13:32:33 RRSAgent has joined #dxwg 13:32:33 logging to http://www.w3.org/2017/05/18-dxwg-irc 13:32:41 Zakim has joined #dxwg 13:32:49 RRSAgent, make logs public 13:33:14 agenda: https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/wiki/Kick_Off_Meeting 13:33:23 chair: Karen, Caroline 13:34:05 hi,phil. i see you've started the bots. 13:43:10 DaveB has joined #dxwg 13:49:03 colleen has joined #dxwg 13:49:36 Ruben has joined #dxwg 13:50:13 present_fanieli has joined #dxwg 13:50:23 RubenVerborgh has joined #dxwg 13:50:42 present+colleen 13:50:57 present+ RubenVerborgh 13:51:51 Do we need a password to join the WebEx? 13:55:23 alejandra has joined #dxwg 13:55:37 KateRoberts has joined #dxwg 13:56:59 AndreaPerego has joined #dxwg 13:57:10 MJ_Han has joined #dxwg 13:58:29 ByronCinNZ has joined #dxwg 13:58:33 SimonCox has joined #dxwg 13:58:46 chile has joined #dxwg 13:58:47 Hello all 13:58:54 Hi, everyone. 13:58:56 May I ask what is the Webex meeting password? 13:59:08 present+MJ_Han 13:59:22 newton has joined #dxwg 13:59:41 Caroline_ has joined #DXWG 13:59:41 thank you! 14:00:04 Hello! 14:00:42 RiccardoAlbertoni has joined #DXWG 14:00:48 present+ SimonCox 14:00:55 Present+ Caroline_ 14:01:01 present+ newton 14:01:06 LarsG has joined #dxwg 14:01:14 present+ 14:01:17 PWinstanley has joined #dxwg 14:01:21 present+ ByronCinNZ 14:01:28 RiccardoAlbertoni has joined #DXWG 14:01:48 ericstephan has joined #dxwg 14:02:10 present+ PWinstanley 14:02:18 Jacco has joined #dxwg 14:02:54 present+ ericstephan 14:03:17 present+ chile 14:03:29 Hi Phil, I know I have issues connecting 14:04:03 Martin_B has joined #dxwg 14:04:03 scribe: phila 14:04:06 scribeNick: phila 14:04:12 Topic: Introductions 14:04:18 present+ alejandra 14:04:20 kcoyle: Let's get started... 14:04:24 present+ AndreaPerego 14:04:25 mdaquin has joined #dxwg 14:04:46 kcoyle: This is the DXWG. Looks like folks are all on IRC and WebEx - you need to be on both 14:04:56 present+ RiccardoAlbertoni 14:05:04 present+ Jacco 14:05:21 achille_z has joined #dxwg 14:05:44 kcoyle: The WG has 3 main deliverables (from charter) 14:05:46 Jaroslav_Pullmann has joined #dxwg 14:05:58 present Jaroslav_Pullmann 14:06:01 kcoyle: Timeline is ca. 2 years 14:06:35 ... Note that the last 4-6 months is taken up by a lot of process requirements, so we're looking at getting the bulk of the work done by the end of 2018 14:06:42 present+ mdaquin 14:06:47 annette_g has joined #dxwg 14:06:57 nandana_ has joined #dxwg 14:07:14 kcoyle: With 3 separate deliverables... we can break into subgroups, we can work in one group. 14:07:21 ... Expect to meet for an hour a week 14:07:30 ... We'll discuss timing shortly 14:07:46 present+ Achille_Zappa 14:07:47 kcoyle: Introduces self. From DCMI 14:07:56 Caroline_: Introduces self 14:08:32 Makx has joined #dxwg 14:09:34 kcoyle and Caroline are the Chairs 14:09:37 phila: Introduces self 14:09:43 phila is the W3C team contact 14:10:30 achille_z: Introduces self from INSIGHT Centre, Galway. 14:10:51 ... Interested in the DCAT part - INSIGHT is what was DERI which is where DCAT came from originally. 14:11:24 alejandra: Introduces self, Uni Oxford, eResearch Centre. 14:11:48 ... Interested in all deliverables. Looking at DCAT. We've been looking at NIH funded portal and more 14:12:12 AndreaPerego: Introduces self, from European Commission's JRC 14:12:29 ... author of geoDCAT-AP 14:12:39 ... aspects of metadata interop across domains interest me 14:13:00 ... And use of DCAT for research data. We run the corporate catalogue at JRC 14:13:39 annette_g: Introduces from LLB. Interested in profile aspects. work for national energy sci community 14:13:54 ByronCinNZ: Introduces self from Internal Affairs in NZ 14:14:00 s/LLB/LBNL 14:14:11 ... Also interestec in conneg by profile 14:14:25 note it is 02:15 for Byron right now 14:14:50 chile: Is actually Markus Friedberg from Uni Leipzig 14:15:12 colleen: From research data service at uni Illinois 14:15:34 DaveB: Introduces self from Thomson Reuters 14:15:48 ... Mostly interested in DCAT and profile handling 14:16:08 ... number of initiatives focussing on content ecosystems and how they might work in automated ways. 14:16:43 ericstephan: Introduces self from PNNL. Interested in DCAT, also scientific realm, seeing where APs can go 14:16:58 Jacco: From CWI in Amsterdam 14:17:09 ... Interested in research data management 14:17:49 Jaroslav_Pullmann: Jaroslav_Pullmann and Christian Mader from Fraunhofer. Both involved in Industrial Data Space project. Extension of DCAT towards dynamic distribution patterns 14:18:06 ... Lots of interests 14:18:22 DaveB: pleased to hear all that 14:18:45 LarsG: From DNB. Interested in all 3. The profile negotiation which is what I'm here to work on. 14:19:09 Makx? 14:19:36 maybe type something, Makx? 14:20:34 Makx: Independent consultant. Working in metadata throughout career, including DCMI 14:20:46 ... Been involved in APs since we coined the term way back 14:21:11 ... Was a member of the WG that worked in DCAT and DWBP. Also I'm editor of the EC's DCAT-AP and more 14:21:26 Martin_B: From Eccenca 14:21:46 ... Worked with Markus at Uni Leipzig on Data ID. Interetsed in implementing this in our work. 14:22:02 mathieu: From INSIGHT Centre in Galway (with Achille) 14:22:17 ... Interetsed in extending DCAT for data consumers, relations between datasets etc. 14:22:27 ... Have done work in education and smart cities. 14:22:42 MJ_Han: From Illinois. Interested in 2nd deliverable 14:23:17 present+ Martin_B 14:23:47 presnet+ annette_g 14:23:59 present+ nandana_ 14:24:12 present+ annette_g 14:24:14 I hear people refer to three deliverables, but there are four deliverables at https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/wiki/Main_Page 14:24:33 nandana_: From Uni Pol Madrid. Working Data quality and description 14:25:08 newton: Works with Caroline_ at Nic.br. Worked on DWBP with many folks here. Interestec in conneg 14:25:44 Ixcell: At UCLC. Study what people need to know for dataset assessment 14:25:51 ... Newly joined member so it's all new 14:25:59 present+ 14:26:07 KateRoberts has joined #dxwg 14:26:27 PWinstanley: From Scottish Gov, based in Glasgow. Interested in the 3 deliverables. 14:26:49 ... Made early assessment of DCAT a while back. Have written guides on it. Was a member of DWBP and Share-PSI project 14:27:39 For deliverables: https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/charter#deliverables 14:27:50 OK, I see thare are three deliverables at https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/charter, yes. 14:27:59 RiccardoAlbertoni: Researcher in CNR Italy 14:28:32 ... Interested especially in data and linkset quality. Was a member of the DWBP and was a co-editor of the data quality vocab. Interetsed in all 3 deliverables 14:28:59 RubenVerborgh: From Ghent Uni. 14:29:12 ... Interest in low level tech - how clients and servers can agree 14:29:23 ... So mostly working on the 3rd part with Lars 14:29:24 present__fanieli has joined #dxwg 14:29:48 SimonCox: With CSIRO. It's 00:30 Friday for me 14:29:55 s/Ghent Uni./Ghent University – imec/ 14:30:34 ... Works in Land and Water on Environmental data, working for years in data description. Especially interested in scope of DCAT, potential around data lifecycle etc. 14:31:51 No problem! 14:32:13 KateRoberts: At BOM. Background in metadata, libraries etc. 14:32:49 RRSAgent, draft minutes v2 14:32:49 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/05/18-dxwg-minutes.html phila 14:32:57 Topic: Use Cases 14:33:14 kcoyle: WGs always start with use cases. We need use cases 14:33:33 ... it's advised that these UCs be real, something you're doing or attempting to do 14:33:43 ... We have set up a wiki page 14:33:49 https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/wiki/Use_Case_Working_Space 14:34:32 ... Need to know who you are, if it pertains to specific deliverables. Links to documents and projects are good. And what requirements arise from these. 14:34:47 ... The UCs will be discussed by the WG and accepted or not 14:34:56 ... And a Use Case document will be part of our deliverables 14:35:19 ... This means that we need one or more editors for the Use Cases and Requirements Document (UCR) 14:35:29 ... Make sense of the UCs, do the formatting etc. 14:35:44 ... There are people here who have expereince of how this works - help is at hand 14:35:59 ... It would be good if we could have a volunteer early 14:36:27 ... The UCR doc is one of the easier editing jobs you can havea in a WG. If you don't expect to be an editor in one of the primary docs, this is a good one to do. 14:36:38 ... Please let us know, post to the list etc. 14:36:47 q+ 14:36:54 ... It would be good to have a good body of use cases before the next meeting 14:37:04 ... It sounds as if people already have quite a bit to say 14:37:05 q+ 14:37:10 ack Caroline_ 14:37:27 Caroline_: Just to add - some people are new, so if you are an editor, it doesn't mean you can't also edit anotehr doc 14:37:49 kcoyle: We won't stop you doing more worl 14:37:49 ack phila 14:39:04 RRSAgent, draft minutes v2 14:39:04 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/05/18-dxwg-minutes.html phila 14:39:21 to get into the queue type q+ 14:39:36 phila: IRC is very important :) 14:39:39 alejandra_ has joined #dxwg 14:39:58 Jaroslav_Pullmann: What is the gathering process. Edit the wiki? 14:40:06 kcoyle: Yes, please just add to the wiki page 14:40:07 q+ 14:40:23 kcoyle: That wiki page is a draft area 14:40:30 q+ 14:40:33 q+ to make a very quick comment about the iki 14:40:37 question: can we all edit the wiki page? 14:40:41 s/worl/work/ 14:40:49 Caroline_: 2 things - the wiki page is editable by everyone in the WG 14:40:51 q- 14:41:14 present+ DaveBrowning 14:41:26 Caroline_: Also, Karen and I will always post the agenda for each meeting at least 24 hours ahead of the meeting. You can always send us agenda items 14:41:31 ? 14:41:32 ack c 14:41:50 ack ann 14:42:06 annette_g: Should we try and focus use cases towards specific tasks 14:42:27 newton has joined #dxwg 14:42:32 kcoyle: I wish I could answer that definitively. I think most UCs might tend towards one task, but it may pertain to all three. 14:42:48 q? 14:43:12 Topic: Regular meeting slot 14:43:25 kcoyle: We have had a discussion about this on e-mail. 14:43:38 q+ to propose a simple Doodle 14:43:42 ... Simon you wanted to make a case for a meeting time? 14:44:11 SimonCox: I think Andrea also supported ... with such a distribution, it's hard to get a time that suits everyone 14:44:18 +1 14:44:22 (California to New Zealand) 14:45:01 SimonCox: If people in Europe are willing to work in the evening (before midnight), Australisia can get up earlier 14:45:09 ack RubenVerborgh 14:45:09 RubenVerborgh, you wanted to propose a simple Doodle 14:45:13 ... I suggest 20:00 UTC is probably the only choice 14:45:21 https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/meetingtime.html?iso=20170518&p1=264&p2=152&p3=157&p4=136&p5=263&p6=64&p7=224 14:45:25 q+ to make a suggestion 14:45:26 RubenVerborgh: Why don't we do a big Doodle 14:45:38 kcoyle: I assume we'll do another Doodle 14:45:50 q? 14:45:51 can someone send a link to documentation for IRC , please? 14:45:56 q+ 14:46:05 ack annette_g 14:46:05 annette_g, you wanted to make a suggestion 14:46:07 Don't like alternating :-( 14:46:15 ack annette_g 14:46:15 I wwas going to propose alternate times 14:46:16 Lose momentum, no predictability 14:46:27 also, if we split into subgroups, might not be too much of a problem? 14:46:28 q+ 14:46:34 so maybe good to discuss that early on? 14:46:38 q+ 14:46:41 q+ 14:46:45 I just created a use case. Is that the way to do it? 14:46:48 ? 14:46:50 https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/wiki/Use_Case_Working_Space 14:47:07 ack er 14:47:19 ericstephan: I was just going to agree with Annette on alternating times 14:47:45 ericstephan: The concern is that it splits the group 14:47:53 Same concern here. 14:47:56 ack Caroline_ 14:48:23 q? 14:48:42 Caroline_: I think Eric said something important and I was going to say something similar. We can meet at 2 different times, 20:00 UTC is one of the times, anotehr s the one we have met today 14:48:52 ... Then it's important that we decide the dates already 14:49:06 ... Maybe next week we meet at 20:00 UTC and then back to this time 14:49:17 ... But we need to have a regular pattern so people can plan. 14:49:19 ack SimonCox 14:49:20 ack SimonCox 14:49:40 SimonCox: I will say that alternating times are bad. It always splits the group. 14:50:21 SimonCox: I think it's likely that we'll split into multiple parallel groups anda then the possibility is that the sub groups will find it easier to schedule meetings 14:50:30 phila: +1 to Simon 14:50:32 q+ 14:50:45 +1 to SimonCox 14:50:52 I don't have a problems with 2000UTC 14:50:55 q- 14:51:13 +1 to I don't have a problems with 2000UTC 14:51:23 kcoyle: We haven't talked about how we'll organise ourselves but as Simon says, it's likely we'll have sub groups. 14:51:51 q? 14:52:00 kcoyle: Any more questions on the use cases? 14:52:27 Jaroslav_Pullmann: Who is the contact to get the UCs consistent 14:52:44 q+ to add the importance of always writing to the mailing list 14:52:59 kcoyle: The WG really does need to agree to the UCs 14:53:02 Re questions: best if all mail goes to group email reflector - transparency, record-keeping 14:53:05 q+ to talk about ReSpec adn GH 14:53:24 q? 14:53:32 +1 to Caroline_ 14:53:43 Jaroslav_Pullmann: What I saw with other groups, was the need to cluster the use cases - to make UCs comparable and to be able to elaborate 14:53:54 q+ 14:53:55 kcoyle: That's what the editor(s) will do 14:54:02 ack Caroline_ 14:54:02 Caroline_, you wanted to add the importance of always writing to the mailing list 14:54:03 ack c 14:54:17 Caroline_: It is important to always communicate via the mailing list 14:54:51 ... This might be frightening for some people - it was for me at first - but it's the only way to keep the conversation going and people involved 14:54:52 q- later 14:55:06 ack s 14:55:34 SimonCox: I presume the assumption is that wew'll be using the Issue tracker and Actions? 14:55:57 Added 2 use cases as well. 14:56:00 ... But I'll note that we've got tangled up with GH Issues. Sme issues are in both places, some only in one. 14:56:00 s/wew'll/we'll/ 14:56:08 ... I think the WWG needs to establish a plan 14:56:21 kcoyle: Yes, we'll need to decide which to use. 14:56:31 q? 14:56:40 ack phila 14:56:40 phila, you wanted to talk about ReSpec adn GH 14:56:56 s/Sme issues/Some issues/ 14:57:37 You can link commit/pull request to issue by including "Closes #37" in the commit message's extended info. 14:57:56 q+ to ask what the advantage of the actions tracker is 14:58:50 alejandra has joined #dxwg 14:59:16 ack RubenVerborgh 14:59:16 RubenVerborgh, you wanted to ask what the advantage of the actions tracker is 14:59:48 phila: Github doesn't have an action tracker the same way IRC has 15:00:43 kcoyle: Thanks everyone for joining today. We will resolve the issue of the call timing ASAP. And we'll post a mail about the UCs very soon. 15:00:50 bye see you next week 15:00:52 Thanks, and bye! 15:00:52 bye 15:00:56 bye all! 15:00:58 bye 15:00:59 RRSAgent, draft minytes v2 15:00:59 I'm logging. I don't understand 'draft minytes v2', phila. Try /msg RRSAgent help 15:01:00 bye bye! 15:01:01 RubenVerborgh has left #dxwg 15:01:02 colleen has left #dxwg 15:01:05 bye 15:01:06 Bye! 15:01:16 RRSAgent, draft minutes v2 15:01:16 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2017/05/18-dxwg-minutes.html phila 15:01:48 phil, do you want to talk me through editing the minutes? or some other itme? 15:03:17 newton has joined #dxwg 15:04:45 annette_g has left #dxwg 15:11:28 trackbot, bye 15:11:28 trackbot has left #dxwg 15:11:40 trackbot has joined #dxwg 15:11:55 issue-1? 15:11:55 Sorry, but no Tracker is associated with this channel. 15:22:17 action: phila to make this work 15:22:17 Sorry, but no Tracker is associated with this channel. 15:27:23 Jean-Gui has joined #dxwg 15:27:29 trackbot, status 15:28:03 action: phila to make this work 15:28:04 Created ACTION-1 - Make this work [on Phil Archer - due 2017-05-25]. 15:40:04 newton has joined #dxwg 15:41:17 close action-1 15:41:17 Closed action-1. 15:42:45 Jean-Gui has left #dxwg 16:05:19 newton_ has joined #dxwg 16:31:24 newton has joined #dxwg 17:00:54 newton has joined #dxwg 17:04:32 Zakim has left #dxwg 17:09:18 newton has joined #dxwg 17:10:07 newton_ has joined #dxwg 17:10:53 newton has joined #dxwg 17:13:39 newton_ has joined #dxwg 17:14:29 newton has joined #dxwg 17:15:16 newton has joined #dxwg 17:16:09 newton_ has joined #dxwg 17:16:56 newton has joined #dxwg 17:17:57 newton_ has joined #dxwg 17:38:44 newton has joined #dxwg 17:51:25 newton has joined #dxwg 17:56:30 newton has joined #dxwg 18:00:14 newton has joined #dxwg 18:02:36 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:09:10 newton has joined #dxwg 18:10:12 newton has joined #dxwg 18:11:02 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:15:56 newton has joined #dxwg 18:16:49 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:17:42 newton has joined #dxwg 18:19:53 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:21:11 newton has joined #dxwg 18:24:21 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:25:17 newton has joined #dxwg 18:26:21 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:27:09 newton has joined #dxwg 18:28:07 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:29:04 newton has joined #dxwg 18:37:04 newton has joined #dxwg 18:38:53 newton has joined #dxwg 18:40:21 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:42:39 newton has joined #dxwg 18:43:52 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:44:39 newton has joined #dxwg 18:45:49 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:46:52 newton has joined #dxwg 18:48:41 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:49:27 newton has joined #dxwg 18:50:16 newton_ has joined #dxwg 18:56:34 newton has joined #dxwg 19:10:05 newton has joined #dxwg 19:18:53 newton has joined #dxwg 19:24:42 newton has joined #dxwg 19:30:41 newton has joined #dxwg 19:31:43 newton_ has joined #dxwg 19:39:09 newton has joined #dxwg 19:56:56 newton has joined #dxwg 20:00:39 newton has joined #dxwg 20:49:02 newton has joined #dxwg 20:51:18 newton has joined #dxwg