17:02:10 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #DPUB
17:02:10 <RRSAgent> logging to http://www.w3.org/2016/06/24-DPUB-irc
17:02:59 <tzviya> present+
17:03:18 <clapierre1> present+ Charles_LaPierre
17:03:30 <clapierre1> present+ George_Kerscher
17:04:24 <clapierre1> Topic: Use cases for PWP
17:04:26 <clapierre1> http://w3c.github.io/dpub-pwp-ucr/
17:04:46 <clapierre1> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lTC9nQoAcjDnvRN46ud4ToiycX_PcB3YuRVhYMbbyck/edit#heading=h.2h76hdxptv1i
17:07:16 <tzviya> https://www.w3.org/annotation/wiki/Use_Cases
17:07:21 <clapierre1> Tzviya: we need to add more robustness to these
17:08:23 <tzviya> you can edit here: https://github.com/w3c/dpub-pwp-ucr/blob/gh-pages/index.html
17:08:28 <clapierre1> 9.1 Personalized Experience
17:08:28 <clapierre1> Alice, a dyslexic student, downloads a textbook and proceeds to personalize the material with larger font and different contrast.
17:12:09 <clapierre1> Tzviya: A user wants to adjust a textbook to her specific needs
17:12:32 <clapierre1> …, example 1 a dyslexic user wants to use Dyslexic font
17:12:55 <clapierre1> …, example 2 a user with low vision wants to increase the font size
17:13:09 <clapierre1> …, example 3 a blind user wants the material read to them.
17:14:10 <clapierre1> …, maybe these are separate use cases?
17:14:24 <clapierre1> Deborah: I think these are all separate use cases.
17:16:24 <clapierre1> George: for dyslexic user wants to use a a different font, but separation between words or between lines.  then AT auditorially they would want the words highlighted as they are read.  They may not just to have a single word but my want to highlight separate sentences or lines, chapters etc..
17:16:51 <clapierre1> Tzviya: we dont want to make this an accessible document but more general in nature
17:18:07 <clapierre1> Deborah: this use case is for a user with dyslexia.  But this use case could also work for … a user with low vision, a user with seizures issues etc… this use case could be used for these other host of specific users needs.
17:18:55 <clapierre1> Tzviya: a new Research Questions group and one area is personalization
17:19:06 <clapierre1> George: is that Jason White's new group?
17:19:07 <dkaplan3> Each separate use cases: a dyslexic user; a low vision user; a user with seizures; a user with color blindness; a user with migraines; ... etc. All the user stories.  We certainly don't need to write them all, but we can write narrowly, and reference broadly.
17:19:10 <clapierre1> Tzviya: Yes
17:19:48 <clapierre1> George: trying to extract the uniqueness for portability is hard to do, without repeating all of WCAG
17:21:43 <clapierre1> Deborah: what are we saying which is DPUB has something to add to, or something to say that gives a new light or adds richness to the conversation.  A user with dyslexia wants to change the font.  but sometimes users are using web browsers and are using e-readers.  and EPUB uses web standards but using your kindle and there you want your personalization where is where DPUB has something to add.
17:22:58 <clapierre1> tzviya: personalized reading, even with these are already defined in WCAG, but defining these here is worth doing.  adjustable fonts, contrast, color, size etc….
17:24:07 <clapierre1> Deborah: HTML falls down because they haven't defined them and is re-implemented a thousand times in various JS implementations.
17:25:31 <clapierre1> Tzviya: what we have now is a personalization use case
17:26:30 <clapierre1> …, pick a disability and then we can clarify that this also applies to a host of others.
17:26:54 <clapierre1> …, so deborah pick a disability.
17:27:40 <clapierre1> …, Alice, a dyslexic student, downloads a textbook and proceeds to personalize the material with larger font and different contrast.
17:27:56 <George> A low vision user needs a black background with white text. This provides to the low vision person best view of the text. This also benefits people who want to read in a dark room.
17:27:59 <clapierre1> …, we may want to say that she wants to use a font that serves the dyslexic community
17:29:33 <clapierre1> George:Not sure if this is what you want but could then expand on how this could be.  Night mode,
17:29:56 <clapierre1> Tzviya, good in a dark room not to disrupt the person sleeping beside you.
17:30:53 <clapierre1> …, so stick with the dyslexic user and expand this.  I can write this up and add the PS onto this for other disabilities including but not limited too.
17:31:09 <clapierre1> s/…,/Deborah:
17:31:27 <clapierre1> Tzviya: we need this a draft by sometime in August.
17:31:58 <clapierre1> Tzviya: we need something by July 7th.
17:32:39 <clapierre1> tzviya: we should use this as a guide on how to write the use-cases
17:33:25 <clapierre1> scribe: clapierre1
17:34:06 <clapierre1> Next Use Case
17:34:08 <clapierre1> 9.2 Adding Alternative Media
17:34:08 <clapierre1> As a publisher of accessible content, I need to add content such as a braille style sheet, image descriptions, or video captioning (text / descriptive audio) to a PWP previously published by a third party.
17:34:22 <clapierre1> Tzviya: I dont think we need the last phrase
17:34:39 <clapierre1> Charles: is this media overlays?
17:35:14 <clapierre1> Tzviya: no, ie Bookshare making content available
17:35:29 <clapierre1> …, multiple versions like braille as well as HTML
17:36:13 <clapierre1> …, that is one use case
17:36:32 <clapierre1> …, is Braille added to a PWP the same way it would be added to the web?
17:37:03 <clapierre1> George: the only time if it is preformatted Braille, 99.9% of time is that it is done on the fly.
17:39:05 <clapierre1> …, you could use 64bit unicode that show the dot patterns.  APH might, or library of congress.  No one else will read them but they are optimized for a particular group of people. 6dot/8dot / computer braille
17:40:47 <clapierre1> charles: wouldn't we do the same in a pwp with a web.
17:41:53 <clapierre1> Tzviya: is the use case we need to sync with braille?  I am trying to see where this fits the Portable or Publication.  or does the web not really support Braille.  Maybe we need to ask someone else
17:42:05 <clapierre1> George: Lloyd, Jason, or Keith
17:43:21 <clapierre1> …, the publication can be transformed into Braille by the user but that is just taking the text and sending to the device which does the transformation.  If someone wanted to publish in a Braille performed braile then it would be a separate rendition
17:43:37 <clapierre1> Tzviya: a PWP must be transformed into Braille.
17:43:47 <clapierre1> …, since Braille is not a web format.
17:44:07 <clapierre1> Deborah: Braille is not a web format in the same way that letters are not
17:44:15 <clapierre1> George: its a font.
17:44:39 <clapierre1> George: you can't deliver it as an image.
17:45:34 <clapierre1> Deborah: its not just that… do cleaver things with unicode, or transpose things .  it must be content meaningful in Braille.
17:45:35 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
17:47:59 <clapierre1> George: with 64 char. you are limited and there are escape codes that you have infront of it. where abcde are the same as 12345 but has an additional escape char ahead of it.
17:48:51 <clapierre1> …, Publisher of braille must be able to have a complete braille rendition
17:49:28 <clapierre1> …, same requirement for Braille as TextToSpeech both are translating it and putting it into something else.
17:50:25 <clapierre1> Tzviya: PWP must be translatable into Braille, and the two statements it must be real text that is translated, and the same real text is used by a Text to Speech engine.
17:51:16 <clapierre1> George if we can get 1 model down like we want the rest will be easier.
17:51:30 <clapierre1> Tzviya: Charles can you add this to the use case then?
17:51:33 <clapierre1> Charles: Yes
17:52:33 <clapierre1> chair: clapierre1
17:52:44 <clapierre1> 	rrsagent, draft minutes
17:52:44 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2016/06/24-DPUB-minutes.html clapierre1
17:53:26 <clapierre1> rrsagent, make logs public
18:32:17 <dauwhe> dauwhe has joined #dpub
18:46:48 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
19:04:15 <darobin> darobin has joined #dpub
19:04:51 <Zakim> Zakim has left #dpub
19:47:39 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
20:11:58 <clapierre> clapierre has joined #DPUB
20:14:30 <clapierre> clapierre has joined #DPUB
20:46:59 <chaals> chaals has joined #dpub
20:48:20 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
20:56:39 <clapierre> clapierre has joined #DPUB
20:58:01 <clapierre> clapierre has joined #DPUB
21:48:55 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
22:49:49 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub
23:50:34 <Florian> Florian has joined #dpub