago and Glenn asked Addison for his confirmation
- 15:00:08 [nigel]
- .. that the fix works for him.
- 15:00:45 [nigel]
- Nigel: I think for these and the IMSC issues I will send a private message to Addison
- 15:01:14 [nigel]
- Nigel: and Richard just asking them to confirm the issues work for them or proposing
- 15:01:18 [nigel]
- .. something different.
- 15:01:32 [nigel]
- Pierre: We need to work live with them, we don't have time to iterate over a 2 week period
- 15:01:34 [nigel]
- .. for these.
- 15:01:37 [nigel]
- Nigel: yes.
- 15:03:22 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/ttml2/issues/274 Add an illustration of pinyin for ruby align #274
- 15:03:34 [nigel]
- Dae: There was some back and forth on this, and we ended up saying an illustration might
- 15:04:26 [nigel]
- .. be all that is needed. I could do it, but it might still take a while for Richard to respond.
- 15:04:42 [nigel]
- -> https://github.com/w3c/ttml2/issues/258 How to space base characters where shiftRuby kicks in for group ruby? #258
- 15:07:31 [nigel]
- Mike: [question about process and how much time people have to respond]
- 15:07:44 [nigel]
- Nigel: I will mention to Richard and Addison that we plan to publish TTML2 by end of June
- 15:08:02 [nigel]
- .. so any responses would ideally be received by then, otherwise they will have to get
- 15:08:06 [nigel]
- .. dealt with before we move to CR.
- 15:08:32 [nigel]
- Nigel: On #258 you are suggesting we can close the issue with no more change.
- 15:08:46 [nigel]
- Dae: Right, I think Richard is suggesting fine grained control for Japanese that no subtitler
- 15:08:54 [nigel]
- .. would ever use, so it is not needed for subtitling.
- 15:09:33 [nigel]
- Nigel: OK I will send that message, and I think that's all we can do for now on the i18n issues.
- 15:10:19 [nigel]
- .. Now last week we made a decision to merge the PRs so there would be an ED for review
- 15:10:34 [nigel]
- .. and since then there is one new pull request for audio feature designators, and I've asked
- 15:10:38 [nigel]
- .. for a missing bit to be added.
- 15:11:16 [nigel]
- .. The idea is that everyone should review the ED prior to publishing the WD by next week's meeting.
- 15:11:21 [nigel]
- .. Are there any comments on that?
- 15:11:28 [nigel]
- group: [silence]
- 15:14:20 [nigel]
- Nigel: Okay then I think we can close for today, since there are no more points on our agenda.
- 15:14:26 [nigel]
- .. Thanks everyone. [adjourns meeting]
- 15:14:45 [nigel]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 15:14:45 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/06/22-tt-minutes.html nigel
- 15:18:40 [nigel]
- s/publishing with v1.1/publishing as v1.1
- 15:19:31 [nigel]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 15:19:31 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/06/22-tt-minutes.html nigel
- 15:25:53 [nigel]
- ScribeOptions: -final -noEmbedDiagnostics
- 15:25:54 [nigel]
- rrsagent, make minutes
- 15:25:54 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/06/22-tt-minutes.html nigel
- 16:22:58 [Zakim]
- Zakim has left #tt